From £12,240
An attractive interior and a good chassis only part-compensate for an ageing turbodiesel

Our Verdict

Vauxhall Astra 2009-2015
The Astra is now in its sixth incarnation, but it can trace its linage back to 1963's Viva

The Vauxhall Astra is one of the best-looking hatchbacks, but average dynamics and performance hamper its overall appeal

12 October 2009

What is it?

This sixth-generation Astra is an almost entirely new car, but some of its engines live on from previous generations, including the old 1.7 litre, 109bhp Isuzu turbodiesel, which is now the least potent oil-burner in the range until the 109g/km 1.3 CDTi turns up next year.

This engine does not go under the Astra’s bonnet unmodified however, because it now meets Euro V emission standards, and its installation has been modified in the quest for refinement.

There’s also a 123bhp 1.7 CDTi - although this is a different and quicker engine, it produces the same combined fuel consumption figure of 60.1mpg and identical Co2 emissions of 124g/km.

What’s it like?

For this 109bhp engine none of these figures is especially competitive, the 104bhp Golf 1.6 TDI beating it on every count for emissions (119g/km), fuel consumption (62.8mpg), 0-62mph (11.3sec) and top speed (117mph), while Ford’s Focus 108bhp 1.6 TDCi also trounces the Vauxhall.

And the same is true on the road. Although the Isuzu motor is much quieter than before, whether you’re sitting behind it or hearing its presence from outside the car, it still sounds like a set of deftly deployed maracas, and there’s a muted over-run growl to match.

On-board the Golf, you’ll be struggling to tell which fuel it burns. Still, this Astra certainly isn’t an unpleasant drive. The diesel’s clatter is far from insistent enough to overwhelm the car’s considerable virtues in other directions, which include a pleasingly supple ride, very tidy handling and a classily crafted cabin. Though far from scintillating, its performance is elastic enough for adequately brisk journeys.

Should I buy one?

The Vauxhall Astra is a sophisticated addition to the class that should not be overlooked by anyone shopping for a family hatch, particularly when fitted with one of the new engines available in the range. But this latest Astra deserves an oil-burner of the calibre of the Golf and Focus whose engines are plainly better, whether statistically and aurally.

Join the debate

Comments
1

12 October 2009

You said "For this 109bhp engine none of these figures is especially competitive, the 104bhp Golf 1.6 TDI beating it on every count for emissions (119g/km), fuel consumption (62.8mpg)". Well if the VW beats it for CO2 emissions then it's bound to beat it for fuel consumption, isn't it!! Duuuh.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • 2016 Hyundai I30 1.4 Turbo prototype
    First Drive
    30 August 2016
    We get early access to the third-generation Hyundai i30 1.4 Turbo. Does this prototype show promise?
  • Citroën C4 Grand Picasso
    First Drive
    26 August 2016
    The Citroën Grand C4 Picasso gets tweaked styling, improved tech and new personalisation options to keep it ahead of rivals
  • Car review
    26 August 2016
    Wolfsburg celebrates the GTI’s 40th with its most extreme version yet
  • Kia Optima Sportwagon
    First Drive
    25 August 2016
    New Kia estate looks the part, has good space and handles tidily, but its engine's flexibility and refinement let it down
  •  Kia Optima PHEV
    First Drive
    25 August 2016
    Plug-in hybrid Optima is a practical, tax-efficient PHEV that undercuts rivals and fulfils its main remit well, but keen drivers need not apply