From £44,535
A 5 Series in name but half X6 in (driving) nature

Our Verdict

BMW 5 Series Gran Turismo
Despite its name, the 5 Series GT shares 7 Series underpinnings

The 5 Series Gran Turismo is an interesting concept, but the execution is flawed

  • First Drive

    BMW 5 Series GT Fuel Cell concept review

    Fuel cell-powered 5 Series GT concept previews a revolutionary storage and refuelling system which could pave the way for hydrogen to become the alternative fue
  • First Drive

    BMW 520d Gran Turismo

    The BMW 520d GT represents the new entry point in the Gran Turimso range, slashing £9000 from the list price

What is it?

The X6 is all well and good, so is the 7 Series and so is the 5 Series Touring. BMW insists, though, that if you make a triangle out of those three cars, the car that fills the space in the middle will be perfect for a lost generation of potential buyers who want some of each car, but not all.

So the 5 Series Gran Turismo was built specifically to mop them up and, BMW evangelistically claims, to create an entirely new market segment – something the car industry really hasn’t managed since the Renault Scenic.

So BMW’s got big claims behind this car, but it actually does offer 7 Series front and rear leg room, luxury and entertainment features, as well as X5 head room, monster luggage space and cracking new engine and gearbox technology.

What’s it like?

All of that evangelism can turn you off a car before you even drive it, but that would be a mistake with this car.

For starters, there’s the technology. It has the latest generation of 3.0-litre diesel, which is expected to comfortably outsell the 535i GT in Europe. It deserves to as well, because it has 241bhp of power at 4000rpm and 398lb ft of torque from 1750 to 3000rpm.

It will help that it’s the cheapest Gran Turismo, but it’s also the best of the GT’s engine range.

But while it’s not the fastest, it never actually feels wanting. Our side-by-side charges showed the 535i consistently pulling away, even in rolling in-gear sprints, but the 530d version was never humbled as it smoothly charged through its eight gears, swapping seamlessly regardless of whether the brilliant new transmission was in its softest or sportiest settings.

BMW claims it will pull 43.5mpg on the EU combined cycle, but we didn’t come close to that. In fact, we comfortably halved it without even trying and, with only a 70-litre tank, the GT might be stopping to refuel more than we’d like.

Short-range tank apart, it will be a legendarily good cruiser. The engine idles at 700rpm, and at 62mph it’s only ticking over at 1350rpm. At 80mph it’s only pulling 1700 revs – which isn’t even at the torque peak yet – and at 124mph it’s still only around 2200rpm. Relaxed? You bet.

If the driveline is comfortable, the cabin backs it up, and then some. It will be the tank dictating your stops, not your back. The seats are brilliant, with soft initial cushioning and firm support beneath it – and that goes for all four of them (a bench seat, with a strictly temporary middle seat, is actually standard).

It’s almost better in the back, too. It sits on exactly the same wheelbase (and tracks) as the 7-series, so there’s plenty of space, but it’s been cleverly worked on. The design of the dash and front doors flows beautifully into the rear, where the seats adjust fore and aft individually and so do their backrests. And BMW has rediscovered the joy of oddments storage space in the cabin.

BMW makes much of the rear hatch, which has a small opening that doesn’t crack the passenger bulkhead and a big one that does, but the important thing is that the space is very flexible, with up to 1700 litres with the rear seats folded down.

All of that would mean nothing if the chassis wasn’t this astonishingly good. At 1960kg, the 530d GT has every excuse to be a floppy mess. It isn’t.

Dynamic Drive Control, which tweaks the gearbox, throttle and steering maps and the dampers, is standard and ranges from Comfort to Sport+ programs. Forget the extremes (Comfort is too wallowing and Sport+ is too aggressive on bump) and keep it inside Normal and Sport and you’ll find a terrific chassis lurking here.

It’s balanced, it never gets unsettled, it’s quiet, the ride quality is brilliant and there’s so much poise that it’s difficult to imagine how you’d ever throw one away, aside from falling asleep in it.

Its only noticeable flaw – and, even then it’s magnified out of all proportion by the quality of everything else it does – is the thumping noise out of the rear suspension as the air spring pushes its shaft back down on broken, square-edged holes. It’s like that, we were told, because the spring rate has been set for the car to run at its maximum load, which is 600kg heavier than as tested.

Should I buy one?

That depends on a lot of things about you, such as what you need, what you don’t need and how big your parking space is.

Don’t automatically nay-say it, though, because it doesn't feel like a 5 Series and it doesn't feel like an X5, either. The driver’s hip point sits exactly between them, and so does the whole feel of the car.

The front suspension is pure 7 Series, the rear is from the next generation of 5 Series Touring and somehow they’ve been combined to make the GT feel as though it does indeed occupy its own turf, yet it still feels like a BMW.

