Ford Focus RS or Renault Clio Cup - which is the ultimate hot hatch?

Ford Focus RS or Renault Clio Cup - which is the ultimate hot hatch? To find out Autocar tested them back-to-back.

The Focus RS500 is billed as the ultimate expression of a hot hatch. But has it gone too far? With 345 bhp and a price tag up with a BMW 335i or a base spec Porsche Cayman has this extremely talented but insane hatchback forgotten its roots?

See the exclusive Ford Focus RS versus Renault Clio Cup picturesSee the cars in action on video

At £35,750, up £7,855 over the ‘standard’ RS, the RS500 has an extra 45bhp, a shade more torque, a matt black vinyl wrap and a few interior details. It also comes with the hugely evocative RS500 name, last used on the whale tailed Sierra Cosworth.

The Clio Cup musters a naturally aspirated 197bhp and 156lb ft of torque from its 2.0-litre four pot motor. Its price of £16,710, under half of the Ford, asks a lot of questions of the menacing Focus.

The RS500 has the answer in third gear. In its lowest two ratios, the Focus’s torque is limited to the same levels as in the standard RS to protect the gearbox and improve traction. But when you slot third, you enter a different world – one dominated by induction gasps and the sort of acceleration the Clio can’t live with.

Your view - the best hot hatch ever poll

It is also a world that features a fair amount of torque steer, even with its trick Revo-knuckle suspension. On a dry straight road you have to hold the wheel quite tight, but it seems a reasonable trade-off for the performance available.

Find a section of road that’s quiet enough and the Focus feels brutally rapid. Just as we found with the regular RS, the RS500 has a playfulness to its chassis that is downright amusing. Turn in, lift off and the nose tucks in nicely without any real risk of misadventure, then get back on the power.It’s the classic front wheel drive recipe, but honed for maximum enjoyment.

Swap into the Clio and it can feel underwhelming. With the poorer ride and an artificial feel to its steering, the only obvious advantage is its lightness: at 1204kg, it carries 263kg less than the Ford. But it is from this lack of mass, and a closely stacked set of ratios, that everything else grows.

See the exclusive Ford Focus RS versus Renault Clio Cup pictures

Although its outright pace will still be less than the RS500, between the wave of gearchanges, frenzy of revs and a surprisingly useful upshift buzzer, the sense of pace is at times greater in the Clio.

But it is into braking zones and corners that the Clio’s lack of weight pays dividends. The steering, brakes and lack of body roll the car gives you a sense of freedom that encourages a little more entry speed and a little more throttle.

This means you arrive at the end of a fast drive wired and exhilarated, exactly the point of a hot hatch.

But the fact remains the Focus RS500 will always be going slightly quicker. To find out how much quicker, we visited the Bedford Aerodrome for a few laps free from the moral (and legal) restrictions of the road.

See the exclusive Ford Focus RS versus Renault Clio Cup pictures

Up to a point, the Focus proves an entertaining track car, with good front-end bite and plenty of adjustability in the chassis. However, at the limit the movement in the rear axle that makes the RS500 such a fun road car robs time around a lap.

The RS500’s brakes also lack modulation and it is difficult to carry speed into a corner without tripping into messy oversteer. The result is a one-shot lap time of 2min 12sec.

The Clio is at a disadvantage on the circuit’s straights, but the fact is you can brake later and turn in with more speed than in the Ford. At first your cornering speed is limited by front end grip, but persevere with more speed and it can be persuaded into the sweet spot between understeer and oversteer, giving a lap of 2min 15.5secs – very close considering the power deficit.

Where does this leave the Focus? Well, it remains a hugely exciting car, with refinement and space the Clio can’t match.

But a hot hatch should be about simple ingredients and a balance of abilities not dominated by any single component. Having 345bhp is great for a time, but using every last one of the Clio’s 197bhp is simply more fun.

I’m not saying there shouldn’t be more or less powerful or expensive hot hatches out there, but I reckon the Clio Cup defines better than any other where the centre of gravity for the hot hatch should be.

The full test review is available in this week's Autocar magazine, on sale now.

