From £27,5455
Jeep Cherokee gets a new face and updated safety tech for 2019, but it's hamstrung by an unsettled ride, a coarse engine and a high price

Our Verdict

Jeep Cherokee

Can Italian tech put this once-rugged off-roader ahead of the pack, or is the Cherokee lost in an increasingly large crowd of superior family SUVs?

Simon Davis
10 September 2018

What is it?

The Jeep Cherokee has come a long way since the first-generation SJ model was launched way back in 1974. The fifth-generation version we have here has lost the boxy, all-American image of that original, instead morphing into an SUV that carries very few features indeed to help distinguish it from its competitors in what is now one of the most crowded segments there is - seven-bar grille aside.

For 2018, Jeep has treated the Cherokee to a facelift. Gone is the squinty-eyed front end of the 2014 model; it has been replaced by a far more classically handsome (if a little forgettable) nose. At the same time, a range of new active safety systems and updated infotainment software have been introduced.

For the UK, the sole engine available is likely to be the same 2.2-litre four-cylinder Multijet II diesel from before, offered in a single 192bhp state of tune. This is paired with a nine-speed automatic gearbox that, in our pre-production test car, sent its power to all four wheels.

As before, the Cherokee’s suspension architecture consists of MacPherson struts up front and a multi-link arrangement at the rear.

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

What's it like?

Frankly, it's rather disappointing. In fact, there’s precious little about the manner in which the Cherokee drives that would give any of its rivals any real cause for concern.

The ride, for instance, is almost perpetually choppy and unsettled, with even the smallest imperfection in the road surface causing it to lose nearly all of its composure. Short-wave undulations cause its vertical body control to all but go out the window, while potholes and expansion joints send fairly forceful jolts through the cabin - even at lower speeds. On all but the smoothest roads, the Cherokee doesn’t make for particularly comfortable motoring. That said, on those rare sections of smooth road, the Cherokee does regain some composure, but not enough to make up for its shortcomings elsewhere.

One such shortcoming is its engine. With 192bhp and 332lb ft on tap, the Cherokee feels like it’s capable of hitting its claimed 0-62mph time of 8.8sec, but the manner in which it goes about completing that undertaking isn’t what you’d call calm or refined. The MultiJet II motor is particularly vocal under throttle, while the timbre of its four-cylinder soundtrack is harsh and unrefined - although things do quieten down when you return to a steady cruise. 

Then there’s the nine-speed auto ’box, which is not only slow to respond to your inputs but also indecisive about which of its nine ratios it would prefer to select at any given time. Overtaking manoeuvres, therefore, require a good deal of forethought, because you need to factor in the eternity it seems to take for the gearbox to respond to your right foot hitting the kickdown switch. Opting to use the steering wheel-mounted paddles doesn’t do much to remedy this tardiness, either, because the response times are equally as lethargic.

There is at least a decent amount of weight in the steering, but its low gearing doesn’t lend the Jeep a front end that feels particularly enthusiastic about the idea of changing direction. And when it does turn in, you find you don’t have to be travelling all that quickly to cause understeer to rear its head. Taking sharper corners even at low speeds can lead to fairly vocal protest from the front tyres.

The cabin, meanwhile, doesn’t offer much in the way of practical or material appeal to tempt you out of more mainstream rivals. There’s a good-sized - although far from class-leading - boot that offers 448 litres of cargo capacity, while heated nappa leather seats provide agreeable levels of support and adjustability. However, rear passenger space is tight; taller adults will find that their knees touch the front seatbacks, while the optional panoramic roof severely compromises head room. Soft-touch and scratchy plastics don’t do much to lift the cabin’s ambience, either, and the 8.4in infotainment system just isn’t on the same level as those you’ll find in rivals, despite its upgraded software. Apple CarPlay and Android Auto do come as standard, at least.

Should I buy one?

Speaking of rivals, the Cherokee finds itself in a bit of a tricky position. Jeep says it goes up against the likes of the Hyundai Santa Fe, Kia Sorento and Land Rover Discovery Sport, yet all of those SUVs offer a third row of seats. The Cherokee, on the other hand, does not.

Then there’s the issue of how much it costs. Jeep will offer just two trim levels - Limited and Overland - when the Cherokee goes on sale in the UK next year, and both sit at the plusher end of the range. While UK pricing has yet to be confirmed, we were told that the Limited model - the same as our test car - would be priced at €54,900 in Austria, while a figure of £40,000-£45,000 should be expected for the UK. While its higher default spec does mean it comes generously equipped, its price places it in BMW X3, Volvo XC60 and Audi Q5 territory. Next to those cars, the Cherokee seems out of its depth in terms of not only refinement, dynamic capability and material appeal but also badge desirability.

It’s not economical, showing an indicated 27mpg over the course of our test drive, and if the pre-facelift model is anything to go by, residual forecasts likely won’t be that impressive, either. 

It does come with a full five-star Euro NCAP safety rating, though. But is that enough to make it a recommendable buy? Afraid not.

Jeep Cherokee Limited 2.2 195 4WD

Location Sicily On sale 2019 Price £40,000-£45,000 (est) Engine 4 cyls, 2174cc, diesel Power 192bhp at 3500rpm Torque 332lb ft at 2000rpm Gearbox 9-spd automatic Kerb weight 2106kg Top speed 126mph 0-62mph 8.8sec Economy 42.8mpg (NEDC combined) CO2/tax band 175g/km, 37% Rivals Land Rover Discovery Sport, BMW X3, Audi Q5, Volvo XC60

Join the debate

Comments
20

10 September 2018

This sounds like the worst £40k+ car that Autocar have ever reviewed.  Normally you say try before you buy but the interior shots show all you need to know, under investment!

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

FMS

11 September 2018
xxxx wrote:

This sounds like the worst £40k+ car that Autocar have ever reviewed.  Normally you say try before you buy but the interior shots show all you need to know, under investment!

 

So speaks the Towering Intellect of the Automotive Industry. TwIT

289

10 September 2018

....that JEEP, who after all invented the 4x4, still cant build a decent SUV.....(and never will all the time they hitch their cart to crappy VM engines who have never made a decent engine in their lives), still dont get that they need to up their game with interior quality in a far more competitive SUV market.

The last good JEEP was the XJ Cherokee. Cramped and basic, but a great working tool at a competitive price.

10 September 2018

Not sure about that one

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

289

10 September 2018

I didnt say that they invented 4 wheel drive....merely that they invented THE 4x4 (as we know it).

10 September 2018

Nope, even as I know it JEEP didn't invent the 4 X 4 or 4WD.

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

289

10 September 2018

No?!

Jeep Wagoneer of 1968 not the first of what we now refer to as a SUV?

11 September 2018
289 wrote:

No?!

Jeep Wagoneer of 1968 not the first of what we now refer to as a SUV?

You've gone from "who after all invented the 4x4" to '1968 first SUV'. 4x4 was around well before 1968 

typos1 - Just can’t respect opinion

FMS

11 September 2018
xxxx wrote:

Not sure about that one

 

Then OH TOWERING INTELLECT OF THE AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY, who did then?. Always ready to criticise, never has the (allegedly) correct answer. TwIT

10 September 2018
289 wrote:

....that JEEP, who after all invented the 4x4, still cant build a decent SUV.....(and never will all the time they hitch their cart to crappy VM engines who have never made a decent engine in their lives), still dont get that they need to up their game with interior quality in a far more competitive SUV market.

The last good JEEP was the XJ Cherokee. Cramped and basic, but a great working tool at a competitive price.

Isnt this an enlarged version of the GM/Fiat 2.0, which in turn was based on the old 1.9? 

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week