From £8,9752

On the face of it, the Proton Gen-2 is an appealing prospect. For the price of a Ford Fiesta, you get a Focus-sized hatchback with handsome, if dated styling.

Available as a hatchback and a saloon, the later is offered with an LPG tank fitted in the boot -one of very few new cars available with the cost-saving setup. LPG fell out of favour with other manufacturers when government subsidies dried up, but the rising cost of fuel could see it make a comeback. Putting the LPG powertrain aside, the Gen-2 is less sound as a Focus rival.

The interior is several generations behind the class leaders, with low-rent plastics and dated design. The impressive equipment levels fails to compensate for this fully. The dated feel translates on the road too. Uncomfortable driving position, joins cumbersome steering and suspension with limited ability hampers appeal for drivers quickly.

Proton says the ride and handling have been developed by Lotus, but little of its excellence in chassis work is evident. The 1.6-litre engine develops 110bhp, but feels strained at speed. The saloon will reach 62mph in a leisurely 12sec, six tenths before the hatchback version.

Specifying an automatic gearbox hampers performance further, with the time increasing to 14.3 and 13.6sec for the saloon and hatch respectively. A 1.3-litre engine is also available, but little is promised from the slow-selling 94bhp unit.

The LPG system - where fitted - is executed well. It fits in the spare wheel well, and only reduces boot depth by about three inches. It does, however rob a small amount of throttle response, but if you're in the market for a Gen-2, this isn't likely to cause much of a problem. Given the low sticker price, equipment levels are pretty good, with all derivatives coming with twin front airbags, electric front window, air-con and alloy wheels.

But you'd have to be really keen to have the cachet of a new car on your drive to choose a Proton Gen-2 over a year-old Focus, which will offer a nicer drive, better interior and improved residual values. Aside from its value, there's very little to recommend the Gen-2.

Interior quality on later models is improved, but it's still way short of mainstream Focus-segment standards. The less said about the utterly wooden ride, handling, and steering the better.

Top 5 Family hatchbacks

  • More than 29 million Golfs have been sold since 1974

    Volkswagen Golf

  • The standout component of the Ford Focus has always been its handling

    Ford Focus

  • Leon
    Seat offers five engines for the Leon, ranging from a 104bhp 1.2 petrol to a 181bhp 2.0 diesel

    Seat Leon

  • Mazda 3
    The SkyActiv platform used in the 3 features more high and ultra-high-strength steel, offering greater strength and less weight

    Mazda 3

  • Peugeot 308
    The 308 marks the first time a carry-over name has been applied to an all-new Peugeot

    Peugeot 308


First drives

Find an Autocar car review

Explore the Proton range

Driven this week

  • First Drive
    25 November 2015
    More powerful Clubsport version of Volkswagen's iconic hot hatch proves thoroughly entertaining on our track-only first drive in Portugal
  • First Drive
    25 November 2015
    Suzuki has added an automatic diesel powertrain to its S-Cross crossover line-up. Does it offer a compelling choice over the manual versions?
  • First Drive
    24 November 2015
    Alpina’s D3 saloon and estate benefit from the latest BMW 3 Series updates. We've always loved it, but is it still as beguiling as ever in this latest form?
  • First Drive
    24 November 2015
    Our first UK drive shows that few supercars offer as rounded a package as Audi's new R8. It isn't the last word dynamically but it still has a lot to offer
  • First Drive
    20 November 2015
    A new 1.8 turbo petrol engine and manual gearbox make the Ibiza Cupra a more satisfyingly brutish, hands-on hot hatch, but it's still not the best of its breed