Can the i8 plug-in hybrid, the most sophisticated BMW ever, make Porsche's 911 feel outdated?
31 May 2014

You might have already read our first drive verdict on the BMW i8 and think you know what direction this test is set to take: the Porsche 911 walks it. 

However, the i8 is one of the most advanced road cars ever: carbonfibre construction, plug-in hybrid driveline, myriad drive modes, the capability to run in either zero-emissions electric front-wheel drive or petrol-electric four-wheel drive, two gearboxes… the list goes on. It is the most sophisticated car ever to wear a BMW badge.

Next to it, the Porsche appears rather conventional. You wouldn’t call it old-fashioned, even if the 50th Anniversary Edition example driven here plays up its heritage with some throwback stylistic elements, but its mechanical package is nowhere near as contemporary as the i8’s. It is essentially a Carrera S with the wide body of the Carrera 4 and 20-inch wheels that evoke Porsche’s classic Fuchs rims.

At 4689mm long, 1942mm wide and 1293mm high, the i8 has the proportions of a mid-engined car, which it is – at least as far as its petrol engine is concerned. But it is the layered surfaces within the body and the flowing shapes that form the integral rear wing that set it apart. Its design goes further than pure visual appeal, though. It represents the advanced technology that has gone into both this new BMW and the more affordable all-electric i3.

The Porsche is 199mm shorter, 132mm narrower and 7mm taller than the BMW, but still has a pleasing appearance almost two years after this latest incarnation arrived.

The i8 features a lightweight carbonfibre-reinforced plastic body and is underpinned by a chassis made almost exclusively from aluminium. But unlike the boxy i3, the new i8 has a plug-in hybrid drivetrain consisting of both a conventional petrol engine and a pair of electric motors.

BMW says the i8 weighs 1485kg, which is impressive given that there’s 200kg of lithium ion batteries running down the centre of the cabin. The aluminium-bodied Porsche tips the scales at 1430kg in PDK form.

Getting into the i8 isn’t easy. It requires a good deal of gymnastic dexterity to fold yourself between the lower edge of the scissor door and the substantial slab of carbonfibre sill. The 911, on the other hand, is a cinch to enter. Its conventional doors, relatively narrow sill and generous door openings are part of its enduring everyday appeal.

Swing your legs down into the i8’s footwell and you’ll find an interior that’s every bit as new world as the exterior, with deeply dished seats, a futuristic dashboard and a heavily sculptured fascia. And the Porsche? Its cabin lacks the sheer modernity of the i8, but there is nevertheless a satisfying completeness to it despite myriad buttons and switches.

When it comes to packaging, there is little to separate the two. Each provides seating for up to four, although the rear seats in both are really for emergency use only. As for luggage capacity, the i8 comes out ahead. The 154 litres under its glass liftback-style tailgate is 19 litres more than offered by the 911.

All up, the i8 boasts a combined 357bhp at 5800rpm and 420lb ft at 3700rpm. Just how much of this is available at any given time is dependent on the state of charge of the batteries and the drive mode that is chosen: Eco Pro, Comfort or Sport. Alternatively, you can select E-mode although it is only available when the batteries have enough charge.

Eco Pro and Comfort are entirely suitable for urban driving or cruising at a steady clip. Provided that the batteries are sufficiently charged, the electric motor within the front axle is automatically engaged. With 128bhp at 4800rpm and 184lb ft the moment that your foot brushes the throttle, it provides the i8 with zero-emissions front-drive running for limited distances up to an 80mph top speed.

Read our first drive review of the BMW i8 plug-in hybrid sports car.

The turbocharged 1.5-litre, three-cylinder petrol engine mounted at the rear engages when you give the throttle a decent nudge or when the energy in the batteries is depleted to a preset level. The engine is a more highly tuned version of the unit first unveiled in the new Mini Cooper. 

It boasts the highest specific output of any current BMW engine, with 228bhp at 5800rpm and 236lb ft at 3700rpm – all channelled through a six-speed automatic gearbox to the rear wheels, essentially giving the i8 part-time four-wheel drive.

A second electric motor, mounted at the rear, acts as a generator to integrate the operation of the combustion engine with the front electric motor. There’s a brief interruption as the three-cylinder unit springs to life and begins to send power to the rear wheels, but it does not impede progress in any great way.

