Feature3 December 2012

Steve Sutcliffe finds out if a dinky Audi A1 quattro can keep pace with the mighty Nissan GT-R

Join the debate

Comments
25

3 December 2012

Such is the dominance of German over Japanese engineering that a modified Audi hatchback can beat a bespoke Nissan sports car.  And just think the Audi is based on a humble Polo.  Just goes to show you the absolute integrity and quality of every VW vehicle!

3 December 2012

It makes me laugh that quite a few of the GTR fanboys are jumping on this one because it seems to me that the purpose of the test was to demonstrate that all cars no matter how great have their shortcomings. Shortcomings that may be familiar to some, being as our roads are quite narrow in places and it rains quite a lot here. I suspect most people do not live on a billiard-table smooth racing circuit where it rains once a year.

I recall being a passenger being driven quickly by someone quite well known for tuning GTRs. We weren't in a GTR at the time but another Japanese four wheel drive high power machine. "This is faster than a GTR down here" he said. "They're heavy and sometimes quite unwieldy, especially in these conditions" was the conclusion.

4 December 2012

Some of you should lighten up.  It's entertainment.  Not everything has to be a PHD by geeks with tape measures.  Reminds me of the Top Gear stunt in which an M3 followed a maxed-out Prius on a circuit and used less fuel - great stuff!

IAD

4 December 2012

I agree 275not599. It's only entertainment and it's not to be taken seriously as a proper road test.  Just an entertaining demonstration of basic laws of physics.  Reminds me of the Top Gear 'fastest car around their track' and how much faster the V8 Atom is around corners compared to a much more powerful but heavier and infinitely more expensive car like the Bugatti Veyron.  If it was with something more comparable like the R8 with the same tyres, the Nissan will probably run rings around it. 

Anyway I wouldn't care if a bloody VW Beetle was faster around UK roads in wet conditions.  I still rather have a GTR or Ferrari or any of the numerous number of supercars out there, any day.

4 December 2012

@IAD

I am all in for entertainments but if I were working for Nissan, I wouldn't find this very amusing.. Would you?

For a change, I would like to see a Nano Tata out run an Audi R8 in Nürburgring. -How about that for a proper entertainment?

IAD

4 December 2012

@rocketscience.

Why would the guys at Nissan be threating over this? You're assuming that they are thinking that any right minded person with a lot of money looking to buy a supercar will be put of by this and buy a Audi A1 Quattro instead?

4 December 2012

@IAD

I am not saying that Nissan guys will feel threatened but please try to understand this;

It is all about publicity- GTR for Nissan is a technical showcase, the ultimate of what they can do.  Now, imagine when this supposedly a technical (four wheel drive / electronic control) masterpiece gets over 5 seconds slower lap time than some German hot hatch driven by some entertainment seeking journalist clowns...

Publicity wise, the only clear winner here is the VW group and it is certainly not helping Nissan. 

 

4 December 2012

@rocketscience

That you take a simple and very effective demonstration about the laws of physics (it isn't rocket science is it?) and extrapolate into some sort of conspiracy to poke at Nissan says a lot about you...

ANY sub 1200kg AWD hot hatch would get the same result (although kudos to Audi for a AWD system clearly coping better with the conditions than that of the GTR).  And let me see, there are SOOOOO many candidates to choose from aren't there???

Lighten up

5 December 2012

But no need to give me physics lession as I had enough of it trying to get my degree in engineering back in the early 90s.

B.T.W, this weight issue is all relative. I have seen many previous GT-Rs leaving smaller and much lighter cars such as Caterhams, hot hatches and Sub-WRX at stand still on wet racing tracks.

4 December 2012

I love the design on Nissan GT-R perfect for agent hypothécaire montréal whose getting  courtiers hypothécaires loans.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Car review
    27 February 2015
    The second pure Mercedes-AMG model is a triumph of engineering and design, and should have rivals from Porsche and Audi worried
  • First Drive
    27 February 2015
    Dual motors and a power hike give Tesla's electric family car supercar acceleration - and the rest of the package is as strong as ever
  • Car review
    26 February 2015
    Flagship performance C-Class is more than ever a true rival for BMW's M3, and impresses with both its breadth of ability and its practicality
  • First Drive
    26 February 2015
    The new Renault Megane GT 220 is essentially a toned-down version of the hallowed Renaultsport 275, but does it have the required DNA?
  • First Drive
    20 February 2015
    Remember Mercedes' 6x6 monster off-roader? Well, this is the 4x4 version, and we've driven it.

Latest videos