From £24,8008
Revised saloon icon gets a superb engine and a more upmarket interior but less than definitive handling

Our Verdict

BMW 3 Series

The BMW 3 Series' outstanding performance and handling complete a consummate all-rounder

  • First Drive

    2016 BMW 330e iPerformance Sport review

    Plug-in-hybrid 3 Series shows the benefit of BMW's experience with the i3 and i8.
  • First Drive

    2016 BMW 330e review

    Plug-in hybrid technology for BMW's 3 Series results in the most compelling model for company car drivers yet. But is it still the driver's choice?

What is it?

A mid-life facelift for what may be the most important and enduringly popular executive car the world has ever known: the BMW 3 Series. Now a remarkable four decades old, the car was a symbol of Britain in boom throughout the 1980s, 1990s and 2000s – and its success story continues.

The current ‘F30’ generation was introduced in 2012 and continued Munich’s best traditions of outstanding performance and rear-drive handling. It also went straight to the top of our road test class rankings – where it stayed until very recently.

But with an increasingly popular Mercedes-Benz C-Class to fight off, an all-new Audi A4 arriving later this year and a fresh and desirable newcomer on the scene in the shape of the Jaguar XE, the 3 Series needs to move forward just to stand still at the moment.

In fact, standing still may not even be a guarantee of success. Thanks to the introduction of the 4 Series line and the demise of the 3 Series Coupé and Convertible, BMW’s wider 3 Series brand has undoubtedly lost a bit of its old lustre and quietly dropped out of the UK’s top 10 biggest-selling cars.

Which may partly explain the lengths to which BMW has gone with this unusually far-reaching mid-cycle update - there’s clearly a consolidation job to be done. And this is not just the usual headlights-and-bumpers revision – although new optional LED headlights and reshaped bumpers front and rear are included in it. New turbocharged petrol and diesel engines come in under the bonnet, coupled to an updated optional eight-speed automatic gearbox, while extensive changes have been made to the 3 Series’ suspension, cabin and equipment.

What's it like?

Formidable. Outstanding in lots of ways. But still the class’s benchmark on performance and handling? It’s too early to say, but the early signs aren’t universally promising.

Munich could only provide examples of the new range-topping petrol 340i for us to test drive. It's a model with a quite brilliant engine, but it's a bit-part player in a sales mix that will be utterly dominated by the more affordable and fleet-friendly four-cylinder diesels.

BMW could also only manage one vehicle specification, including an optional eight-speed automatic transmission, optional adaptive dampers, optional Variable Sport Steering, and wheels and tyres that won’t be a part of the UK sales offering. So the verdict on a 3 Series anything like the one most UK owners may eventually take delivery of will have to come later.

The 340i’s is one of a pair of turbo petrol engines that make their world debut in the facelifted 3 Series. In replacement of the four-cylinder turbo 328i comes a new 330i four-pot with 249bhp and 258lb ft, while succeeding the 335i is the 340i, which gets a new twin-scroll turbocharged 3.0-litre straight-six producing 20bhp and 37lb ft more than the last one. Elsewhere in the engine range, the all-important 320d gets a bit more power, the EfficientDynamics versions becomes a bit more efficient and there’s a plug-in hybrid version in the pipeline for 2016 – the 330e – combining 249bhp of total output with combined CO2 emissions of just 47g/km.

The overhaul to the 3 Series’ suspension has been made possible by a change to the way the car’s various combination of struts and links mount to the body. Anchored at three points previously, the car’s suspension is now secured at five separate points per corner, allowing for better rigidity and robustness from the suspension assemblies themselves and more effective support of the car’s weight.

The more solid mountings have in turn allowed BMW to increase the car’s suspension spring and damper rates without adversely affecting its refinement levels. So stiffer springs and new twin-tube dampers appear on the car as standard, with adaptive dampers continuing as an option that come in tandem with a 10mm drop in ride height.

