When the first of the previous-generation Jeep Grand Cherokees arrived at our office for testing in August 2005, one tester wrote in his notes: “I don’t know what they were thinking of.” Five months later, when we named and shamed the worst car we’d driven all year, the Jeep got it without a single dissenting voice.

It was crude, cramped, overpriced and over here. Were its mediocrity not so prejudicial to its creator’s health, it would have been laughable.

But perhaps in time we’ll regard it as its equivalent of the Mk4 Ford Escort, a car so bad that it actually became a force for good, stinging the firm out of its complacency and into action. Ford’s next two cars were the Mondeo and Focus and it has never looked back.

We usually save this bit for the verdict, but there is something you should know now: the current Jeep Grand Cherokee is almost indescribably better than the model it replaced.

A mid-2013 update improved the new Grand Cherokee even further, adding an eight-speed automatic transmission and cosmetic improvements including changes to the lights, grille and rear tailgate.

The question, though, is whether it's good enough to compete with the likes of the Land Rover Discovery. Let's find out.

Top 5 Large SUVs

  • Range Rover Sport
    The new Sport, from a keen driver’s point of view, might just be the best SUV in the world at the moment

    Range Rover Sport

    1
  • The Porsche Cayenne is available as a hybrid for the first time

    Porsche Cayenne

    2
  • BMW X5
    The X5 uses in effect the same platform as the previous generation, but it's been substantially revised

    BMW X5

    3
  • Land Rover Discovery
    The Discovery really is the defining go-anywhere super-utility vehicle

    Land Rover Discovery

    4
  • The Mk2 model, also based on the Porsche Cayenne, is lighter, roomier and more economical than the first

    Volkswagen Touareg

    5

First drives

Videos

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • First Drive
    30 June 2015
    Significant upgrades to the M6's Competition Package only serve to lift its appeal even more
  • First Drive
    29 June 2015
    Third-gen MPV exudes characteristic Volkswagen refinements, so it's solid, upmarket, smart and practical – albeit a bit bland
  • First Drive
    29 June 2015
    This Tucson is proof Hyundai hasn’t run out of momentum. If it's priced and specced keenly, it could be a rival to the class best.
  • First Drive
    26 June 2015
    A niche proposition as ever, but then Subaru revels in its uniqueness. This would be a significantly improved car with a conventional automatic or manual transmission
  • First Drive
    26 June 2015
    In the past we've rated the Toyota Auris as solid and dependable but hardly exciting. Has a mid-life refresh injected it with a sense of fun?