Mark Tisshaw
11 July 2012

What is it?

After launching last year with a limited choice of engines and trim levels, the BMW 1-series range is now beginning to expand. Headlining the latest price lists are the new 125i and 125d models in M Sport trim.

We tested the VW Golf GTI-rivalling 125i last month, and now it’s the turn of the GTD rival, the 125d.

The 125d gets the new 2.0-litre turbodiesel engine that has also been added to the X1 range. The 125d replaces the 123d, and is the latest part of BMW’s deeply impressive EfficientDyanmics program. It’s an engine that boasts 215bhp and 332lb ft, but still returns a claimed 58.9mpg and emits just 126g/km when equipped with the optional eight-speed ZF automatic gearbox tested here.

What is it like?

It’s certainly not without appeal. The heart may push you towards the petrol-powered 125i, but the head is always going to push towards the oil-burning 125d.

The 125d’s engine is a sterling example of just how far diesel technology has come in recent years, and to prove the point it’s just as quick from 0-62mph as the 125i. The eight-speed auto also has a happy knack of selecting the right gear at the right time, whether you’re sprinting away from traffic lights or need to perform a quick overtake when settled into a motorway cruise.

We managed just over 50mpg on our test route, which is impressive considering how hard the powertrain’s plentiful and wide-ranging torque encourages you to drive.

The M Sport upgrades are a mixed blessing. Visually, they give it more purpose than the dowdy-looking regular car. But as is typical in the UK, the combination of M Sport’s large alloys, low-profile tyres and firm suspension settings result in a ride that’s far too firm, particularly around town. This is even taking into account the optional adaptive M Sport dampers our test car was fitted with.

And despite the straight-line performance, it’s just not that fun to drive. The sense of driver involvement from the chassis that you’d expect from larger 3-series is absent in the 1. Push it hard and all you’ll be rewarded with is understeer.

Should I buy one?

The 125d is not going to be short of buyers. It’s desirable and has the performance to match its hot hatch looks. And that performance comes guilt-free, too, given how economical it is.

It’s just a shame it’s not as fun going around corners as it is in a straight line.

BMW 125d M Sport

Price: £29,310; 0-62mph: 6.5sec; Top speed: 149mph; Economy: 58.9mpg; CO2: 126g/km; Kerb weight: 1480kg; Engine: 4cyls, 1995cc, turbodiesel; Power: 215bhp at 4400rpm; Torque: 332lb ft at 1500-2500rpm; Gearbox: 8-spd automatic

 

Join the debate

Comments
10

-

48 weeks 6 days ago

This engine is brilliant, but it's in a car that really does let it down, especially if the handling is as it says in the review. The looks are unforgivable, too.

Is this even a review?

48 weeks 6 days ago

This is one of the worst reviews I've ever read, it doesn't tell me anything about the way the car drives.  

 

Maybe...

48 weeks 5 days ago

ewallace1 wrote:

This is one of the worst reviews I've ever read, it doesn't tell me anything about the way the car drives.  

#

Or you could read between the lines... i.e. nothing that much to say about it - it's good, flawless and a bit like a AEG Washing Machine...

Understeer

48 weeks 5 days ago

Mark

450Nm in a RWD hatchback, and you complain of understeer! Boy, you need a few driving lessons.

L

he is not the only

48 weeks 5 days ago

journalist that needs driving lessons.

In fact, I recently tried an Audi A4 quattro that many of these journalists considered understeery. I would love to take a few of them as passengers to show them that it's their problem and the car does not understeer at all.

Mark

 

BMW 125d

48 weeks 5 days ago

Lapps and zetapiscium, I know exactly what you mean!

When they tested a 123d in 2007 they moaned about understeer, but I have one and I don't find it a problem.

At the same time they mention a Golf GTD as a rival - really; it only makes about 170 bhp I think, so is only close to being a rival to the 120d and if understeer is an issue in the 1 Series then it must be a nightmare in the Golf (and the dearer but no better Audi version).

And yet Autocar rave about the new 135i, but it is not that different from other 1 Series so surely that understeers too?

To be honest the most significant difference seems to be who tested it - maybe RWD cars need to be driven only by those with some RWD experience.

125d and 135i

48 weeks 4 days ago

@toptidy:

They mentioned something about the 135i in the last review. Essentially the fact that it has too much rear grip so it does not oversteer. I can relate to that because I have the same experience with my 330d in summer with the staggered setup. Not in winter, with the square set up: more fun to drive and at least 5% more economical due to the less grip.

I was thinking earlier on: looks (read as bigger wheels, staggered setup) do not always equate to better driving experience.

 

How are we supposed to take

48 weeks 8 hours ago

How are we supposed to take these reviews seriously when this review slates the suspension as too firm and the chassis as unrewarding when the 125i review linked from this very page says the opposite? Same chassis, same M sport suspension.

zetapiscium

47 weeks 5 days ago

zetapiscium wrote:

@toptidy:

They mentioned something about the 135i in the last review. Essentially the fact that it has too much rear grip so it does not oversteer. I can relate to that because I have the same experience with my 330d in summer with the staggered setup. Not in winter, with the square set up: more fun to drive and at least 5% more economical due to the less grip.

I was thinking earlier on: looks (read as bigger wheels, staggered setup) do not always equate to better driving experience.

 

Maybe that is why my 123d is as good as it is; it is an SE model but has the Dynamic pack so although it has the M Sport suspension the tyres are "only" 205/50 x 17's.

Personally I think the obsession with fitting over-wide rubber band profile tyres is only an aesthetic consideration; it ruins the ride and the handling at the same time (Audi Sportline must be sponsored by the dental profession)!

This would seem to be borne out by the road test of the Toyota GT-86 (strangely not yet online) where the fitting of "only" 215/45 x 17 tyres seems to be viewed as a good thing dynamically.

I have a work colleague with a 2007 Astra 1.8 Sri which has ridiculous 225/45 x 17 tyres, but with barely 125 bhp you probably could not break traction from a standing start unless you had stolen it (and why would you)!

The exterior is quite

33 weeks 2 days ago

The exterior is quite impressive but I am still confused about the car.  Still  I doubt whether one should buy it or not ?It is all mixed reactions which is making it difficult to decide.

BMW Repair Los Angeles

 

 

Please register or login to post a comment.

Our Verdict

Measures up on comfort and space, but it’s still boring to drive

Driven this week

  • Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid

    First drive review: Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid

    First drive
    18 June 2013 9:02pm

    The Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid is the world's most advanced luxury petrol-electric hybrid, but can it live up to its 91mpg billing?

  • Maserati Ghibli diesel first drive review

    Maserati Ghibli Diesel first drive review

    First drive
    18 June 2013 11:02am

    The new Maserati Ghibli is a premium saloon, based on the same root architecture as the Quattroporte, that's designed to rival the BMW 5-series

  • Tesla Model S

    Tesla Model S

    Car review
    17 June 2013

    It's the world's most appealing electric car – but does that make it an appealing car?

  • Aston Martin DB9

    Aston Martin DB9

    Car review
    17 June 2013

    The Aston Martin DB9 matches the emotion of a Ferrari but it adds practicality and offers an experience unmatched for versatility and all-round appeal

  • 2013 Nissan 370Z Nismo first drive review

    2013 Nissan 370Z Nismo first drive review

    First drive
    14 June 2013

    Nissan 370Z Nismo adds some harder-core appeal, but it feels like too little too late for Nissan’s street-fighting Z