Tue
Nov 03 2009

Car connectivity: does it matter?

Vicky Parrott
How important is a car’s user interface? I don’t mean the physical switchgear, I mean the electronic system through which you connect your phone, choose your music, and generally make your car a personal haven.

I drove an Infiniti EX37 recently – my first experience of Nissan’s new premium brand. As well as thoroughly enjoying the drive, I was also amazed at how easy it was to connect all the essential gadgets.



It took less than a minute to get my phone connected via Bluetooth (search via the phone, put in the code on the car’s screen and you’re sorted), and then you just plug your iPod in and choose what you want to listen to on the touch screen.

When I got back in the car, my phone connected automatically and it took me marginally more time to plug in my iPod than it did to do my seatbelt up. Both connections are standard, simple and effective.

It was this ease of use, as much as the pungent leather and swanky analogue clock that really conveyed a sense of the Infiniti being a high-quality car.

So why in a Mazda 3 do I have to spend 15 minutes at the side of the road talking at a voice command system, going through various sub menus and shouting “pair phone” at the dashboard only to find that it finally connects, giving you a tantalising glimpse of the hands-free communication you’re hoping for, and then disconnects again. With no warning from the smug woman residing behind the radio fascia.

Would it not be easier for the car to display a message on its LED screen giving a code, which can then be tapped into the phone? You don’t need a six-inch sat nav screen to do that. The 3’s standard display would manage fine. There are better connections in plenty of similarly positioned rivals.

Of course, many people don’t care about this. Just select Magic FM and you’re there. But I don’t think manufacturers should underestimate the importance of this connectivity stuff.

The Lexus LS600h costs over £84,000. That doesn’t include an auxiliary input, let alone a USB connection. I realise that the typical LS buyer (or chauffeur) may not be that interested in MP3 players, but it’s very narrow minded to assume that someone who’s impressed by a car with a Mark Levinson sound system isn’t going to want to connect an iPod. To put it in perspective, remember that our Hyundai i10 has an auxiliary input as standard.

The car industry is slowly catching up with the iPod revolution, and for every impossible interface in production there is another that will impress.

Only if a car is designed for track days is it acceptable for it to not be able to my playlists.

With those few exceptions, I know that I wouldn’t buy a car that didn’t play my music and connect to my phone.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , ,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Vicky Parrott

Turned up for work experience here in 2005 and never went home. Loves lightweight track cars, Japanese performance cars and Le Mans. Hopes to own a Metro 6R4 one day.

Comments

ThwartedEfforts November 3, 2009 6:11 PM

I used to tick all the "communications" options when buying (though Benz never offered Bluetooth until recently, even on the S-Class, instead charging you the earth for a 'pre-wire' phone install and cradle) but now I simply don't bother.

I have no interest in connecting a phone because I've come to appreciate the relative isolation that travelling by car brings, and I'm not interested in skipping around ten thousand tunes from an MP3 player when you can burn 150 tracks to a 25p writeable CD for each journey - the actual duration of 125 tracks played back to back exceeding the length of any journey you can make within the UK. Exactly how much choice do you need?

The fact you wouldn't buy a car that didn't play music and didn't connect to your phone makes me question whether driving still motivates you - with all these toys to distract us it's become a minority interest.

Starscraper November 3, 2009 6:16 PM

I wish the phone manufacturers would sort out their end of the connectivity issue. I used to have a Nokia that would auto connect with my Leon's Bluetooth system when the ignition was turned on, it wouldn't however let the phonebook be displayed on the MFD. Now I have a Samsung that doesn't auto connect but does allow the phonebook to be displayed.

theonlydt November 3, 2009 6:18 PM

I have to admit I think all cars should come with an aux input (3.5mm), but sometimes these USB interfaces are more trouble than they are worth. They won't work with certain generation ipods, or they'll only work with ipods and not other competitor devices etc etc.

As for bluetooth - it was a good connectivity idea gone wrong. Too many manufacturers of devices all trying to put their own spin on it which led to massive incompatibility. I don't use bluetooth, I don't like it. If people want to speak to me when I'm driving they can leave a message, send a text for me to read when I've arrived or just wait until I'm not driving and then ring me. The reason for this: when I'm not at work I'm not at work anymore. I refuse blackberry things, I don't want to be able to read my work e-mails every hour of the day, be beeped when something happens, be contactable by work collegues about work 24/7. Some people like that, some people have to have that in their jobs, good for them - 90% of us need to stop the gradual technological creep that has us increasing our dependency on our workplaces rather than letting us lead our own lives.

