Nic Cackett
26 June 2012

What is it?

Concerned that its buyers may have their heads turned by younger models, Fiat has treated the venerable Punto to a very gentle mid life makeover (which you probably won’t notice) and added two new engines (which you certainly will).

One is an evolution of the MultiJet diesel engine which extracts 83bhp from 1300cc, and emits just 90g/km CO2, but the other, which we’ll focus on here, is the turbocharged version of Fiat’s two-cylinder TwinAir petrol motor.

Making its debut in the Punto, the award-winning powerplant also pulls 83bhp from its hat, along with 107lb ft of torque at 2000rpm, but the real party trick is the diesel-rivalling 67.3mpg and 98g/km CO2.

Those figures are unchanged from the engine’s appearances in the 500 and the stellar new Panda, but elsewhere several changes have been made, partly in deference to the higher quality expected of a B segment model.

In the Punto the TwinAir is mated to a six-speed manual gearbox rather than the five-speeder found in its smaller stablemates, and in the interests of greater refinement, it has been fitted with a dual mass flywheel and balancing countershaft.

What is it like?

Thanks to its microscopic proportions, there’s always an element of incredulity that a TwinAir-equipped car functions at all, let alone does so with modest potency. The Punto is not a heavy supermini, but 1075kg is still a considerable tortoise shell to carry around and it’s a tribute to Fiat’s ingenuity that the engine - probably helped by the extra ratio - retains a modicum of flexibility in high gear.

Nevertheless, the temptation to rev the tiny two-pot into the upper echelons of its whiny thrum remains. Mechanical modifications may have smoothed away some of the vibrations, but the TwinAir unit still sounds like a chainsaw being held under a pillow on the floor below. It’s just as easy to wind up too; pay too little attention and every gear will be ushered swiftly into its soft limiter.

What it does not do, however, is resonate as much fun. The already cute-as-a-button 500 suited its blustery pluck, but in the lardier Punto it’s like throwing punches under water - all effort and no real impact. The alternative is to obey the nannying gearshift indicator and make a play for hyper-mile economy. The slower pace suits Fiat’s supermini - its dynamic temperament is roughly the equivalent of a fat puppy running on wet grass – and with so much weight removed from its nose, it lolly gaggles over bumps like it’s about to float away. The effect is not unwelcome after one too many firmly nailed down superminis, and chances are you’ll never pick up enough speed to encounter the poorly contained body roll, but doing what the TwinAir wants is a copper-bottomed way of placing its headline issue front and centre.

Even with our lead feet substituted for sensible shoes, we couldn’t better 45mpg on a half hour journey despite being propped for long periods at the national limit. Arguably that’s not a shameful figure (doubtless others could do better - we lacked the saint-like patience required to repeatedly depress the torque-sapping Eco button) but if you’re expecting oil burning mpg from your green Punto, you’ll likely be disappointed.

Should I buy one?

If you’re allergic to diesel prices, don’t expect to do mammoth miles and don’t burst a blood vessel if your car fails to measure up to its claimed economy figures, then the TwinAir might appeal. But, more often than not, the aged supermini feels like a model too far for Fiat’s diminutive engine.

Certainly its emissions fall below the right limit, and it isn’t formidably expensive, but even with a novel new ingredient, the Punto never does enough to convince you that you’re not going to be better off in four or five of the superior options currently available.

Fiat Punto TwinAir

Price: £12,100; 0-62mph: 12.7 seconds; Top speed: 107mph; Economy: 67.3mpg; CO2: 98g/km; Kerbweight: 1075kg; Engine: Two cyls, 875cc, turbocharged petrol; Power: 83bhp @ 5500rpm; Torque: 107lb ft @ 2000rpm; Gearbox: 6-spd manual

 

 

Join the debate

Comments
16

"Punto with interesting engine" headline...

2 years 16 weeks ago

... would be read more avidly by many if the numbers 1750 were involved...  come on Fiat, take the hint.

Its probably just me, but I

2 years 16 weeks ago

Its probably just me, but I found this review very hard to read. For example:

"doing what the TwinAir wants is a copper-bottomed way of placing its headline issue front and centre."

What does that mean? Come on Autocar, please keep it simple so I can actually understand what you're saying about the vehicle being tested, without having to re-read sentences to follow it.

An Engine Too Far ...

2 years 16 weeks ago

Amusing similes aside, it's clear that the revolutionary TwinAir is NOT the engine for the Punto ...

TS7

Shock! Horror! Engine

2 years 16 weeks ago

Shock! Horror!

Engine designed to 'beat' government fuel economy tests fails to deliver in the real world.

but the best looking supermini by far!

2 years 16 weeks ago

this skin refresh gives the Punto back its calss leading styling and after all these years leads the class - glad they got rid of the mid-life restyling which was horrid.  Nothing contrived, just pure Italian style.  OK, the cassis is not the greatest now, but 99% of buyers would not notice and the other 1% will find other things to prefer over ugly offerings from Ford etc.

PhilLC

I like the Punto, and it is

2 years 16 weeks ago

I like the Punto, and it is finally looking good again! The proportions are neat, the styling simple again. No, it won't lap a track like a fiesta, but I think it will be a good small car for most peoples needs. Plus, with discounts, very good value!

-----

10 years of Smart ownership over, sensible car mode activated

MrJ

Refreshed looks

2 years 16 weeks ago

Yes I have noticed the refreshed Punto's looks - it's back to being quite attractive again, now they've ditched the curious extra grille they added last time around.

Not too impressed by the economy though, unless you have a heavy right foot. I regularly achieve 48-55 mph in a SEAT Ibiza 5-door that's usually loaded up with hefty gear and a couple of passengers.

No it's not just you...

2 years 16 weeks ago

Agree 100% - that report was gibberish.

-

2 years 16 weeks ago

I like this little car. Someone I used to work with had a Punto Evo 1.2 MyLife, and it was a great little car to drive, and I'd certainly consider one over the norm.

The styling has improved,

2 years 16 weeks ago

The styling has improved, back to how it used to look before some fool messed with it. Give Fiat credit, it hasnt taken them long to correct the error.

This engine however is a big mistake. Some years ago i had a 1.3 Yaris, and it averaged 46mpg with my lead feet, and didnt have a turbo, or a dual mass flywheel to cost some poor soul dearly later in life.

I do like the Punto, but lets stick to 4 cylinders.

Finally some credit must go to Autocar who at least got into the 40's mpg, afterall in the smaller 500 with this engine they only managed 30's mpg !

 

Please register or login to post a comment.

Our Verdict

Decently spacious for a supermini, with a good range of engines, but the Punto's driving dynamics are less-than beguiling

  • First Drive

    Fiat Punto 0.9 TwinAir

    It’s an intriguing car; decently spacious nippy and particularly characterful
  • First Drive

    Fiat Punto Evo Abarth

    Fun and charismatic - but buyers should check out the Seat Ibiza Cupra and Skoda Fabia VRS too

Driven this week