From £55,685
Ingenious, but hard not to see it as an alcoholic brandishing a water bottle, claiming reformation

Our Verdict

Cadillac Escalade
Its hard not to see the Escalade as an alcoholic brandishing a water bottle and claiming reformation

The Cadillac Escalade is one hybrid that doesn't wear its eco credentials on its sleeve

19 October 2010

What is it?

A hybrid version of Cadillac’s biggest beast, the very enormous Escalade. The idea of a hybridised attempt on fuel-saving seems absurd with a giant like this, but the principle is no different from Porsche’s equally contradictory bi-motor Cayenne – and GM got there first.

This is the General’s two-mode hybrid, which mostly operates as a CVT but also has four fixed gears that are used when the Caddy’s a-haulin’. GM claims a 20 per cent improvement in fuel consumption over a standard Escalade – quite a saving given its thirst – but the £6300-odd price difference will mean clocking many miles before savings are made.

Still, given the Escalade’s 2.7 tonnes, it’s easy to see the sense of harnessing its kinetic energy when coasting and braking. The electricity generated is stored in a 300-volt battery stored under the middle row of seats – the Escalade swallows it almost unnoticed – which propels it at low speeds. The Atkinson cycle 332bhp 6.0-litre V8 has auto-stop-start, and can also operate on four cylinders to save fuel.

What’s it like?

Inevitably truck-like, in both low-speed manoeuvring and cornering, though for a vehicle almost as big as a house it gets around bends with less drama than you’d expected. But, this is a tall, ponderous-looking vehicle, and that’s how it feels on the road.

More disappointing than this is the near-ceaseless vibro-massage accorded to your lower legs, presumably the consequence of riding on 22in wheels with 45-section tyres.

Also impossible to ignore are the curious hums and whirrs of the multiple electric motors that not only propel the Cadillac but power the compressor, the brake pump and more, these especially evident when the V8 is switched off.

But the worst refinement issue flaws the brakes, whose transitions between regenerative and hydraulic retardation make it near impossible to bring the Escalade to a smooth stop.

Yet for all its crudities, there’s something fascinating about the way this complex beast goes about its business, and there’s no question that you get a great view out from a vehicle this vast.

Should I buy one?

If you want an Escalade it’s probably only an Escalade that will do, in which case your choice is whether to buy hybrid or not. A part-electric drivetrain certainly makes it more defensible, though many may judge its plentiful ‘hybrid’ badging at best ludicrous, at worst offensive. Plus, the Escalade feels like the gussied up, workaday Chevrolet Tahoe that it is, with an interior finish vastly adrift of any premium SUV’s.

It’s ingenious, but it’s hard not to see the Escalade as an alcoholic brandishing a water bottle and claiming reformation – you can see clear liquid in there, but is it really H2O?

Cadillac Escalade Hybrid Sport Luxury

Price as tested £73,959; 0-62mph 8.4sec; Top speed 106mph; Kerb weight: 2729kg: Combined economy: 25.5mpg; CO2: 264g/km; Powertrain: V8, petrol, 5967cc, plus electric motor; Power: 332bhp at 5100rpm; Torque: 367lb ft at 4100rpm

 

Join the debate

Comments
10

25 October 2010

As Much as I love the Escalades in your face styling, Whats with the price? Are they using a £1=$1 exchange rate?

I think I would have me the standard 6.2L V8!

25 October 2010

With them squared off wheel arches, baseball bat column shifter and centre stack from a 1990 Nissan ZX, the only thing's missing are bull bars and the spare thrown out on to the "tail dooooor". Unbelievable that any sane person would even consider one of these, turd on wheels, as a potential 70k purchase.

25 October 2010

I think the CO2 emissions quoted for the Lexus 450h should be checked again. They are 148g/Km not 246g/Km. I think this is more than marginal defference?

25 October 2010

[quote fhp11]As Much as I love the Escalades in your face styling[/quote]

Are you Rooney in disguise?!

25 October 2010

A 6 litre hybrid???someone is having a laugh!!! only in America of course!!absolutely nuts!!!

25 October 2010

Seriously, who buys these things? You can get any European/Japanese luxury SUV for that money, and even the worst one is light years ahead of this.

26 October 2010

[quote KArkhon]Seriously, who buys these things? You can get any European/Japanese luxury SUV for that money, and even the worst one is light years ahead of this.[/quote]

Gosh it must have taken you a while to test all of them to come up with such a damning verdict. Even then your logic is pretty flawed. How many competitors are there to this?

You want a Luxury Full size SUV with 7 seats...

Range Rover? Only 5 seats

Toyota Land Cruiser? Not really a luxury image, looks boring as sin, and only diesel availible.

I guess the only real competitor would be a Discovery. But even then, this doesnt have a hybrid option. only a much thirsyer petrol engine if you didnt want the diesel. Plus the Escalade is sizably larger than a disco.

I've had a look inside an escalade and its pretty nice, I've never driven one, and Ive no doubt it wouldnt be as dynamically sharp as some others, especially as its based on a truck chassis. But they are comfortable, and if you just want a relaxed drive, I'm sure it does the job just fine. That said, I do think its a bit too expensive. Id have a hard time justifying 70-80K for one.

26 October 2010

Flawed execution maybe...but at least they're trying!


26 October 2010

The definitive face of the worst of the US suv now that they have abandoned the abortion that was the Hummer. Wilfully ugly, grossly over weight a real in your face car, ideal for those who like confrontation and especially if they are in the chemical trade. Although I can imagine these people will give a stuff whether it is a hybrid or not.

28 October 2010

A "Luxury" SUV?????

I sat in one of these at a motor show, and while at first glance it looked high class the facade did not last long. The leather was of a similar quality to that found on a £9 pair of primark shoes, and many of the plastics feel genuinely awful. Everything had a tinny, cheap feel to it, and I'm sure after 10,000 miles would already be showing it's age.

For £70k they are having a laugh.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Car review
    23 September 2016
    Aston kicks off its ‘second century plan’ with an all-new turbo V12 grand tourer
  • Ford Ka+ 1.2 Ti-VCT 85
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    A rounded, refined and well-sorted bargain supermini – once you’re used to the confusing role redefinition imposed on the once-cheeky Ka
  •  Maserati Ghibli Diesel
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    Maserati releases another range of updates for its range best seller, the Ghibli. We've driven the diesel version, but there's little improvement on before
  • Tipo Front
    First Drive
    21 September 2016
    New Fiat Tipo offers impressive space and practicality for a reasonable price. We try the 1.6 diesel on the demanding roads of North Wales
  • Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150
    First Drive
    20 September 2016
    The Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150 makes perfect sense: it's spacious, tidy to drive for an SUV and cheap to run