We know that VW's futuristic hybrid eco-car packs phenomenal efficiency, but does the driving experience match up?

Our Verdict

Volkswagen XL1

New 313mpg hybrid points the way to making cars cheaper to use

  • First Drive

    Volkswagen XL1 first drive review

    We know that VW's futuristic hybrid eco-car packs phenomenal efficiency, but does the driving experience match up?
  • First Drive

    Volkswagen XL1

    Volkswagen's XL1 is a sort of 50th percentile supercar, immaculately surfaced and detailed

What is it?

A hyper-economical carbonfibre and gull-winged two-seater that is the culmination of more than a decade of engineering effort at Volkswagen. This started with Ferdinand Piech’s (now chairman of the VW supervisory board) turn-of-the-century vision of building a production car capable of covering 100km on one litre of fuel, or 282mpg.



The first concept was the 2002 L1, which combined a carbonfibre body, tandem seating, a side-hinged canopy and a single-cylinder, 8bhp, engine. The car weighed just 290kg. The L1 was demonstrated by Piech, who was then VW Group boss, and the company claimed fuel economy of 0.99-litres per 100km, or 238mpg.

The second-generation L1 was shown in Autumn 2009. This featured hybrid transmission combining a two-cylinder diesel engine and an electric motor. 

The problem with making the L1 production-ready was less the uncivilised tandem seating and aircraft-style side-hinged roof canopy and more the issue of it meeting crash test requirements.

Less than two years after the second-generation L1, VW showed the XL1 in the form of a series of driveable prototypes. VW engineers had taken a huge leap with the ‘one-litre’ concept by retaining the two-cylinder hybrid drivetrain but completely rethinking the body design. 


Bringing the story right up to date, the final design is based around a supercar-style carbonfibre reinforced plastic (CFRP) monocoque passenger cell, with the passenger seat staggered behind the driver seat. This clever arrangement reduces the amount of shoulder room needed, allowing the body to be as narrow as possible for aerodynamic reasons. Crash protection front and rear is provided by large extruded aluminium crash boxes and the mid-mounted powertrain is also hung off the rear aluminium subframe. The whole assembly weighs just 230kg.



To make for easier access across the wide sills, the XL1 has large gullwing doors which cut right into the roof. If you end up upside down in the XL1, explosive bolts release the gullwing doors.

The XL1 is 3.88m long, just 1.65m wide and 1.15m tall – which makes it 10cm shorter than a Volkswagen Polo, less than 20mm narrower but nearly 30cm lower.

These dimensions are, of course, at the maximum points. In the flesh, the XL1 looks tiny, not just because it so low, but also because the body tapers away to the classic teardrop shape with the rear wheels enclosed by the body. It has a Cd rating of just 0.189 - surely a world record for a production car.



The front suspension is made up of double wishbones, the rear a ‘semi-trailing link system’. The brake discs are made of lightweight ceramic and the wheels are magnesium. The front wheels are almost motorcycle-slim at 115/80 R15 and the rears 145/55 R 16.



Behind the passenger cell is the two-cylinder hybrid drivetrain. Effectively half of an existing 1.6-litre turbo diesel, tweaked and fitted with a balancer shaft, it develops 50bhp and the electric motor provides 27bhp. Both drive through a seven-speed DSG gearbox. The 5.5kWh lithium-Ion battery pack is mounted in the front of the car, in the void ahead of the passenger’s feet.

The XL1 can run on diesel only, electric only or, in boost mode, a combination of the two. During boost mode the two motors generate a maximum of 68.3bhp and a maximum of 103lb ft of torque. The XL1’s top speed is limited to 99.4mph and it can hit 62mph in 12.7secs.

What's it like?

Exceptional on the motorway and agreeably flawed in town. It takes a bit of effort to get into the XL1, the sills are very wide and the seats very low, but once you’re inside, it is very comfortable indeed. The view ahead is panoramic, while the view directly behind is non-existent because there’s no rear window. The rear-view mirrors have been replaced by what looks like a pair of iPhone screens mounted in the door trims - the XL1 is the first production car in the world to have rear-view cameras in place of conventional mirrors.

 Top marks for the interior design, too. The dash is a model of restrained good taste and quality finish. There's a half decent boot, too. It's hidden in the tail and has room for a couple of large weekend bags.

Twist the key, put the shift lever into ‘D’ and the car hums away on battery power. Straight away you are aware of the different sensations that come from a car built around a carbonfibre monocoque. There’s a slight hollowness and resonance to the sounds transmitted into the cabin. As I accelerated and the – still cold – diesel engine fired up, the noise was alarming, a kind of empty reverberating thrum.



On a straight road the XL1 is very stable and straight-running, with easily enough power to keep up with traffic flow. It is surprisingly comfortable and quiet on decent roads. The steering is accurate and the swiftness and seamlessness of the engine cutting in and out is very impressive - even if it is relatively vocal. Even the smallest incline can be quickly detected by the XL1 and the engine almost instantly spun up to assist the electric motor and battery pack.



In town, the story is slightly less happy. The ride can be a little brittle and the unassisted steering takes some getting used to. It’s quite hard, say, to whip around a mini-roundabout because the steering weights up considerably. The brakes feel a little dead and are also a little noisy, but that’s a consequence of the lightweight ceramic brake discs.

