From £14,444
Doesn't feel new enough to challenge the MX-5

Our Verdict

MG TF
The MG TF was the model that marked the brand's comeback

The MG TF is undeniably flawed, but it is an appealing driver’s car nonetheless

26 August 2008

What is it?

This is the reborn MG TF, fresh from MG’s Chinese owner, assembled at the Longbridge factory from parts largely sourced from China and featuring the lightest of makeovers.

The revisions consist of a new front bumper and grille assembly, a modernised main instrument pack, an engine that’s been cleaned up to meet Euro4 emissions and modified in (yet another) quest to cure this lightweight motor of its infamously weak headgasket.

Improved hood sealing is said to reduce water leaks, another sporadic MGF/TF problem, and parking sensors are now an option.

Those radar sensors are standard on this introductory LE500 model, which comes with the bulk of the options MG Rover used to offer on the TF for more than £6000 less than they would have cost at the time. 

Don’t think that you’ll be driving a car of huge sophistication as a result, though.

Three years ago, when MG Rover went under, air conditioning was an option, as was the LE’s hardtop, leather trim, metallic paint and a bundle of other cosmetic features.

There’s an expensive stereo – an aftermarket Pioneer, whose absurdly small buttons must be the reason for providing a remote control unit in one of the smallest cockpits on the market today – the pedals are alloy and many of the decorative interior mouldings that were once silver are now piano black.

What’s it like?

If you’ve ever sat in a TF, or an MGF, this interior will seem very familiar, right down to a wheel that can only be adjusted for rake, those sunvisors extended by flimsy-looking flaps and the fake allen bolts around the gear lever.

Much of the interior looks old – which it is – and even cheaper than it did when new, partly because that was so long ago.

Still, the new instrument pack – apparently under development at MG Rover when it went down – looks good.

It includes an orange bar graph temperature gauge and even a gearlever change-up light, though the strained sounds emerging from behind your back during the final 500rpm assault to the 7000rpm limiter makes this fairly unnecessary. The absent sixth gear would be useful.

Not a promising start, then. Yet it’s hard not to enjoy actually driving the TF. With only 133bhp it’s not terribly brisk, especially for a sports car. It’s also confined inside and far from quiet. But it’s fun.

The engine, now redubbed ‘N’ Series, sounds eager - even if the only way it will torch asphalt is by self-immolating - the gearlever can be shifted with more accuracy than its rubbery movements suggest, and this compact little car darts about with the kind of zeal that goads you into pushing it harder.

The electric power steering, among the very earliest of the breed, offers more feel than plenty of modern set-ups, and you also get plenty of feedback through the (cheaply) leathered seat.

This latest TF runs the softer standard suspension of the previous MG Rover edition (a good decision; the old sport set-up was far too firm) but the car rides on the bigger, lower-profile 16in rims, producing a compromise set-up that generally works well.

On some potholes the suspension clatter slightly, but most of the time this car rides with a suppleness that has you wondering whether its still suspended with the MGF’s Hydragas spheres.

But it’s not, and the steel suspension’s occasionally less absorptive capabilities can be exposed on a bucking B-road.

Push the TF hard and it understeers, and without kicking out its engine-heavy tail if you lift off. It’s good, safe stuff from a potentially treacherous mid-engined layout that does without the protections of ESP.

The keen will wish the tail kicked with more ease, but this disappointment does little to prevent this car being a surprisingly satisfying, if somewhat crude, steer down an English country lane, where its lack of bulk is a major advantage.

Should I buy one?

Unless you’re a completist MG collector, probably not. And certainly not with a price tag that puts it into contention with a Mazda MX-5 one generation on from the model extant when the TF fell into hibernation.

Eager demeanour and amusing handling apart, this MG has a lot less going for it now other than the curiosity of driving a car that has been reincarnated.

Its prospects might be improved if the mainstream model is significantly cheaper; a base price of £12,500 would suddenly make it very attractive.

Longbridge will need to improve quality too. The pre-production car we drove had an abysmally fitted passenger door, paint flaking from the front bumper, a rear tonneau cover that part-snapped free at 85mph, carpet quality of the kind you used to find in base Metros and possibly the nastiest key (inherited from the old F) supplied with any new car on sale today.