It ends up being a car that is just so crackingly good that you forget everything BMW has tried to convince you of and just respect is as a superbly engineered machine. Because it is.

Definitely a drive-it-before-you-discount-it proposition.

Michael Taylor

Join the debate

Comments
40

6 September 2009

Sounds like yet another great car from BMW. I was expecting autocar to shoot it down as it is an easy target with the huge amount of pro-British, anti-BMW readers of Autocar. It looks like just as with the X6, BMW has made yet another winner here. Yeah, you are complaining about high fuel consumption yet you were doing 124mph!

6 September 2009

[quote blasos1983]an easy target with the huge amount of pro-British, anti-BMW readers of Autocar.[/quote]

Quite right! I'm so pro-British I last bought a British car in 1990! That said, at £40,810 this is still a crock of sh*te; it'll sell by the ship load...

Stick £40k in Autotrader and see what stunning cars you can get instead.

  • If you want to know about a car, read a forum; that's a real 'long term test'

6 September 2009

Surely I'm not the only one to notice the apparent need for a rear facing periscope on your new GT? The rear window (slot!) looks incredibly difficult to see out of when reversing... or is there a rear mounted camera lens mounted in the rear hatch?

I will believe everything that the tester says about the driving experience of this GT 530d, but does it really add anything that is not within the remit of the current 5-series Touring, let alone the next one (2010?). The comment on it's short range (in a Grand Tourer? and fuel thirst, remind me of the X6 - perhaps that is the strand of X6 DNA that is included in this car!

Come on BMW! I love most of your cars and have owned a number (E34 535i, E34 M5, E36 M3 Coupe, E46 330i Coupe)and currently E39 M5). This pastiche I do not think I will like at all...

PS: Stylistically it reminds me of a rather bulky copy of a Rover SD1, or do I mean a Rover 820 Hatchback?

6 September 2009

Good thing the dash is absolutely gorgeous and inside is a nice place to be because once you have parked the car and stepped out you will be reminded how cr*p this car looks!


6 September 2009

What a waste of resources! It won't be long until BMW start producing cars that fill the points of the triangle! It is actually ridiculous. Im sure BMW could produce a convertible van that is equally as comfortable on the racetrack as it is four wheel driving that has great driving dynamics but that doesnt mean it is a great car. Regardless of how it drives, it is utterly pointless.

6 September 2009

Well, I suppose BMW cannot resist all this marketing speak! It's a 5 series hatchback with raised suspension!

Hype aside, good for them if the Germans have identified a new niche to exploit.

6 September 2009

[quote wallabytoo]Stylistically it reminds me of a rather bulky copy of a Rover SD1, or do I mean a Rover 820 Hatchback?[/quote]

Yep, they must have pulled out some old drawings!

With Audi doing a five door hatch, lets hope the other manufacturers don't try to jump on the non existant band wagon

It's an expemsive pointless car

6 September 2009

OK - so I've actually seen and sat in one of these. In the metal it looks fantastic and the interior is simply stunning.

Until you have seen on - reserve judgement, trust me!

6 September 2009

Another car iteration from BMW, another luxury 5 door hatch from the Germans, ie including Audi. Is it a new idea and a mould breaker? no, Rover's SD1 was here 30 years ago, I suppose this is BMW's updated version of the SD1 and may even have worn a Rover badge if they still owned them, likewise Audi had their own 100 Avant hatchback in the '70s. So they weren't wrong in the 70's. Both cars are are beautifully engineered versions of their current cars, interior looks nice in this BM but will reserve judgement about the looks until I see one on the road, like the current 5 series saloon and a lesser extent the front of the Jag XF, they do grow on you when you see enough of them. There will probably be a market for these cars. I can't wait for spy Autocars' spyshots of VW's Bentley Mulsanne and BM's Rolls Royce Ghost hatch/touring/CC/Speesdsters appearing soon!!

6 September 2009

Caution! Panzer attack!

BMW, the war is finished!

No comment...

For blasos1983 :

I like BMW, finally the true BMW...

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

  • 2016 Hyundai I30 1.4 Turbo prototype
    First Drive
    30 August 2016
    We get early access to the third-generation Hyundai i30 1.4 Turbo. Does this prototype show promise?
  • Citroën C4 Grand Picasso
    First Drive
    26 August 2016
    The Citroën Grand C4 Picasso gets tweaked styling, improved tech and new personalisation options to keep it ahead of rivals
  • Car review
    26 August 2016
    Wolfsburg celebrates the GTI’s 40th with its most extreme version yet
  • Kia Optima Sportwagon
    First Drive
    25 August 2016
    New Kia estate looks the part, has good space and handles tidily, but its engine's flexibility and refinement let it down
  •  Kia Optima PHEV
    First Drive
    25 August 2016
    Plug-in hybrid Optima is a practical, tax-efficient PHEV that undercuts rivals and fulfils its main remit well, but keen drivers need not apply