From £17,140
Lots of front, even more behind

Our Verdict

Seat Toledo
As well as the diesel, Seat's Toledo is offered with three-cylinder and four-cylinder petrols

The Seat Toledo makes a good case for itself as a no-nonsense family car, but don't expect any thrills

  • First Drive

    Seat Toledo 1.6 TDI

    Seat Toledo makes a return to a saloon shape. It represents excellent value for money, but it’s a compromised option.
  • First Drive

    Seat Toledo 1.9 TDI

    Lots of front, even more behind

VW’s brand engineers have a hell of a job. Carefully plotting the development and core values of four brands (VW, Audi, Skoda and Seat) and making each of them viable, individual and self-sufficient is a monumental task that would have many car makers floundering. But they’ve done a magnificent job of diversifying the VW portfolio and providing each brand with a decidedly different raison d’être.

However, one interface remains fuzzy – the gulf between Seat and Skoda isn’t as wide as VW would like. Seat should be more desirable, with superior materials quality and refinement. But a question remains, if ‘auto emoción’ is still its tagline, why have Skodas felt stronger of spirit lately than Seats? Seat is left to trade on promises of a sporting drive and a more inspired product.

It’s a question I asked myself while staring at the odd-looking boot of the new Toledo. It looks weird – part Renault Vel Satis, part Wolseley Hornet (which was basically a Mini with a protruding boot). And ‘weird’ isn’t a great adjective for a car company that desperately lacks a clear image in the UK. What Seat needs is sleek, raw cars that can back its claim to be a sporty brand. There’s nothing sleek and raw in the look of that boot.

Forget everything from the C-pillars back and concentrate on the bodywork in front of the curved rear glass (which is also weird), because from the rear wheel arches forward, the Toledo looks just like an Altea. If you’re being tailed by a Toledo, you’ll find it impossible to distinguish the two. In fact all of the bodywork ahead of the C-pillars is identical to the Altea’s, which means the same swept-back headlights, oversized grille and ‘dynamic line’, which runs the length of the body and integrates well with the bulge of the rear wheelarch.

In the cabin

So the new Toledo is an Altea with some extra boot space. This doesn’t make it the most innovative idea in the world, seeing as the Altea’s 409-litre rear isn’t exactly titchy in the first place. But the Toledo’s frumpy rump has an extra 91 litres of load space, equalling a Mondeo hatch’s 500 litres.

Climb aboard and an elevated seating position and swept-back centre console seem familiar. A second glance at the red-lit instrument cluster and the check pattern etched into the hard plastic dashtop crystallise your suspicions into fact – this interior is all Altea.

From the cheap feeling of the door pulls to the arcing line in the dash that runs from beneath the fascia and terminates on the right side of the instrument pod, this cabin is exactly the same as its MPV sibling’s. Other than the lack of individuality, however, this isn’t all bad. It’s nicely styled, extremely airy and feels well put together, if not quite up to Audi standards for plastics.

Along with its interior, the Toledo inherits the Altea’s terrible front visibility. The rakish windscreen and chunky A-pillars mean you’ll leave nostril imprints on the windscreen as you peer over the prow when parking. And accurately placing the Toledo is near impossible unless the seat is cranked right up high, so you can see the asphalt below.

The wide range of adjustment for the driver’s seat and wheel are to be appreciated, but the high dash means that if your favourite position is low down you’ll struggle to get a clear picture of the road ahead. At least rear-seat passengers will be delighted with the generous amounts of knee and headroom.

Thankfully, the Toledo has direct and accurate electro-hydraulic steering to help it trace your desired line (once the seat is cranked up and you can see over the dash, that is). And because the Seat borrows its chassis from the latest Golf, it has that car’s same sense of composure and fluidity. Slightly firmer springs than those on the Altea, which is also Golf-based, together with standard large-ish 16in alloy wheels mean the Toledo exhibits some low-speed fidget.

Under the bonnet

Power comes courtesy of VW’s familiar 1.9-litre TDi. It’s unreasonably loud at idle and on the move; at around 2300rpm the diesel chunter combines with the high driving position to create the ambience of a tractor. It is also nowhere near as quick as the (£1650 more expensive) 2.0-litre TDi and still isn’t Euro4 emissions compliant, meaning company car drivers will face bigger bills. But with 104bhp and 184lb ft of torque, it moves about town quickly enough and provides a nice surge of mid-range punch.

Seat wants to call its new Toledo a saloon, and even more than that, it wants to redefine a segment. But there’s a problem, because the Toledo is as much a saloon as a McLaren F1 is a supermini. And it’s this confusion, not just with the Toledo, but with the brand as a whole, that denies Seat the sort of image it’s striving for in the UK.

The Toledo fails to exude the ‘emoción’ Seat would like it to, but critically it doesn’t make much sense next to the Altea – they both offer identical dynamics, practicality and interior space, with the only difference being 91 litres of boot space. As a Toledo costs £500 over a similarly specified Altea (that’s £5.50 per litre of boot), we reckon you should spend the money on something else.

We don’t need to put the boot in to the Toledo – Seat has done it for us. The smaller, less expensive and more handsome Altea is also the better buy.

Jack Galusha

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • Car review
    23 September 2016
    Aston kicks off its ‘second century plan’ with an all-new turbo V12 grand tourer
  • Ford Ka+ 1.2 Ti-VCT 85
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    A rounded, refined and well-sorted bargain supermini – once you’re used to the confusing role redefinition imposed on the once-cheeky Ka
  •  Maserati Ghibli Diesel
    First Drive
    22 September 2016
    Maserati releases another range of updates for its range best seller, the Ghibli. We've driven the diesel version, but there's little improvement on before
  • Tipo Front
    First Drive
    21 September 2016
    New Fiat Tipo offers impressive space and practicality for a reasonable price. We try the 1.6 diesel on the demanding roads of North Wales
  • Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150
    First Drive
    20 September 2016
    The Seat Ateca 1.4 TSI 150 makes perfect sense: it's spacious, tidy to drive for an SUV and cheap to run