Inside you can immediately see where BMW has attempted to counter the advances made by the likes of the Mercedes C-class and current Lexus IS on material quality. It’s hardly had a transformative effect, but the fascia and fittings have nonetheless been massaged to create an overall impression that’s now very smart, from what was formerly only broadly smart enough.

The car’s primary mouldings are nicely textured, if a bit dull and hard in places, but the decoration laid on top of them is now notably classier and more expensive-looking. Chrome accents extend across the width of the dashboard and into each door console, while oyster-coloured leathers and mouldings are available for the lower part of the fascia for the first time.

The annoying removable front cupholder cover tray is gone, replaced by a much neater sliding lid. Elsewhere, the already excellent Professional Media infotainment system has been made faster and better. It’s now 4G-compatible, configured to work with smartphone apps such as Audible, Deezer, GoPro and Spotify, and has a navigation system clever enough to learn your preferred route home and automatically guide you that way after only a handful of repeated deviations.

Which is all very well – but few who drive a BMW do so because of the excellent sat-nav. This 3 Series needs outstanding performance and handling to take its place among the all-time greats of the dynasty. And here's the sticky part: it’s not yet clear if this version has both.

The excellence of the car’s engine and transmission is beyond question. The new straight six surprises you on several fronts: with its muffled suaveness at normal operating speeds, its remarkable swell of torque from very low revs, its flexibility and freedom to rev and its outright power.

It makes the 340i a seriously fast car in full cry - as quick from standstill to 62mph as an E46 M3, in fact, and probably quite a lot quicker pulling from low revs. It’s also very frugal given its performance level. Better than 40mpg is claimed for the eight-speed auto version, and on the basis of our test route, that wouldn’t be hard to reproduce. The one shortcoming is a lack of endearing charisma or theatricality to the engine’s voice. Some owners won’t miss it – but those hoping for a proper sports saloon just might.

And, whisper this, they may very well also miss the engaging cornering balance, deft body control and uncorrupted steering of the better versions of the outgoing F30. It’s much too early to start the obituary on this car’s peerless dynamic qualifications, but they’d certainly gone missing in the case of our 340i. The car rode quietly and comfortably, but it lacked the good initial damping and lateral grip levels to take to testing roads with any distinguishing alacrity. The car still handles relatively well – but it’s far from outstanding.

BMW’s Variable Sport Steering remains the 3 Series’ biggest dynamic bugbear - it’s to be avoided on the order form at any cost. It works adequately well at high motorway speeds, and always makes the 340i feel directionally stable. The latter may well be exactly what it’s for, given Germany's liking for destricted autobahns and tightening slip roads.

But its prices for doing that are the sacrifice of any natural contact patch feedback, a clumsy return to the dead-ahead as you wind off lock and the never-ending guessing game you’re obliged to play when turning into any given corne, without really knowing how much steering angle you’ll need or how much effort it’ll take to apply it. At times, the steering becomes so heavy off-centre that you'd swear the power steering had given up altogether.

Should I buy one?

At this stage, we wouldn’t warn you off. It’s early days. Bigger-engined Threes have for a long time had a problem replicating the handling vivacity of their smaller, lighter-engined peers, and the 3 Series is no more specification-sensitive now than it has been for at least a model generation. Probably longer, if you take BMW's regrettable early runflat-shod cars into account. One badly dressed 340i - albeit with a stonking engine and an improved cabin – is no reason to conclude that Munich’s compact executive institution has somehow lost its way.

But on this evidence, it’s certainly worth taking several lengthy test drives, and even greater care with your order form, to ensure your new 3 Series represents the very best of what BMW has brought to the sports saloon market for the past four decades. Because on handling at least, there is now the very real chance that you’ll be sold on greatness, but end up with something a long way wide of that mark.

BMW 340i auto

Location Munich; On sale now; Price £39,505; Engine 6 cyls in line, 2998cc, turbocharged, petrol; Power 322bhp at 5500-6500rpm; Torque 332lb ft at 1380-5000rpm; Gearbox 8-spd auto; Kerb weight 1615kg; 0-62mph 5.1sec; Top speed 155mph (limited); Economy 41.5mpg (combined); CO2/tax band 159g/km, 26%

Join the debate

Comments
28

17 July 2015
Wow, a review that doesn't just regurgitate accepted wisdom in cliched terms but actually describes pros and cons, notes with a caveat that further tests with a different spec may address specific concerns. Good stuff. Interesting !

