Fri
Feb 26 2010

Jag XJ: the limo that thinks it's a sports car

Matt Saunders
By now you’ve probably read our reviews of the various new versions of Jaguar’s 2010 XJ.

If one thread runs through all of them, it’s the one marvelling at the unlikeliness of this car’s transformation from old-fashioned, old-English luxury conveyance to modern thoroughbred sports saloon.



To understand the completeness of this metamorphosis, you need to get stuck into a few of the gorey details pertaining to this great big Brit four-door.

For starters, the XJ’s got the same steering rack as an XFR; only its longer wheelbase and slightly softer chassis makes it any less agile than the smaller M5-basher.

Next, there’s a mass issue to consider: because an aluminium XJ Supersports actually weighs less than the largely steel, identically engined XFR. If it’s any slower, therefore – and it isn’t much slower – it’s because of the way the larger car’s drivetrain and running gear are configured.

Then there’s the more sophisticated ‘Dynamic’ chassis mode that the XJ has relative to the XF. When you press the button marked with the chequered flag in the XJ, you get slightly meatier steering feel as well as higher-rate damping and sharper pedal response.

Stick the transmission in ‘S’ mode and you also get a more sporting software setting for the automatic gearbox. Tug on a paddle to enter manual mode and you’ll find that even the diesel version of this car will hold a gear right up to the engine’s redline, giving you total manual control of the car’s gearshifts.

Also, that gearbox is clever enough to delay a downshift, rather than aborting it without letting the driver know. Say you’re braking hard into a corner, and click twice on the left-hand paddle in quick succession to go from 4th to 2nd.

In most flappy paddle ‘boxes you’ll only get 3rd, because the software involved makes a decision that you’re going too fast for 2nd at the moment the command is made. The XJ’s ‘box, however, recognises that you’re slowing down, and delivers the change into 2nd at the point at which it becomes possible without over-revving the engine. Jaguar calls that ‘bending the shift line.’

That’s just one of the ways that they make this 5.2-metre executive saloon feel like a proper driver’s car: it’s one of the many lengths they’ve gone to in the process of giving the XJ the same dynamic DNA that you’ll find in an XK or XF.

If you ask me, they have emphatically succeeded in creating a large executive saloon that transcends the normal restrictions and definitions of its class. This is a Porsche Panamera Turbo and Aston Martin Rapide rival; it makes a Mercedes S-class look boring and obsolete.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Matt Saunders

Was a news boy, web reporter and general staff dogs body before two stints as Autocar’s features editor. Now holds enviable status as a road tester for the magazine that invented the format, and is developing a hankering for a fast motorbike.

Comments

Dan McNeil v2 February 26, 2010 11:23 AM

But the secondary and long distance ride is inferior to the previous model, which makes this just a wannabe German sports saloon.

nicksheele February 26, 2010 12:29 PM

'gorey details' - does Al Gore come with the car?

Peter Cavellini February 26, 2010 2:26 PM

So turning it into a Ford Granada from a distance was a brilliant idea, was it?

ThwartedEfforts February 26, 2010 2:33 PM

What Dan said.

Someone at Jaguar clearly thought it'd be a super idea to do what Jerry was doing in terms of appearance and ride (i.e. brassy and bad respectively), and look what's happened: while they were all in committee meetings working out just how far to stretch the car's backside, their German rivals twigged that the world was heading into what the media nauseatingly refer to as an 'age of austerity' and immediately begun ditching all the gaudiness and gimcrackery in preference for more old fashioned designs and a ride that was soothing rather than sporty. Jaguar were already there - they could have ditched the worn out Lawson shape for something not quite so 'arsey' and hey presto, an XJ for the modern world.

An another thing, who the heck spends upwards of £80K to 'enjoy' a long wheelbase diesel limo? Seriously? Giving up the company's world-beating secondary ride for an ability to carve new Teutonic lines on corners is pure madness. If you want a car that drives like a German one, you tend to buy a German car.

cornflakes99 February 26, 2010 3:30 PM

Jaguar have just invented the greatest car in history!

this thing can shape shift, because so far it's been

a Ford Granada

a Citroen  

a Kia

a Lincoln

a Ford Mondeo

a maserati quattroporte

a Morris Marina

a bangle butt BMW wannabe

now if that's not talent I don't know what is!

anyway I'm off to smoke some crack now to catch up with you guys

I bet I'll see a soccermom mini-van, that cameleon callum's one talent boy!

CambsBill February 26, 2010 7:11 PM

cornflakes 99:

The wheels look awfully familiar as well, I'm sure I've seen some just like that on some other car, all round & with a strip of rubber all the way round it.

DKW February 26, 2010 8:29 PM

'The wheels look awfully familiar as well, I'm sure I've seen some just like that on some other car, all round & with a strip of rubber all the way round it.'

Thanks CambsBill, that bought a smile to my face at the end of the week.

scrap February 26, 2010 8:45 PM

Wow, there's a lot of mealy-mouthed comments on here. You Autocar regulars are an angry bunch, eh?