Join the debate

Comments
27

28 August 2008

Far far too expensive!

As suggested in the article, if this car was pitched at around the £12000 mark (and even then I would require a discount) then it may find buyers.

A missed opportunity.

 

 

It's all about the twisties........

28 August 2008

I agree too expensive but a warm welcome on my behalf back to the market.

28 August 2008

Kind of nice to see it back though I just can't see them making a go of it. It's an old design and bringing back a car almsot untouched from the 90s doesn't strike me as a recipe for success. Will it really find enough buyers, and I reckon owners are going to have to be pretty understanding as I can see reliability and depreciation being issues. Hope to be proved wrong though.

28 August 2008

I suspect owners of the previous generation TF will be a little ticked off, especially if re-introduction of this updated model turns out to be a flop (which it sounds like it unfortunately will be). Some things are best laid to rest and remember fondly of.

28 August 2008

  • No, no, no ,no!! Anyone who even contemplates buying this atrocious rubbish at this price needs their head examined.

v8

28 August 2008

It should of been allowed to die

28 August 2008

Trying to work out which was older - the LE500 design or that pin-striped suit (I won't comment on the reporter's shirts!)

28 August 2008

It's just too expensive. With rivals such as the MX-5 around for similar prices, the TF looks a little dated. Yes, it's a classic, but they needed to do more with the design - especially that interior. Let's hope their marketing is good and they try their hardest to shift them. It would be a shame for them to lose it AGAIN, so I hope there is some success here. I also hope MG's 'new raft of models' make more of an effort, and come along soon. I still welcome the little MG back though!

"The creative adult is the child who survived."

28 August 2008

[quote v8]It should of been allowed to die [/quote]

It did die v8, and the LE500 is a lingering ghost that the (non) buying public is about to exorcize.

PaulJ

28 August 2008

I am Ling, the only Chinese new car supplier in the UK. So it is with interest I read about this new old Chinese/British car.

The delay getting this out for sale has been a joke, and the prices seem laughable.

Several journalists I have spoken to say the quality has been terrible and if the parts are now sourced from China, why is it so expensive? Why assemble it in Longbridge? I will explain. Autocar are blinkered, they want to sell magazines in the UK AND China, so criticism would be bad for their sales there.

The Chinese market is hungry for ANY cars it can get, and having a Union Jack on their cars is a selling point (believe it or not, like Clark's shoes and Burberry). The fact the Chinese market cars will be built in China is best ignored and will not be emphasised.To them, this is a new model "British" car! Rule Britannia.

So, aspirational Chinese are the real market. The ones on sale here are to give the veneer of a British car and assembly line, and UK sales are a black hole. Chinese MGs are being sold with Tower Bridge, Big Ben, U2, Beckham and London Eye backdrops.

Pity the UK dealers who will not survive on these tiny sacrificial volumes, and give the British operation a veneer of credibility. Anyone buying the MGTF in the UK must be slightly demented, but then, we are talking about MG owners.

Proof is here, the MG websites in China

http://www.nacmg.com/mgtf070918/ ...and http://www.nacmg.com/range

Take a look!

Wo ai MG - NOT!

Ling

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • 2016 Audi A3 Sportback e-tron UK review
    First Drive
    29 September 2016
    First UK drive finds the facelifted A3 Sportback e-tron remains a first-rate plug-in hybrid that is packed with tech if a little short on driver appeal
  • Citroen C11.2 Puretech 82 Furio
    First Drive
    29 September 2016
    Citroën's city car gets a new sporty-looking trim level, adding visual adornments, but no premium for the 1.2-litre Puretech triple we're driving
  • Mercedes C350e Sport
    First Drive
    28 September 2016
    Petrol-electric C-Class is a surprisingly well-priced alternative to a diesel but not the greatest example of the new ‘PHEV’ breed
  • Car review
    23 September 2016
    Aston kicks off its ‘second century plan’ with an all-new turbo V12 grand tourer
  • Ford Ka+ 1.2 Ti-VCT 85
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    A rounded, refined and well-sorted bargain supermini – once you’re used to the confusing role redefinition imposed on the once-cheeky Ka