17 July 2015
So, despite this 3-Series benefiting from major revisions, the largest in the model's history, it seems clear that BMW have been unable to match the XE's class-leading excellence yet alone topple it. More telling is just how far off the pace of the Jaguar the pre-facelift model was. No surprises really though as the XE is superb and just shows how far ahead of BMW Jaguar's cars are. It looks like BMW will have to wait until the next, all-new model is due to have a chance of even getting close to the XE. And although the coupe and convertible models of the 3 Series have now been spun off in to their own range, that the 3 Series is no longer a top 10 seller in the UK is recognition that buyers are finally wising up to the fact that the car isn't good, it suffers from reliability issues and is cheap feeling. BMW can no longer con buyers in to just buying the badge while a nearby franchised BMW dealer has admitted than since the XE became available to order, orders for 3 Series dropped by 30% to 35%.

17 July 2015
Saucerer wrote:

So, despite this 3-Series benefiting from major revisions, the largest in the model's history, it seems clear that BMW have been unable to match the XE's class-leading excellence yet alone topple it. More telling is just how far off the pace of the Jaguar the pre-facelift model was. No surprises really though as the XE is superb and just shows how far ahead of BMW Jaguar's cars are. It looks like BMW will have to wait until the next, all-new model is due to have a chance of even getting close to the XE. And although the coupe and convertible models of the 3 Series have now been spun off in to their own range, that the 3 Series is no longer a top 10 seller in the UK is recognition that buyers are finally wising up to the fact that the car isn't good, it suffers from reliability issues and is cheap feeling. BMW can no longer con buyers in to just buying the badge while a nearby franchised BMW dealer has admitted than since the XE became available to order, orders for 3 Series dropped by 30% to 35%.

This BMW is lighter, more economical by 5 MPG, chucks out less C02, has more interior space, is no worse built (possibly better), produces it's torque a lot lower down in the rev range and is a whole 5 grand cheaper than the equivalent XE model. I'm all for supporting British marques but exactly how do you explain the Jag being so far ahead?????

17 July 2015
gigglebug wrote:

This BMW is lighter, more economical by 5 MPG, chucks out less C02, has more interior space, is no worse built (possibly better), produces it's torque a lot lower down in the rev range and is a whole 5 grand cheaper than the equivalent XE model. I'm all for supporting British marques but exactly how do you explain the Jag being so far ahead?????

None of this matters, the Jag is fresh and exciting, not to mention it looks brilliant, as does every other modern Jaguar on the road. I'm an American and even I say that JLR has done an extraordinary job with all of their vehicles. Not only would I have an XE over every other small luxury sedan on the planet, I would also take an XF over all of the other exec sedans if I was shopping in that segment. And my wife and I are planning on buying a Discovery Sport soon. Jag is on a roll right now and its going to take a hell of a lot more than a facelifted 3 series to stop them.

17 July 2015
gillmanjr wrote:
gigglebug wrote:

This BMW is lighter, more economical by 5 MPG, chucks out less C02, has more interior space, is no worse built (possibly better), produces it's torque a lot lower down in the rev range and is a whole 5 grand cheaper than the equivalent XE model. I'm all for supporting British marques but exactly how do you explain the Jag being so far ahead?????

None of this matters, the Jag is fresh and exciting, not to mention it looks brilliant, as does every other modern Jaguar on the road. I'm an American and even I say that JLR has done an extraordinary job with all of their vehicles. Not only would I have an XE over every other small luxury sedan on the planet, I would also take an XF over all of the other exec sedans if I was shopping in that segment. And my wife and I are planning on buying a Discovery Sport soon. Jag is on a roll right now and its going to take a hell of a lot more than a facelifted 3 series to stop them.

