To appreciate the original BMW X5's impact on the market, you have only to consider for a moment which other SUVs were available to buy in 1999.

The Land Rover Discovery looked like farming equipment and had all the durability of a falling comet. The Toyota Land Cruiser could brush off a comet strike, but only because it was the size of a continent.

Elsewhere, Mercedes' M-class was still a body-on-frame calamity, and while the Lexus RX wasn't, it drove like it might well have been. Only the Jeep Grand Cherokee had the right image – and that was American.

When BMW's newcomer arrived on the scene, the writing was on the wall. There was no antecedent for the X5. Before the original, E53-generation X5, BMW had shown no interest at all in the market for 4x4 machinery. Then, in 1994, BMW acquired the Rover Group and, with it, Land Rover.

The manufacturer learnt much from its ownership of the troubled British brand by the end of the 1990s. But it was still smart enough to mould its 4x4 in its own image, dubbing the first X5 an SAV – Sports Activity Vehicle – that prioritised on-road manners over off-road ability.

Over two generations, the X5 racked up 1.3 million sales. With this latest version, the F15 generation of the X5, BMW has promised improvements across the board – particularly with a view to improving efficiency – as it plays catch-up to a new breed of Mercedes-Benz M-class, Volkswagen Touareg, Range Rover Sport and Porsche Cayenne.

Has BMW now managed to overtake its newer and much-improved rivals rivals? Our comprehensive test will reveal all.

Top 5 Sports SUVs

  • Porsche Macan
    The new Porsche Macan is offered with a choice of three engines, including a 3.0-litre turbodiesel

    Porsche Macan

    1
  • Alpina XD3 Biturbo
    The XD3 is the first SUV to be developed by Alpina

    Alpina XD3 Biturbo (2011-2014)

    2
  • The Range Rover Evoque Si4 costs from £41,000

    Range Rover Evoque SI4

    3
  • SQ5 is powered by the 309bhp, 479lb ft twin-turbo V6 diesel introduced in the A6

    Audi SQ5

    4
  • The G63 replaces the old supercharged G55 as the most powerful, quickest and most expensive version of the venerable G-class 4x4

    Mercedes-Benz G63 AMG

    5

First drives

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • First Drive
    2 September 2015
    Kia facelifts its Cee'd and drops its six-speed torque converter in favour of a new seven-speed dual-clutch automatic gearbox in the process. We drive it for the first time
  • First Drive
    1 September 2015
    Kia has developed a better-mannered, more sophisticated Sportage for 2016
  • First Drive
    31 August 2015
    Thought the 3 Series was losing its edge? Well it's back, with a facelifted version that offers improved performance and dynamics. Does it reclaim its top spot after our drive on UK roads?
  • First Drive
    27 August 2015
    BMW gives its flagship 7 Series an extensive overhaul in a bid to tempt buyers of luxury cars away from the Mercedes S-Class, Audi's A8 and the Jaguar XJ
  • First Drive
    26 August 2015
    New Qashqai rival majors on practicality and usability and benefits from a long warranty, but lower-specification versions are the better bet