From £16,384
Eco improvements enhance Insignia's virtues

Our Verdict

Vauxhall Insignia
Vauxhall's traditional family saloon is regular UK class sales champion

The Vauxhall Insignia is only small details away from rivalling the class best

What is it?

Very possibly the car your employer’s fleet manager has been waiting for: this is the new, most frugal, lowest carbon version of Vauxhall’s Insignia.

Until now there have been only two diesel versions of Luton’s new and much-improved mid-sized saloon, powered by the same 2.0-litre four-pot engine in low (128bhp) and high (158bhp) states of tune. The Ecoflex brings the tally of oil-burners up to three; a fourth will be added later this year in the shape of a 188bhp 2.0-litre twin-turbo diesel.

Most low-CO2 versions of mainstream cars feature the smallest and most feeble engine in the range, but the Insignia Ecoflex is different. It runs the 158bhp version of Vauxhall’s 2.0-litre diesel because, according to the maker’s claims, it’s no less frugal and no more given to producing carbon dioxide than the 128bhp version.

In order to bring about the economy and emissions gains, GM Europe has tweaked the Insignia’s underbody aerodynamics and lowered it on its wheels by 10mm, bringing the car’s coefficient of drag down to 0.26. The Ecoflex runs on Michelin Primacy low-resistance rubber, and also has taller first and second gear ratios and a higher final drive.

What’s it like?

As impressive as the regular 158bhp Insignia in most ways, and even more so in one.

We tested the car on the undulating Millbrook Alpine Route, and 90 per cent of the time couldn’t discern it from its closest rangemate. All of the Insignia’s transferable virtues are here, including a well-appointed, classy and comfortable cabin, better-than-average passenger accommodation and some new-found good looks.

Performance feels stronger than you’d expect from an economy special, and gives credit to Vauxhall’s claim that the car is only a couple of tenths slower to 62mph than a standard 2.0-litre CDTi 160.

In normal conditions there’s enough mid-range punch for fairly swift overtaking. Only climbing the Hill Route’s steepest slopes was the car’s longer gearset evident, and only then in a little sluggishness in the upper reaches of the rev range.

Roadholding feels all-but-indiscernible from that of any other Insignia. That may be damning with faint praise in as much as the Vauxhall’s not the stand-out act in the class dynamically.

It just doesn’t quite steer precisely enough, ride subtly enough or handle deftly enough to bear comparison with a Ford Mondeo. But viewed in the right context, relative to Insignias with stiffer springs and a more overt sporting agenda, the Ecoflex is actually a bit of a triumph for Vauxhall.

While you expect compromised grip to come from the car’s low-resistance tyres, you actually get all the traction and lateral purchase you need. There’s noticeable tyre squeal in the dry as the tyres run out of adhesion sooner than performance tyres would, but the difference won’t matter during most road driving.

And considering how insignificant those compromises of performance and roadholding are, this car’s excellent economy and low CO2 seem all the sweeter.

Vauxhall claims that the car will return 54.7mpg on the combined cycle, going 10 per cent further between fill-ups than a standard 2.0-litre CDTi.

The car we tested, which was brand new and had been thrashed around Millbrook’s test routes for hundreds of miles, was returning 35mpg according to its drive computer; so we’ll wait to confirm that it really is as frugal as Vauxhall says. But even beating 50mpg on a motorway cruise would be a remarkable result for a car this size.

Should I buy one?

If impressive performance and driver thrills are what you’re after from your family hack, probably not. But then if either of those are top of your priorities list, you’re unlikely to be attracted by an Insignia anyway. Other medium-sized saloons do much better impressions of a sports car.

The fact is though that, if you do like the sound of the Insignia’s blend of virtues – practicality, style, quality, comfort and value-for-money – then the Ecoflex may be the most appealing model in the range.

It’s three brackets lower in the current ‘Benefit in Kind’ company car tax system than any other Insignia. It’s £25 a year cheaper on VED road tax. It’ll make your increasingly expensive litre of diesel go further too. And in every other way that matters it’s performance is as complete as any other version of the 2009 European Car of the Year.

Join the debate

Comments
11

16 June 2009

Still looks like a Hyundai with water retention. Are they selling any?

16 June 2009

[quote ThwartedEfforts]

Still looks like a Hyundai with water retention. Are they selling any?

