From £12,240
More refined than rapid

Our Verdict

Vauxhall Astra 2009-2015

The Vauxhall Astra is one of the best-looking hatchbacks, but average dynamics and performance hamper its overall appeal

2 March 2004

Unaccountably, it took Ford nearly four years to produce a fast, affordable Focus. Vauxhall’s not about to fall into that trap. Here we are at the launch of the new Astra, driving the 168bhp turbocharged SRi that’s set to go on sale with the cooking models on 1 May. What’s more, there’s a faster 197bhp Turbo to come this summer and the promise of a 220bhp (but possibly 240bhp) superhatch VXR in spring ’05.

Until then, the Turbo will do just fine, thank you. Visually, the new Astra’s a knockout. The distinctive (at least until the new model gains ubiquity) low-slung, wheels-filling-guards looks really grab your attention. Just as well, for the SRi doesn’t bring a lot of extra frills to the party: sports suspension, xenon headlights and fog lights, a few black mouldings and 215/45 rubber on 17-inch wheels.

The test car came on wonderfully spindly 18s – at just £200 for four alloys, certain to be snapped up – to add something extra to what are only minor cosmetic changes. With two harder versions in the pipeline, I suppose the £17,195 SRi can afford to be restrained. Only in profile is the Astra’s excessive front overhang – in part a product of meeting future pedestrian crash requirements – apparent. And on the 18s, the 264mm rear discs look puny between the spokes, an all-too-common problem with today’s apparently inexorable increase in wheel sizes.

Interior performance add-ons follow the usual pattern: leather wheel, sports seats, alloy-look pedals and instrument surrounds, all applied to the Astra’s attractive, solid feeling cabin. The seats are firm, and it takes a moment or two to find all the levers required to adjust seat cushion height and, separately, cushion angle and steering wheel.

There’s no aural excitement here. Vauxhall’s familiar low-pressure (max boost 1.8 bar) 2.0-litre turbo is more about mid-range torque than peaky power or a gutsy exhaust note. It offers 184lb ft between 1950-4000rpm and a maximum 168bhp at 5200rpm. Vauxhall knows the Astra’s 1310kg and 168bhp produces a modest 128bhp per tonne power-to-weight ratio – the £16,850 Ford Focus ST170 gives 141 – and will sell the SRi as a refined, quickish hatchback, rather than a Honda Civic Type-R rival.

Accept this role and the SRi makes sense. The test car, an Opel Turbo – as close as we could get to the real SRi, and not pictured here – also came with GM’s much-vaunted Continuous Damping Control (CDC), a £440 option. No other car in the class offers adaptive damping and, because it’s tied in to numerous other electronic systems, it adjusts damper rates in milliseconds based on the output from a raft of sensors. Push the Sport button and, the engineers claim, stability is improved, pitch and roll decreased, steering weight increased and throttle response heightened.

We’ll ignore Sport for the moment. Helped by an all-new six-speed ’box – the new Astra is the M32’s first application – the drivetrain feels refined, isolating the driver from noise and vibration. The engine’s tractable – happy to pull from 1000rpm in high gears on a light throttle. But you need to keep the crankshaft above 2000rpm for sparkling performance. Boost is clean and linear through a long, flat band of power to a smooth 6000rpm, before the power drops off in an inverse ratio to the increase in engine thrash over the last 500rpm to the red line.

Vauxhall’s 8.4sec to 60mph feels spot on. Not shattering, but strong and usable. Plus, effortless to access, because the gearchange is precise, quick – a real pleasure. Clearly, then, a vast improvement over the 1.6’s recalcitrant shifter that upset our testers last week. The gearing, too, helps establish the SRi’s character. Sixth is so high the driver quickly learns it’s almost exclusively reserved for motorways. Not surprisingly, the 135mph top speed is achieved in fifth, not top. Only excessive wind noise, seemingly from the forward edge of the doors, spoils motorway refinement.

Unless you hit the Sport button. Do so and the ride instantly becomes excessively restless and firm, while the throttle is overly aggressive and introduces unwanted tap-in shunt. Where CDC really works is on stimulating roads.

The default setting is good: handling is near-neutral, safe and yet responsive enough for most buyers. Sport brings a noticeable improvement in body control, so you feel inclined to take advantage of the car’s terrific grip. Roll is reduced and, equally importantly, the onset of any transient body movements and the move to understeer are delayed. Not surprisingly, in Sport the SRi is much happier to be fully extended.

What of the critically important steering? The engineers have quickened the ratio for the SRi, reducing the number of turns from the standard Astra’s 2.7 (not 3.8 as Vauxhall told us last week) to a swift 2.5, and a massive improvement over the old car’s 3.2 turns. Even so, the on-centre slack that seems inherent to most electro-hydraulic systems is much in evidence.

Off-centre the steering is quick and feels precise, the weighting meaty, though there is very little true feel. Perhaps this is to reduce torquesteer to a mere hint of gentle tugging of the wheel, even on slippery surfaces. Is it fun to drive? Up to a point, though the driver never feels totally connected. If (a big if, I know) the upcoming hotties comply, please don’t see this as a criticism.

The ride is less convincing on the optional 225/40 R18 Continentals. Vauxhall has carefully tuned the suspension to suit the character of each model, mostly by varying the angle and wall thickness of the C-shaped torsion beam axle. Suspension noise is low and the ride, while firm, is surprisingly absorbent, especially at low speeds. Still, you feel sharp ridges and irregularities and in Sport it becomes even more fidgety. The point is, don’t consider CDC if you spend all day on motorways.

Peter Robinson

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Lexus LC500
    Car review
    20 October 2017
    Futuristic Lexus LC coupé mixes the latest technology with an old-school atmospheric V8
  • Maserati Levante S GranSport
    First Drive
    20 October 2017
    Get ready to trade in your diesels: Maserati’s luxury SUV finally gets the engine it’s always needed
  • Jaguar XF Sportbrake TDV6
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The handsome Jaguar XF Sportbrake exhibits all the hallmarks that makes the saloon great, and with the silky smooth diesel V6 makes it a compelling choice
  • Volkswagen T-Roc TDI
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    Volkswagen's new compact crossover has the looks, the engineering and the build quality to be a resounding success, but not with this diesel engine
  • BMW M550i
    First Drive
    19 October 2017
    The all-paw M550i is a fast, effortless mile-muncher, but there's a reason why it won't be sold in the UK