It seems that Jaguar has pitched the XJ just perfectly. The 3.0d on 18 inch wheels will do the City limo role just fine, according to Matt, with a ride and interior that will match the German opposition.

But spec it up, and you get a classy, desirable alternative to the Porsche, Maserati and Bentley.

This will mean halo cars on the road in Europe, and satisfy buyers in the US (who want to drive themselves) and status-conscious businessmen worldwide.

Dan McNeil v2 February 26, 2010 9:18 PM

scrap February 26, 2010 8:45 PM:

"Wow, there's a lot of mealy-mouthed comments on here. You Autocar regulars are an angry bunch, eh?"

No, we're an intelligent, discerning and irreverent bunch.  How about you?

------------------

scrap February 26, 2010 8:45 PM:

"The 3.0d on 18 inch wheels will do the City limo role just fine, according to Matt, with a ride and interior that will match the German opposition.

And "match is the key word in your post.   You see, in the past, Jaguar's secondary and primary ride far exceeded that of the opposition.   Jaguar's ride was its USP.   Now, according to Autocar's tests, the fabled Jaguar secondary ride has been "dialled out" in the pursuit of German-style handling.    

Jaguar may well have matched the Germans in the handling stakes (a full road test comparison will determine this), but let me ask you a simple question - is it enough for this new XJ to simply "match" the German opposition in the ride department, when the previous model far exceeded them?

CambsBill February 26, 2010 9:38 PM

If they've made it ride & handle more like the XF - which is how I'm reading it rather than 'it's the same as the Germans' - then I for one will be very happy.  The old XJ was that bit too soft for my liking.  Passengers loved it for sure, but for driving involvement it sounds like Jag have moved in the right direction.  

By the way, the Portfolio rides on 20" wheels compared to, say, the 17" or 18" the S350 starts with.  Any head to head tests should be on the same size rims to see which rides the best

Dan McNeil v2 February 26, 2010 9:51 PM

CambsBill February 26, 2010 9:38 PM:

"The old XJ was that bit too soft for my liking.  Passengers loved it for sure, but for driving involvement it sounds like Jag have moved in the right direction.  

-------------

Fair point, except...don't you think more than a few drives loved the smooth, wafty ride as well?  Wouldn't that have been one reason they bought/leased/stole the car in the first place?    Where do these drivers go now that the new XJ has been transformed into a German-riding clone?

cornflakes99 February 26, 2010 11:50 PM

CambsBill:

My comments were actually meant to be sarcastic, read the posts and you'll see, it looks like a Volvo, it looks like marina...blah,blah

I'm absolutely stunned by the lack of love for this car, one gem of a post had the XK as noisy, uncomfortable & slow, the XF, yes XF as Volvo looking and just a rebadged mondeo, don't ask! care in the community has obviously rounded up the village idiots for a day trip to an Internet cafe.

Put me down for a Supersport in Caviar Metallic & Kasuga wheels & I'll be more than happy,,,now where's my wallet???

cornflakes99 February 26, 2010 11:54 PM

Dan McNeil v2:

"Where do these drivers go now that the new XJ has been transformed into a German-riding clone?"

What all six of them!

shortbread February 27, 2010 8:23 AM

The wafty previous generation XJ's only quality was that if had a soft ride and this did not garner it much sales.

This car is a huge improvement, it looks like it belongs to this period rather than sticking to a half attempted effort at British nostalgia.

It looks brilliant as well. People talk as if the German saloons are a work of art, but we instead have staid looking A8 and S and a really ugly 7 series. This XJ is by far the best looking of the bunch.

CambsBill February 27, 2010 9:16 AM

Cornflakes99:

And I was taking your sarcasm and raising you one, given that the new car's been compared to just about everything barring a VW Beetle so far (or did I miss that post).  

I am also stunned at the negative reaction on this site, although also a tad suspicious as there are an awful lot of new posters suddenly popping up just to bung in some frankly daft criticism.

Me, mine arrives in early May - Botanic Green Portfolio diesel.

CambsBill February 27, 2010 9:24 AM

Dan McNeil v2:

I'm sure you're right Dan, but there weren't enough of those drivers buying the X350, lovely as it was (and I've just sold mine after 20,000 faultless miles in it).  Jaguar are clearly aiming for a younger market these days and those drivers by & large are looking for a more dynamic driving experience.

The reviews out so far - and yes, they're first looks with no head to heads - all seem to be concluding that the XJ has a superior handling/comfort balance than the opposition, not that it's walked away from comfort completely.

CambsBill February 27, 2010 9:32 AM

Just read elsewhere that JLR have posted a £39m profit in Q4 of 2009, with both sides of the business showing strong gains.  Not bad considering the old XJ stopped production in the quarter.

softlove010 February 27, 2010 5:43 PM

hello dear friend

How are you today , i know that all is well with you

My name is Gift ,I am a female,I was impressed when i saw your profile  and will like to establishe a long lasting relationship with you. In addition,i will like you to reply me through my private e mail box here is it;(giftbaby09@yahoo.com) Thanks waiting to hear from you soonest.