With the petrol engine and two electric motors working together in either Eco Pro or Comfort mode, the i8 feels powerful, but not explosively so. Peg the throttle at a standstill and the driveline delivers the sort of performance that you’d expect of a turbocharged six-cylinder engine, albeit allied to an odd, synthesised three-cylinder thrum.

The Porsche’s driveline lacks the complexity of the BMW’s, but it is not shamed for power. The 911’s naturally aspirated 3.8-litre flat six engine, mounted behind the rear axle, nominally delivers 395bhp at 7400rpm. Our test car is a US-spec model, though, and receives a power kit as standard, upping it to 424bhp.

It can’t match the BMW’s torque, though. With 325lb ft at 5600rpm, it gives away a considerable 95lb ft. In standard guise, it’s all sent through a seven-speed manual gearbox to the rear wheels, but our test car has the optional seven-speed PDK dual-clutch auto with better standing start qualities and superb shift quality.

Read our comparison of the Porsche 911 Turbo S and the Jaguar F-type R coupé.

The initial impression is that the i8 offers a very different driving experience from any traditional BMW sports car. There is an uncharacteristic lightness to the controls and a faint whine from the electric motor under load but, for the most part, the impression is of outstanding mechanical refinement. 

The electric motor drives through a two-speed automatic gearbox, providing instantaneous responses and the sort of standing start acceleration to allow the i8 to challenge a well sorted hot hatchback away from the traffic lights in electric mode.

Drive it in isolation over a flowing back road without too many tightening second-gear corners and you may never doubt the dynamic ability of the i8. The steering is precise, if a little light, while turn-in is urgent and it happily accepts increasing lateral forces without awkward body movements. 

With its electric motor and combustion engine channelling their combined reserves to all four wheels, there is plenty of traction and the brakes are powerful, albeit lacking in ultimate pedal feel. And besides some annoying patter at the front over pockmarked surfaces, the ride is quite compliant for a car of such sporting pretensions.

And boy, does it go when you put your foot down on the exit of a bend. On smooth roads, it is capable of keeping the rear-engined 911 honest, which speaks volumes for the effectiveness of its high-tech driveline. The Porsche has nothing like the same amount of low to mid-range torque; nor does it possess anywhere near the initial accelerative force out of corners.

But the 911 is not gutless. Above 4000rpm, its naturally aspirated engine provides prodigious shove. But by then, the i8 has already benefited from its initial spurt of electric propulsion and is away down the road. BMW claims 0-62mph in 4.4sec, compared with 4.5sec for the Porsche. However, a constant, linear surge of energy right from the outset makes the i8 feel considerably faster.

Read Autocar's full road test review of the Porsche 911.

The i8 would appear to tick the boxes that buyers of modern-day sports cars are likely to demand, but not if engagement and driving entertainment are your priorities. Seek out the final degree of dynamic finesse and you’ll discover one central weakness: a lack of front-end grip.

The new i8 rolls on 20-inch wheels, albeit only 7.0 inches wide at the front and 7.5 inches at the rear. They are shod with 195/50 tyres up front and 215/45s at the back and, with their limited contact patches, they lack for sheer purchase. The result? Early breakaway as you enter second-gear corners, followed by incessant understeer on a loaded throttle. As a result, the blinking yellow stability control system light is a constant companion on winding roads.

By contrast, the fluidity of the 911 is almost enough to seal this contest in one. It is so pure and involving that it makes the i8 feel stifled and artificial. The Porsche displays a lovely balance that prompts you to keep pushing at the sort of cornering speeds that begin to trouble the BMW, and there is a compelling completeness to the whole car, even as you approach the limits.

The Porsche’s steering is one of the best electro-mechanical systems fitted to any current production sports car. It is deliciously involving and perfectly weighted, and far more engaging than the light and over-servoed rack of the BMW.

And then there’s the rest of the 911’s absorbing dynamic character: its superb body control at any speed, the outright grip it generates, the terrific poise when loaded through a quick corner, the traction on the way out, the well-controlled ride and the way that its electronic driver aids allow you to dabble in a spot of tail-out action. Even if you put the i8 on its optional wider and stickier tyres, I still doubt that it could match the 911.

So the Porsche takes the dynamic contest – and by quite a margin. The tacit handling of the Carrera S is intoxicating on the right road. 

However, the BMW is not disgraced. The i8 is one of the most intriguing sports cars to challenge the establishment in a very long time, and it is a clear winner in an urban environment, where its ability to run in electric mode and strong low-end torque make it wonderfully refined and amazingly frugal.