[/quote]

Agree with that statement. I think they're selling pretty well, sadly. I was chatting with a Vauxhall dealer recently while the Mrs' Meriva was being serviced and he says that there's a 24 week wait. Who the hell is going to wait 24 weeks for a Vauxhall?

My neighbour has an Insignia and when he starts it up in the morning it sounds like a 1980's Transit. Refined it ain't. I hope it has plenty of soundproofing!

16 June 2009

[quote ThwartedEfforts]Are they selling any?
[/quote]

Sales figures for May, Proof that having a waiting list for a new model is not the good news the marketing guys would want you to believe.

Ford Fiesta - 7,040
Ford Focus - 6,693
Vauxhall Corsa - 5,525
Volkswagen Golf - 3,961
Vauxhall Astra - 3,549
Peugeot 207 - 3,103
BMW MINI - 2,650
Ford Mondeo - 2,647
Nissan Qashqai 2,629
Vauxhall Insignia - 2,602

16 June 2009

[quote Lee23404] I was chatting with a Vauxhall dealer recently while the Mrs' Meriva was being serviced and he says that there's a 24 week wait. Who the hell is going to wait 24 weeks for a Vauxhall?[/quote]

Hahahah, 24 week (6 month) wait what the hell are you serious Lee23404 did he tell you that, thats a joke and I thought VW waiting times for new cars were bad this is shocking, i thought all Vauxhall were built in Luton should be much quicker for the new car to be ready if it built on these shores

16 June 2009

[quote Lee23404]I think they're selling pretty well, sadly. I was chatting with a Vauxhall dealer recently while the Mrs' Meriva was being serviced [/quote]

Now, now. People in glass houses....

Where has all Japanese design went to?

17 June 2009

[quote Zeddy]

[quote Lee23404]I think they're selling pretty well, sadly. I was chatting with a Vauxhall dealer recently while the Mrs' Meriva was being serviced [/quote]

Now, now. People in glass houses....

[/quote]

I have little control over what car the wife drives and will not accept responsibility for it. If I did have some control over her choice of car she would now be driving the black Monaro which was next to her Meriva on the dealers forecourt :).

17 June 2009

[quote moe360] i thought all Vauxhall were built in Luton should be much quicker for the new car to be ready if it built on these shores[/quote]

The Insignia is made in Germany and there are/were apparently tens of thousands of pre-orders hence the waiting list. Madness.

17 June 2009

[quote Lee23404]If I did have some control over her choice of car she would now be driving the black Monaro which was next to her Meriva on the dealers forecourt :).[/quote]

Hell's teeth! You'd let a woman near such a powerful car!?? ;)

Where has all Japanese design went to?

17 June 2009

[quote Zeddy]

[quote Lee23404]If I did have some control over her choice of car she would now be driving the black Monaro which was next to her Meriva on the dealers forecourt :).[/quote]

Hell's teeth! You'd let a woman near such a powerful car!?? ;)

[/quote]

That wasn't really part of the plan, no. I think she saw through my plan for a weekend car to get over the boredom of the Vectra company car I had at the time.

18 June 2009

[quote Zeddy]

[quote Lee23404]If I did have some control over her choice of car she would now be driving the black Monaro which was next to her Meriva on the dealers forecourt :).[/quote]

Hell's teeth! You'd let a woman near such a powerful car!?? ;)

[/quote]

"Where's your wife?"

"Oh, that's her going sideways on her third lap of that roundabout - takes her forever to get back from Tesco nowadays, and plays hell with the groceries in the boot"

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • 2016 Audi A3 Sportback e-tron UK review
    First Drive
    29 September 2016
    First UK drive finds the facelifted A3 Sportback e-tron remains a first-rate plug-in hybrid that is packed with tech if a little short on driver appeal
  • Citroen C11.2 Puretech 82 Furio
    First Drive
    29 September 2016
    Citroën's city car gets a new sporty-looking trim level, adding visual adornments, but no premium for the 1.2-litre Puretech triple we're driving
  • Mercedes C350e Sport
    First Drive
    28 September 2016
    Petrol-electric C-Class is a surprisingly well-priced alternative to a diesel but not the greatest example of the new ‘PHEV’ breed
  • Car review
    23 September 2016
    Aston kicks off its ‘second century plan’ with an all-new turbo V12 grand tourer
  • Ford Ka+ 1.2 Ti-VCT 85
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    A rounded, refined and well-sorted bargain supermini – once you’re used to the confusing role redefinition imposed on the once-cheeky Ka