Gift

Please contact me with my Email address here is it.(giftbaby09@yahoo.com)

Chips March 1, 2010 8:01 AM

Hmm - a lot of rose tintery going on for the X350, along with claims of a wonderful ride.

The X350 never rode as well as is alluded to above. Air suspension and low kerb weight never make happy bedfellows  - proven by the fact that the XJs low speed urban ride was crap (and mentioned in practically every X350 road test I've ever read). All air suspension systems are hobbled by the damper friction that has to be overcome before damper starts to work. This means that pock marked surfaces and the usual urban lumps and bumps are not absorbed by the suspension, but channeled straight into the car. The last X350 I drove ( a late 2006 4.2 Sovereign with standard 19s !!) was very disappointing in that respect and put me off the X350 for good.

Fact is, the old X204 was the best riding and smoothest Jag you could get at the time and I would never have had an X350 over one of those. The 4.2 V8 SE was superb.

scrap March 1, 2010 9:39 AM

@ Dan McNeil v2,

Well, nice to know you think of yourself as "intelligent, discerning and irreverent". So humble!

Judging by your reply to me, "condescending" seems most appropriate.

6th.replicant March 1, 2010 6:05 PM

Matt Saunders:

"Also, that gearbox is clever enough to delay a downshift, rather than aborting it without letting the driver know. Say you’re braking hard into a corner, and click twice on the left-hand paddle in quick succession to go from 4th to 2nd.

...The XJ’s ‘box, however, recognises that you’re slowing down, and delivers the change into 2nd at the point at which it becomes possible without over-revving the engine. Jaguar calls that ‘bending the shift line.’"

Hasn't the Aston DB9's paddleshift version of the ZF 6-speed autobox been able to perform 'skip downshifts' since its launch? Curious, you'd think that Jag's paddleshift autobox would have always had this facility, considering Jag & Aston's former Ford PAG tie-up?

Dan McNeil v2 March 1, 2010 8:57 PM

"scrap March 1, 2010 9:39 AM

@ Dan McNeil v2,

Well, nice to know you think of yourself as "intelligent, discerning and irreverent". So humble!

Judging by your reply to me, "condescending" seems most appropriate."

-------------------

Not humble - just a fact.  And if you can be bothered to read before posting, you'll note that I referred to we Autocar readers (plural), not me, an Autocar reader (singular).

shortbread March 2, 2010 1:55 AM

Dan,

why don't u keep your self proclaimed intelligence to yourself, rest of the Autocar readers don't require you to think on their behalf.

Its understood that you dont like Jags, fair to discuss this as well, but quit declaring its the same with everyone else.

I for one quite like this car and the direction in which Jag is moving at the moment.

Dan McNeil v2 March 2, 2010 7:25 AM

"shortbread March 2, 2010 1:55 AM

Dan,

why don't u keep your self proclaimed intelligence to yourself, rest of the Autocar readers don't require you to think on their behalf.

Its understood that you dont like Jags, fair to discuss this as well, but quit declaring its the same with everyone else.

I for one quite like this car and the direction in which Jag is moving at the moment."

-------------

Shortbread - looks like you're another one who is unable to read a post properly before hitting the keyboard.   Now - step away from the keyboard, go back to my post and read it again.  Nowhere in my post do I claim to speak for other Autocar readers regarding my opinion of this Jaguar.  Trust this is clear.

SDR March 2, 2010 12:19 PM

Pathetic.  

Not the car - just half of the comments above.

Car seems wonderful to me - about time Jaguar caught up with their market.  For those maintaining that Jaguar have somehow failed in making this car a credible alternative to German rivals, wake up!  German rivals sell many times Jaguar volumes because Jaguar's priorities have not aligned with those of the majority of people with the money to buy one - that is a poor business model in this industry.  Just because you and a few thousand others may appreciate an old fashioned motorised sofa with a small boot and no rear leg/head room does not mean that it is the right car to build, when Jaguar needs to compete globally and sells 75% of its production outside the UK.

This strikes me as the only sensible direction Jaguar could take, and it appears they've done it very well.  Obviously it pains most people on here to say anything positive about anything other than themselves... but then I rather doubt many of you will ever be in a position to buy the car anyway so your opinion, rather like mine, is of little importance.  Except of course to yourselves, and to your joyless little band of "regulars"...  :)

Latebreaker March 2, 2010 12:57 PM

The All New XJ is a triumph!!! The design has grown on me since its release in July.....Its Stunning.

Im dissapointed to read a few negative comments.

The interior is the best in its class by a mile, the mood lighting, unique color trim options, competitive pricing and great looks makes this a no brainer.

Ok it may discourage the tradtional Jag buyer....is that really a bad thing?

Its built here in the UK and something we should be proud of!

I'll have to wait a few years however to get one, you know how depreication affects luxury cars...more to our benefit!

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - cover 15.2.12

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>