roadtester:
GM would be perfectly sensible to hang on to its UK operations in this way - the UK is GM's biggest European market after all.
I think it would be a smart move for GM and for Vauxhall. If Opel/Vauxhall were spun off into a new company without GM's involvement, chances are that they would soon kill the Vauxhall brand and replace it with Opel in the UK. Opel has always wanted to sell products in the UK under their own banner anyway.
Spinning off the company into a separate unit that is retained by GM Europe would not only allow Vauxhall to continue to thrive in the UK, but would allow them to possibly expand into the rest of Europe to compliment the lower-rung Chevrolet brand.
Some kind of contractual time-table could be set in which, after a certain date, all future Opel and Vauxhall products must have their own unique styling, marketing, monikers, etc. Then Opel could be allowed to re-enter the UK market under their own badge and Vauxhall could do the same in other markets.
roadtester:I don't, however think this is quite such bad news for the future of UK production as the article implies; UK closures would be more likely if Vauxhall were part of a German-dominated independent Opel.
I agree, it would be. If Opel were spun off completely, they could just as easily close Luton and move production to another European production site. In fact, with Opel gone, GM could arguably expand Luton to accomodate more products in the future.
However, even if some products were imported from GM DAT or other GM Europe factories in Russia or Eastern Europe, it is not entirely a bad thing.
People like to rip Daewoo for their older products and poor quality. But honestly, that is in the past. Yes, Chevrolet does import a few older Daewoo designs (Tacuma, Lacetti), but others have been completely updated (Epica, Aveo) or just replaced altogether with platforms never designed by the former Daewoo Motors (Captiva).
More importantly, moving forward, all their new prodoucts are based on new GM platforms that were co-designed with GM development centers around the world. That means that the Cruze's DeltaII platform (which will replace the Astra) wasn't exclusively created by GM DAT but had input from Opel and GM North America. Its truly a world platform. Same can be said for the EpsilonII platform (Opel Insignia/Buick LaCrosse/etc) or the updated Theta platform (Chevy Capitva/Opel Antara).
So these ARE NOT rehashed Daewoo platforms and Daewoo products that would be rebaged as Vauxhalls. They are new products brought to market worldwide by GM. At the end of the day, that means that a Chevy Cruze made in S. Korea or Lordstown, Ohio would be no different from an Astra made in Germany or China since they would be using the same basic components.