I rented one of these recently, and I really could not recommend it - even if it were less expensive. The engine was noisy and a lousy puller, and the car slowed significantly when it encountered hills (despite being a diesel). Fuel consumption was disappointing. Controls are not at all intuitive. Nothing seems particularly "high quality" in the interior - a Golf is better put together and feels more solid.
Last week I rented a Fiat Croma (1.9 Diesel, 150 PSI) and I would consider it a much better proposal (although I personally won't be rushing out to buy one) - great engine, quiet on the move, economical, loads of room, well equipped and a super autobahn kilometer eater.
Proof of the absurdity of "buying for the badge."