The ultimate Mini is great to drive – but expensive for what it gives

Our Verdict

Mini John Cooper Works
Mini's John Cooper Works auto is less highly strung than before but quicker than ever

Faster and more rounded than any ‘Works’ Mini before it. Still a committed prospect – to buy and to use – but rewarding to drive

What is it?

The hottest version of the new age Mini so far. The ‘JCW’ uses a tuned version of the standard Cooper S’s 1.6-litre engine to deliver 208bhp – enough to propel if from 0-62mph in a claimed 6.5 seconds and onto a top speed of 148 mph.

Read our full Mini JCW Challenge review here

After the success of BMW’s previous ‘John Cooper Works’ kit on the previous Mini, the JCW brand has been brought in-house to create what we’re encouraged to see as an equivalent of parent BMW’s M-Division.

The Mini John Cooper Works wears a unique bodykit, boasts new-design 18 inch alloys and gets the all-important extra badges. But the most substantial changes lie beneath the surface.

The engine gets a revised cylinder head, new pistons, more turbo boost and an all-new exhaust system (from the manifold back to the tailpipe). The power output will grab the headlines, but it’s the fat torque plateau, with 192lb ft from 1850-5600rpm, that actually underlies the JCW’s performance.

Brakes have also been uprated, although the suspension remains the same as that of the standard Cooper S, unless you’re prepared to pay more for an ultra-hard JCW handling kit.

What’s it like?

Great fun. The JCW provides instant proof that the standard Cooper S’s chassis is more than up to handling a substantial power hike.

It feels properly rapid – the turbo spools up with almost no lag and the engine’s strong mid-range makes for effortless urge in any gear. Passers by get to enjoy a rorty exhaust note, into which some over-run ‘crackle’ has been carefully engineered. But, unfortunately, inside the cabin it sounds flat and insipid.

The biggest dynamic difference comes from the fitment of what’s described as an electronic differential lock system, which replicates the function of a mechanical LSD by braking a spinning front wheel (if the traction control is turned off) to redistribute torque.

The JCW certainly finds plenty of grip and traction, although the clever traction control is only of noticeable benefit on very tight corners or in wet conditions. The JCW also gets a more aggressive stability control setting – under the same ‘Dynamic Traction Control’ moniker that BMW uses – although this feels slightly pointless on a front-drive hatchback.

The engine’s prodigious output creates some mild torque steer, with the JCW’s steering wheel sniffing out cambers and minor imperfections in the road surface. But it’s well contained and the mild tugging effect is entirely in keeping with the enthusiastic qualities you’d expect from a car like this.

The most surprising thing about the John Cooper Works is just how much equipment it doesn’t get – and which has been reserved for the options list. Despite a pricetag that puts it into direct contention with a 2.0 TFSI Volkswagen Scirocco, the JCW makes do with the same standard, unsupportive seats fitted to the standard Mini Cooper. Proper buckets are a pricey option.

The interior also lacks much to distinguish it from the standard Cooper S. The JCW gets branded plates on the doorsills, a 160mph speedometer and a different gearknob. But, from the driver’s seat, it certainly doesn’t feel like it should be nearly five grand more expensive than the Cooper S.

So, should I buy one?

If you want the ultimate Mini, this is what you’ll have to pay to get your hands on one. But the John Cooper Works feels like it’s going to struggle to justify its seriously steep pricetag against some of its seriously talented, cheaper rivals.

Mike Duff

Join the debate

Comments
6

15 July 2008

I've been privalidged enough to be able to drive the JCW already, I found the exhaust note very entertaining and the steering had a much firmer feel than that of the standard Cooper S.

One of the most important facts that surrounds the MINI is residual values, yes the car is expensive - quote "The John Cooper Works feels like it’s going to struggle to justify its seriously steep pricetag against some of its seriously talented, cheaper rivals..." but if you can afford the initial price tag then in 3 years you wont have regreted it.

15 July 2008

FFFFFFFFFF.....

That's the noise I made though my teeth when I got to the bottom of the page and saw the price.

OMG! £21k for a poorly equipped small car.

15 July 2008

[quote Pauldalg]

OMG! £21k for a poorly equipped small car.

[/quote]

Sounds very cheap to me.

Here in Israel (The official automotive hell...) 21,000 pounds won't even get you into a Mini One (From 27,000 pounds). A standard Cooper S? 37,000 pounds before options, thanks for asking.

Roy.

17 July 2008

I have recently placed an order for a black JCW with all the options I can afford. Few things that you mentioned that are incorrect though, it does not come with 18" rims but, rather the special light weight Borbet rims identical to the Challenge car. The Aero Kit, Carbon Fibre trims, Recaros are amongst the most expensive options. The 5K extra your are paying for are of course for the performance and the 17" Borbet rims only. So I do agree, from the inside, it is rather bland and nothing special compared to the Cooper S Chilli where it is based on. Unless you prepared to fork out extra dough to make it "individual", the 5K is all worth it when you drive the car.

21 July 2008

I was convinced I'd be placing an order for a JCW this summer, I just wish they'd included the funky carbon/alcantara JCW Steering Wheel and a pair of the Recaro seats. It'd be on my drive quicker than you can sign over £22,000.

I know motoring hacks love to get a table consisting for three columns, "Power, 0-62, Price", and simply pick the one that falls convieniently in the middle. But fortunately for the motoring industry, the general public were blessed with hearts and minds too. So when I buy a car, I know what I want to spend, know how I'm going to use it, and how much junk I'm going to carry round.

So why would I want a Scirocco??? Just because its bigger?!?! JCW for me please.

1 August 2008

£21K for a MINI!!! Ok, its quick, but I'm sorry, there a plenty more cars out there that look better, cost less and are less, well, dare I say it, 'feminine'.Sorry, but the Mini is definately not worth £21K.

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Car review
    23 September 2016
    Aston kicks off its ‘second century plan’ with an all-new turbo V12 grand tourer
  • Ford Ka+ 1.2 Ti-VCT 85
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    A rounded, refined and well-sorted bargain supermini – once you’re used to the confusing role redefinition imposed on the once-cheeky Ka
  •  Maserati Ghibli Diesel
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    Maserati releases another range of updates for its range best seller, the Ghibli. We've driven the diesel version, but there's little improvement on before
  • Tipo Front
    First Drive
    21 September 2016
    New Fiat Tipo offers impressive space and practicality for a reasonable price. We try the 1.6 diesel on the demanding roads of North Wales
  • Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150
    First Drive
    20 September 2016
    The Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150 makes perfect sense: it's spacious, tidy to drive for an SUV and cheap to run