See the exclusive Ford Focus RS versus Renault Clio Cup pictures

Jamie Corstorphine

See all the latest Ford Focus reviews, news and videoSee all the latest Renault Clio reviews, news and video

Our Verdict

Ford Focus 2011-2014
A big seller is the 113bhp 1.6-litre diesel in Zetec trim.

Can the Ford Focus capture the hearts and minds of hatchback buyers?

Join the debate

Comments
29

25 June 2010

yes.

and i expect an ibiza cupra will be even faster, being 32kgs lighter than the clio, and with DSG to make it even more fun.

i think the megane 250 RS cup, would easily beat the RS500. as would an audi S3/golf R/sirocco R/leon cupra R etc.

anyway other brands aside, what it makes me think is that i would rather have a focus ST (£22,895) with 221bhp as standard. and spend the £12,895 saved on making it lighter and better handling and steering.

it would end up being a faster car than the RS500, and much cheaper on mpg and wear and tear on the mechanicals.

25 June 2010

[quote beachland2]anyway other brands aside, what it makes me think is that i would rather have a focus ST (£22,895) with 221bhp as standard. and spend the £12,895 saved on making it lighter and better handling and steering.
[/quote]

Couldn't agree more. There comes a point where power - and more tellingly torque levels in a front drive car actually detract from it's enjoyment. Alfasud Ti, Peugeot 205 and 306. Not much power but lots of fun!

25 June 2010

two cars that would find completely different homes regardless of the peformance stats

having sat in a clio recently i couldnt wait to get out, plastic tacky rubbish.

25 June 2010

The Focus RS is an excellent car as is the Clio cup but competition with the Clio is not really representative, the only things they have in common are 4 wheels apart from that they will appeal to totally different demographics.

25 June 2010

It's been said already...Autocar is comparing uncomparable. Those two cars have nothing in common

Besides look at the Focus and then look at the Clio, god there is a difference, Clio is just so much uglier, the interior feels like 20 years old and the exterior simply can't match.

In my opinion Focus is one of the hottest cars there are, and for this reason only, having been lucky getting on the waiting list, I wouldn't hesitate a second and buy one

25 June 2010

the only thing thats hot about the focus are its front tyres after trying to maintain forward momentum.

i'm no fan of clio quality either.

25 June 2010

Anyone else wondering why Autocar are reviewing a car that was sold out 12 hours before it went on sale?

25 June 2010

to say that you are suggesting they are reviewing some red cotton stitching and a tacky interior plate. the rest of the car is Focus RS which is on sale and the upgrade kit which is on sale aswell which gives the 345bhp. that is what they are reviewing really.

25 June 2010

[quote beachland2]

the only thing thats hot about the focus are its front tyres after trying to maintain forward momentum.

i'm no fan of clio quality either.

[/quote]

This coming from the person who recently posted how he destroys a set of front tyres every 3000 miles in a Lupo...

25 June 2010

not through lack of grip though, the tyres have perfect traction and control, thats why i bought them. that is their natural wear rate for a soft compound tyre. i have 130bhp going throught the front wheels on a sub 900kgs car. the focus is what 1400kgs? putting 300 to 345bhp through the front tyres....which dont provide enough traction when power is swiftly sent to them. i have no such problems.


Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Car review
    23 September 2016
    Aston kicks off its ‘second century plan’ with an all-new turbo V12 grand tourer
  • Ford Ka+ 1.2 Ti-VCT 85
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    A rounded, refined and well-sorted bargain supermini – once you’re used to the confusing role redefinition imposed on the once-cheeky Ka
  •  Maserati Ghibli Diesel
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    Maserati releases another range of updates for its range best seller, the Ghibli. We've driven the diesel version, but there's little improvement on before
  • Tipo Front
    First Drive
    21 September 2016
    New Fiat Tipo offers impressive space and practicality for a reasonable price. We try the 1.6 diesel on the demanding roads of North Wales
  • Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150
    First Drive
    20 September 2016
    The Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150 makes perfect sense: it's spacious, tidy to drive for an SUV and cheap to run