In the end, you can make a strong case for owning either one of these cars. If you’re an enthusiast and treasure driving, choose the 911. The Porsche is clearly more entertaining on a back road and the better sports car. 

But if you’re keen on the futuristic appearance and are more obsessed with technology than dynamic appeal, go with the i8. The BMW’s blend of coolness and complexity makes it a compelling statement. Think of it as the world’s most accomplished urban sports car.

BMW i8

Price £94,845 (including government grant); 0-62mph 4.4sec; Top speed 155mph; Economy 135mpg (combined); CO2 49g/km; Kerb weight 1485kg; Engine 3 cyls in line, 1499cc, turbo, plus electric motor; Power 357bhp at 5800rpm; Torque 420lb ft at 3700rpm; Gearbox 6-spd auto (petrol), 2-spd auto (electric)

Porsche 911 50th Anniversary Edition PDK

Price £103,251; 0-62mph 4.2sec; Top speed 187mph; Economy 32.5mpg (combined); CO2 205g/km; Kerb weight 1430kg; Engine 6 cyls horizontally opposed, 3800cc, twin-turbo, petrol; Power 424bhp at 7500rpm; Torque 325lb ft at 5750rpm; Gearbox 7-spd dual clutch automatic

Our Verdict

Porsche 911

The Porsche 911 is a sublime all-purpose sports car

Join the debate

Comments
11

1 June 2014
I'm usually a 911 cynic, but for me, it's without doubt the one to have.

1 June 2014
I've only ever seen the i8 in the silver / black colour combination. It'd look a lot better with a conventional finish such as black or dark blue.

1 June 2014
Good article. It'd be interesting to see if BMW do a sharper version of the i8, an 'i8 M' if you will.

1 June 2014
The i8 comes across as a really advanced appliance, does the job, but in a clinical/cold kind of way. It's Porsche all the way for me.

1 June 2014
I am sorry but there are far too many things we are not told about the i8,how long will the battery last,miles,how much is a new one,electric motors there are quite a few,life span?cost of new one.Miles the petrol engine will do on a tank full?. How long will it take to recharge the battery?, I could go on but will not. For me this so called test is a right cock up,mess and a few other words. Me thinks some one needs to learn how to do their job!!!!!!!!!.

1 June 2014
Looking at the photos, it struck me how good the Porsche looks. It has a simplicity that really appeals. I know people criticise Porsche for their same again styling, but the constant refinement has produced a very good looking car. The i8 isn't ugly car, but both inside and out it feels like it is trying too hard. As for range and reliability, what happens when the batteries in the i8 run out of juice, say when you're on a track day? Are you left with simply a 228hp supercar?

1 June 2014
Despite the puerile folly of comparing two immensely different type of cars, I must say that it's a well written article. Is it not like comparing VW XL1 with the Toyota GT86? Although funnily despite all the high tech the i8 costs less! Crucially it weighs the same! It's almost up there with the conventional 911 in all driving matters. That is impressive.

2 June 2014
Note to 911 owners. When dicing with an i8, exit corner at 4000rpm, not 2000. This isn't rocket science.

2 June 2014
Although I appreciate Porsche 911 for what it is and what it has achieved over the years, I cannot be more happy that someone tried it a little different this time. Dynamic superiority aside, I frankly think the BMW i8 stretches the envelope of the idea of a car as of today than anything else... For that single aspect alone it will command respect and admiration from a generation/audience that is used to the prowess of the 911 or any other car from that segment. Good Luck BMW!

2 June 2014
An interesting comparison but the real question is when will BMW's "i" technology filter down into something more affordable and practical but still great to look at and good to drive? The i8 costs almost £100K. Yes it is it cutting edge technology both in the drivetrain and construction of the car but at that price level apart from the usual suspects such as American celebs (wanting "green" credibility) or a few very rich "early adopters" who will buy it? The only other i Division product the i3 is a box on wheels and hardly sleek. It also uses a very different type of drivetrain not intended for performance or pleasure (despite BMWs marketing guff). So when BMW can come up with a what I will call the i4 - four seats, 250+ bhp,a practical boot and sleek coupe looks for around £40K then I may be tempted. Until then as long as BMW continues to pedal rough 4 cylinder diesel rep mobiles for around that price point I will look elsewhere.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week