And you have to move around in the seat to try to see properly at junctions: leaning forward to look around the A-pillars can lead to you banging your head on the low windscreen surround. Yes, it takes a little thought to drive around on narrow streets, but the learning curve is likely to be short.



On the motorway, the XL1 is supreme. Despite its tiny footprint and the heavy rain on the Swiss motorway, the XL1 was rock-steady, completely unruffled by passing lorries. It ran very straight and true, requiring virtually no steering corrections. At a steady 62mph, the XL1 requires just 8bhp to make progress – an indication of the car’s remarkably low rolling and air resistance. It also feels entirely happy at 75mph and above, and making brisk overtaking manoeuvres.



On an early test drive this week, which including crossing a mountain range, the most economical drivers achieved a real 188mpg. On a long motorway run, there’s surely potential for 200mpg. Overall, the XL1 is quite an unusual experience, but a very satisfying one for any driver who appreciates the brilliant engineering behind the car.

Should I buy one?

Firstly, there’s no news about the price. VW bosses admitted at the Geneva motor show that they still have no idea how much the company will charge for the 250 production examples that will be made by Karmann. Whatever VW charges, there’s no doubt they’ll make a huge loss on the XL1 project, although that is hardly the point. It is a technological marvel.



And, while VW UK has requested as many as 50 of these left-hand-drive-only cars, there’s no news on how many will arrive here. 

All that said, the XL1 is a true landmark machine that points the way to the future – a future as far as a decade away. The combination of lightweight material, a downsized engine assisted by an electric motor, dramatically better aerodynamic performance and the innovations such as automatic coasting on downhill roads are definitely the future for family cars.



Super-early adopters will adore the XL1 – and the chance to hone their driving skills enough to achieve a real-world 200mpg. 



VW XL1

Price n/a; 0-62mph 12.7sec; Top speed 99.8mph; Economy 313mpg (claimed); CO2 21g/km; Kerbweight 795kg; Engine type in-line two, turbocharged, diesel 800cc and electric motor; Installation rear, transverse; Power 68.3bhp; Torque 103lb ft

Join the debate

Comments
28

6 March 2013

Great to see VW getting serious it's just a shame they picked the heavier diesel option, I'd sacifice a few mpg just to avoid the diesel rattle/ noise and generation of cancer causing chemicals.

Another big plus is when putting your thumb over the in-closed rear wheels it's an extremely good looking car.

Anyhow time to read the next hybrid/electric news story

 

Hydrogen cars just went POP

6 March 2013

Very nice but it be will priced for the wrong crowd (it'll just become a green credential to those that can afford it.)

Come on Mercedes, this is what Smart should be doing. This is smart but way too sombre, VW has the tech but lacks any actual spark (no pun intended).

6 March 2013

In many ways its a reminder of the original Insight. Although that was much less compromised, with normal doors, normal seats, and a decent ride. And whilst Honda limited the production numbers, they were limited to many thousand, not 250. And of course they sold for £17,000 here not the much higher price we are expecting from VW. 

Yet both show how excellent engineering can make an eco car appealing. I applaud VW for making this, and hope they make many more than 250 to satisfy demand, and keep the price to a non supercar level

7 March 2013

You're right about the Insight. The problem was that the tiny car cost Honda about double the £17,000 to build and there were very few customers prepared to pay anywhere near the list price - most were heaviy discounted.  Though respected by the press, the car was seen by potential customers as just an expensive 2-seater with economy little better than a cheaper more practical diesel.

The new XL1 faces similar issues, but it's to VW's credit that the car will be built. And perhaps more importantly that much of its technology will be available in the forthcoming hybrid Up   model.

7 March 2013

You casually slip in about it being the worlds first production car without wing mirrors. This is amazing news, as it changes the way everyday cars look completely, this is front cover news.

You havent explained how the law will be changed in the UK to allow it. Currently the law says a car must have an external rear view mirror.

As soon as people get the details modifiers will be stripping their hot hatches of wing mirrors and fitting cameras to gain higher top speed on their favourite roads.

And of course mainstream car makers will follow suit as it's an obvious way to create economy. This hasnt happened for years due to it being illegal.

 

 

 

 

7 March 2013

supertax wrote:

You casually slip in about it being the worlds first production car without wing mirrors. This is amazing news, as it changes the way everyday cars look completely, this is front cover news.

Agreed, I really wanted to see more of the system in the pictures. 

7 March 2013

Sorry to pop your balloon but anyone who needs reading glasses, and that must be most of us 'over 50s' would not be able to drive safely with a rear view camera; you can't drive with your reading glasses on!

This reminds me of when Nasa boasted of inventing the first ballpoint pen capable of writing upside down or in space in zero gravity. The Russians used pencils.

7 March 2013

supertax wrote:

You casually slip in about it being the worlds first production car without wing mirrors. This is amazing news, as it changes the way everyday cars look completely, this is front cover news.

To be fair, HH wrote:

the XL1 is the first production car in the world to have rear-view cameras in place of conventional mirrors.

Plenty of cars have gone into production without wing mirrors, and plenty without any rear view mirrors at all, though it has been a while.

I know, pedantic.  But nevertheless true.

7 March 2013

@xxxx. You may not be a fan of diesel but all petrol cars produce cancer causing pollution too. 

 

7 March 2013

BenC30 wrote:

@xxxx. You may not be a fan of diesel but all petrol cars produce cancer causing pollution too. 

 

Way less than diesels though, by a high factor.

 

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK