From £15,920
This latest Renault Mégane comes with a decent spec and impressive engine, but the 'GT' tag is a misnomer

Our Verdict

Renault Megane
It's hard to make a case for any of the non-sporting Megane range

The Renault Megane looks bland, and it's not that good to drive either

What is it?

Renault is rolling out what it calls the ‘Mégane Collection 2012’, which is basically a well-refreshed range, featuring new petrol and diesel engines, and new trim and equipment levels. Renault’s new 4+ ownership programme is also on the table, which gives a 4 year, 100k mile warranty, free routine servicing for four years/48k miles, four years' roadside cover and up to four years' finance.

Easily the most interesting of the new line-up are the models powered by the new 1.2 TCe turbocharged petrol engine. This unit is the first Renault petrol engine to feature both direct injection and turbocharging. The turbo is integrated into the manifold and there’s variable valve timing to extract the most from this small four-pot.

Offering 113bhp and 140lb ft of torque between 2000 and 4000rpm (with 90 per cent of the twist available from 1600rpm), the engine also promises a most diesel-like average economy figure of 53.3mpg and 119g/km of Co2. The stop-start system uses an extra-quick technique, which re-starts by first firing whichever piston is in the best position to get the engine going as quickly as possible. Renault engineers have worked on reducing internal friction using, among other things, a Teflon-coated timing chain.

Our test car – driven in the hills around Seville – was also the most interesting of the new trim levels. Called GT Line, in addition to useful stuff like the big-screen Tom Tom sat-nav, it gets Renaultsport front seats, a fat sports steering wheel, aluminium pedals, a rear parking camera, rear tinted windows, climate control, an auto parking brake and 17in alloys.

The GT Line also gets the same chassis set-up as the mainstream Mégane Coupé (slightly stiffer springs and dampers) as well as decent-size discs all round and the same brake master cylinder as the Renault Sport Coupe.

What’s it like?

Nippy, refined and, in many areas, nicely polished. On the other hand, this car might also be regarded as rather too restrained and polite for its own good.

First off, the new engine is most impressive: very sweet running, refined and extremely quiet. For drivers used to the gruffness of most EuroV diesels, this drivetrain is a huge breath of fresh air. The stop-start system is also super-rapid and extremely refined.

This nippy (nippier than the bare figures would suggest) 1.2-litre unit also has the legs for long upgrades, without the need for frequent down changing (although the clutch and shift action are both impressively slick and well weighted in left-hand drive), something that can catch-out the new generation of three-cylinder petrol turbo engines.

Also impressive are the excellent seats and steering wheel, the calm and well-composed ride (at least on these Spanish roads), motorway pace and refinement. Mention should also be made of much of the switchgear (including the column stalks and climate control panel), which is very nicely designed and finished. Handy boot size aside, the cabin doesn’t feel as roomy as the higher-roofed Golf and Focus, although the low-riding dashboard does give an airy view forward.

However, the ‘GT’ tag is pretty misleading. This Mégane lacks any kind of even mildly sporting intent. Driven along in normal flowing traffic, it impresses by way of its ease and effortlessness. Turn up the wick, and the chassis is just not interested.

Trying to hustle the car on winding hill routes just results in the whoosing sound of an overdose of grip and safety-first chassis tuning, preventing the driver getting any kind of flow or eager feedback through the seat of the (very impressive) sports seats.

Should I buy one?

It’s an unusual vehicle: an odd mix of polish, refinement and innovation but with rather bland styling and a somewhat characterless driving experience.

True, the standard spec is healthy and the new Renault buying package is pretty comprehensive. The promised fuel economy – as long as the engine isn’t wrung-out – makes it easy to return to the hushed delights of petrol power, especially as the diesel GT Line is another £1500 more expensive. I’d like to see this engine in the (decently specced) entry-level 2012 Mégane. That would be a much more compelling proposition.

Renault Mégane 1.2 TCe 115 GT Line

Price: £19,825; Top speed: 118mph; 0-62mph: 10.9sec; Economy: 53.3mpg; Co2: 119g/km; Kerb weight: 1205kg; Engine: In-line four, turbo,1198cc; Installation: Front, transverse, fwd; Power: 113bhp at 4500rpm; Torque: 190nm at 2000rpm; Gearbox: 6-spd manual

Join the debate

Comments
16

21 March 2012

"(with 90 percent of the twist available from 160rpm)"

Who needs a diesel with this low down grunt !

21 March 2012

Its a shame all this advanced new engine tech is not making its debut in a more visually interesting car.That said Renault dont have any in their current line up.Its little wonder Nissan are the more successful of the partnership.

22 March 2012

Doesnt sound too bad does it . Best to wait till its a year old to buy it though as the depreciation will be horrendous .

22 March 2012

Although a refined and economical petrol hatch certainly has its appeal, at nearly £20 grand for a 1.2 ltr (even if it's turbo charged), this is just poor value.

And for those who say, well it's only the price before discount/haggling, my response would be, why should people have to haggle before they get a reasonably priced new car?

22 March 2012

"However, the ‘GT’ tag is pretty misleading."

Does 'GT' not stand for Grand Tourer so a refined car with long legs for cruising appears to fit the tag perfectly.

"First off, the new engine is most impressive: very sweet running, refined and extremely quiet. For drivers used to the gruffness of most EuroV diesels, this drivetrain is a huge breath of fresh air. The stop-start system is also super-rapid and extremely refined.

This nippy (nippier than the bare figures would suggest) 1.2-litre unit also has the legs for long upgrades, without the need for frequent down changing (although the clutch and shift action are both impressively slick and well-weighted in left-hand drive), something that can catch-out the new generation of three-cylinder petrol turbo engines."

In my view the issue is not Renault's use of the GT, but the misuse of the badge by other manufacturers. Can you really call the Porsche 911 GT2/3 a grand tourer, a perfect car for crossing continents in comfort in?

22 March 2012

[quote Overdrive] Although a refined and economical petrol hatch certainly has its appeal, at nearly £20 grand for a 1.2 ltr (even if it's turbo charged), this is just poor value.[/quote]

That's a view that's becoming increasingly out-of-date. Capacity in isolation tells you next to nothing these days.

22 March 2012

Renault were chucking the 2008+ model out to fleets and lease companies with a good 35% off list. I can only presume it'll be the same with this model.

Who on earth signed off on something so bland - it even makes the 308 look attractive. Is it any wonder Renault are not selling any cars. The new Clio and the EVs need to come on stream quickly.

22 March 2012

[quote nettingham]

[quote Overdrive] Although a refined and economical petrol hatch certainly has its appeal, at nearly £20 grand for a 1.2 ltr (even if it's turbo charged), this is just poor value.[/quote]

That's a view that's becoming increasingly out-of-date. Capacity in isolation tells you next to nothing these days.

[/quote]

Alright then, just to keep up with the times, this 1.2 ltr hatch is excellent value at £20k (even though the Focus 1.0 ecoboost has 123 bhp and 125ft - up to 148ft on overboost - for £17.7k)!

22 March 2012

[quote Overdrive]Alright then, just to keep up with the times, this 1.2 ltr hatch is excellent value at £20k (even though the Focus 1.0 ecoboost has 123 bhp and 125ft - up to 148ft on overboost - for £17.7k)![/quote]

Nettingham's right, we have to re-adjust to the mindset that small capacity no longer mean poor value at this price point. And, to be fair, this GT Line Megane is the highest spec available with this engine and can also be had for £18k as a Dynamique. Also, the 1.0 Ecoboost 100PS Focus now runs to over £20k in its top trim level.

We'll have to get used to a 1.6 Jaguar C-X75 in future..


22 March 2012

[quote nettingham]

[quote Overdrive] Although a refined and economical petrol hatch certainly has its appeal, at nearly £20 grand for a 1.2 ltr (even if it's turbo charged), this is just poor value.[/quote]

That's a view that's becoming increasingly out-of-date. Capacity in isolation tells you next to nothing these days.

[/quote] +1.... Just look at the 3 cyl 1:0 Focus.... Great second car.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Car review
    23 September 2016
    Aston kicks off its ‘second century plan’ with an all-new turbo V12 grand tourer
  • Ford Ka+ 1.2 Ti-VCT 85
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    A rounded, refined and well-sorted bargain supermini – once you’re used to the confusing role redefinition imposed on the once-cheeky Ka
  •  Maserati Ghibli Diesel
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    Maserati releases another range of updates for its range best seller, the Ghibli. We've driven the diesel version, but there's little improvement on before
  • Tipo Front
    First Drive
    21 September 2016
    New Fiat Tipo offers impressive space and practicality for a reasonable price. We try the 1.6 diesel on the demanding roads of North Wales
  • Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150
    First Drive
    20 September 2016
    The Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150 makes perfect sense: it's spacious, tidy to drive for an SUV and cheap to run