BriMarsh November 3, 2009 8:52 PM

My phone is always in the boot; no call is so important I need to be distracted from driving.  And my current car has a tape deck, which has been an excellent opportunity to rediscover my cassette collection from the 80's.

Connectivity? Bah-humbug.

slackboy November 3, 2009 9:27 PM

To a certain extent I don't care - as long as in 2,3 or 10 years the in-car audio/comms can  be upgraded to whatever is new.

My 2003 passat came with a cassette player but now has bluetooth/aux input/usb interface and ipod connectity simply because the stereo is standard single DIN unit that I could replace.

most of the cars built in the last 3-5 years won't be so easy to upgrade when the time comes.

I did get the bluetooth to connect my phone but now never connect the phone - I also value the private time in the car.

suman November 3, 2009 9:56 PM

Are you sure about the lack of Aux input on the LS600h? My LS460 had one in the centre console under the driver's armrest.

But when you can play up to 6 MP3 CDs with a shuffle function, it's not so bad. But I agree that full iPod connectivity would have been nice.

kr38 November 3, 2009 10:32 PM

my 09 honda accord ex connects to either my wife's or my phones (nokia and iphone) automatically as soon as one of us gets in the car. the ipod lives in the armrest and is connected by usb with all the playlists shown on the sat nav screen. it all works so easily i've grown to take it for granted. at least i had until i bought a 2001 saab as a second car and now get bored stiff in london's traffic jams.

chris333 November 3, 2009 11:49 PM

You can get an ipod adapter for any Lexus for a couple of hundred quid. If I was able to get them to throw it in when I bought my 2year old IS, I'm sure getting it a spart of a deal for an LS should be no problem!

chandrew November 4, 2009 7:56 AM

I have an ipod connector in one car and wish it was a simple Aux-in connection.  The interface on the stereo is a poor shadow of the one on the ipod and by connecting the ipod I can no longer control music via the ipod.  

For me the best solution would be to ditch the car stereo altogether (well apart from a power amp and speakers), and let me run everything from apps on the ipod  - music, GPS and all.  I have more faith in a teenager in his bedroom writing more useful functionality than a car company with armies of 'resources'.

Will this happen?  Of course not, selling these electronics options is far too profitable for the car companies.  

TegTypeR November 4, 2009 12:09 PM

What ever happened to the good old fashioned single din radio slot?

I am lucky that all of my cars have such a basic piece of equipment, in to which I can install a £150 after market radio / CD / DVD / sat nav unit, which connects to my phone immediately, plugs in to my iPod and shows me the way home with no fuss or hassle.

The best thing though....  When it all gets upgraded to Bluetooth version 27 or when they actually perfect DAB reception, I will take out the old unit and replace it with a similar but updated unit.

Simple, easy and cheap.

Lanciaman November 4, 2009 12:28 PM

As I said to the guy who asked me what sound system I had in my Integrale; "If you`ve got time to fiddle with a sound system, you`re not driving fast enough!"

 Nice to see you back on a regular basis Teg.

Quattro369 November 4, 2009 1:10 PM

The lower end of Audi's range is well behind the times stereo wise. I just bought a brand new TT and D.A.B. Radio was not even an option! The IPOD interface is rubbish and yet costs £175. It doesnt even list tracknames!

If you want Sat-Nav its a £1650 option and yet its DVD based so is slow and the CD slot cant be used at the same time as the Sat Nav. This extremely dated unit doesnt even have a hard-drive so you have to put your music onto SD cards!

Im actually considering getting an aftermarket unit.

J400uk November 4, 2009 4:39 PM

A2DP is the future. Wirelessly connects to your iPhone or whatever when you get in, streams music, sat nav voice instructions and phone calls all with no cables in site.

suman November 4, 2009 9:20 PM

Now we can all have iPods or MP3 players with thousands of songs on tap, I wonder how many different songs do you like to listen to in one go?

Personally, I have less than 100 favourite songs that I like to play in the car. The rest of my iPod library almost never gets heard.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Mag cover 3-2-10

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>