I agree the Jaguar does look better but if I was buying on looks alone I'd be having a C class. I really don't like the line of the rear door on the XE though but it's probably a small grumble in reality. To say that none of points I made matter is just wrong. To many the more practical, more economical, less polluting and cheaper car would be the choice they would go for regardless of subjective things like aesthetics. These things matter now-a-days it would appear

17 July 2015
gillmanjr wrote:
gigglebug wrote:

This BMW is lighter, more economical by 5 MPG, chucks out less C02, has more interior space, is no worse built (possibly better), produces it's torque a lot lower down in the rev range and is a whole 5 grand cheaper than the equivalent XE model. I'm all for supporting British marques but exactly how do you explain the Jag being so far ahead?????

None of this matters, the Jag is fresh and exciting, not to mention it looks brilliant, as does every other modern Jaguar on the road. I'm an American and even I say that JLR has done an extraordinary job with all of their vehicles. Not only would I have an XE over every other small luxury sedan on the planet, I would also take an XF over all of the other exec sedans if I was shopping in that segment. And my wife and I are planning on buying a Discovery Sport soon. Jag is on a roll right now and its going to take a hell of a lot more than a facelifted 3 series to stop them.

I am surprised by gillmanjr's uncritical endorsement of the XE. XE looks brilliant? I would say it looks exceptionally bland if not exactly offensive as in most current Mercedes. And what about its uninspiring interior? We know there are many Jaguar brand loyalists out there, like Alfisti, but if they buy whatever comes out of Jag and Alfa there will be no incentive for these companies to improve. Judging from the XE, and pics of the forthcoming XF, Jag has some way to go to recapture, asthetically speaking, the magic of the XJ series 1 or even the X350

19 July 2015
abkq wrote:

I am surprised by gillmanjr's uncritical endorsement of the XE. XE looks brilliant? I would say it looks exceptionally bland if not exactly offensive as in most current Mercedes. And what about its uninspiring interior? We know there are many Jaguar brand loyalists out there, like Alfisti, but if they buy whatever comes out of Jag and Alfa there will be no incentive for these companies to improve. Judging from the XE, and pics of the forthcoming XF, Jag has some way to go to recapture, asthetically speaking, the magic of the XJ series 1 or even the X350

I will admit that I don't think the XE is the best looking car out there, nor is it even the best looking in the class, I think the Cadillac ATS takes that crown at the moment. But I completely disagree with you about Jag's interiors. They are simple, yes, and some people (you included apparently) would even say they are boring or uninspired. On the contrary I find them to be very elegant and understated.

19 July 2015
Yes, I like Cadillac's razor sharp edgy styling. But Cadillacs are not imported into the UK (All previous attempts at reviving the brand having failed) If the XE dashboard were more coherently designed I would have agreed with you, but elements don't relate to each other eg. the strange shape of the airvents at the extremities of the dashboard, and the chrome surround on either side of the centre console that widens and twists in the most arbitrary manner ... These unsettling details I find offputting.

17 July 2015
Saucerer wrote:

So, despite this 3-Series benefiting from major revisions, the largest in the model's history, it seems clear that BMW have been unable to match the XE's class-leading excellence yet alone topple it. More telling is just how far off the pace of the Jaguar the pre-facelift model was. No surprises really though as the XE is superb and just shows how far ahead of BMW Jaguar's cars are. It looks like BMW will have to wait until the next, all-new model is due to have a chance of even getting close to the XE. And although the coupe and convertible models of the 3 Series have now been spun off in to their own range, that the 3 Series is no longer a top 10 seller in the UK is recognition that buyers are finally wising up to the fact that the car isn't good, it suffers from reliability issues and is cheap feeling. BMW can no longer con buyers in to just buying the badge while a nearby franchised BMW dealer has admitted than since the XE became available to order, orders for 3 Series dropped by 30% to 35%.

Haha! NICE! You crack me up!

17 July 2015
A balanced review indeed. But the 'Our Verdict' praises the outstanding performance and handling, which is not what Matt says. And why is it amazing that there have been 3 Series around for 40 years?!

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week