Tue
Feb 23 2010

Ferrari accuses FIA of starting a 'holy war'

Alan Henry
I’m not quite certain whether or not  Luca di Montezemolo and his fellow Ferrari directors have collectively had a bang on the head just recently or they’ve decided to try and teach a donkey to dance (first step, smack it round the head to get its attention) but the official Maranello website has gone for the FIA’s jugular in blaming the governing body’s former president Max Mosley for starting a ‘holy war’ that drove half the manufacturers out of the sport.

Clearly Maranello’s rampaging seems to have ignored the fact that BMW were useless at F1 these past couple of years, and Toyota arguably even worse, and it’s just possible that Honda were busy going nowhere as well. But Ferrari’s point is that swapping these big names for Lotus F1, Virgin Racing, Campos Meta and US F1 and a bunch of Serbians with their second-hand Toyotas is hardly a fair deal which adds credibility to the sport.



On the face of it, these manufacturers left for widely differing reasons, but Ferrari exclusively blames it all on Mosley being hell-bent on implementing a “controversial and ill-conceived” budget cap.

"Of the 13 teams who signed up – or were induced to sign up – for this year's championship, to-date only 11 of them have heeded the call, turning up on-track, some later than others, and while some have managed just a few hundred kilometres, others have done more, but at a much-reduced pace,” says a highly provocative item on the Ferrari website in the Horse Whisperer column.

"As for the twelfth team, Campos Meta 1, its shareholder and management structure has been transformed, according to rumours which have reached the Horse Whisperer through the paddock telegraph, with a sudden cash injection from a munificent white knight, well-used to this sort of last-minute rescue deal. However, the beneficiaries of this generosity might find the knight in question expects them to fulfil the role of loyal vassal.”

Can’t think who the hell this white knight might be, can you Bernie?

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Alan Henry

Our F1 expert has been covering the sport since Lewis Hamilton's father was a teenager (do the maths yourselves on that one), and writing for Autocar since 1994.

Comments

phenergn February 23, 2010 10:40 PM

"Maranello’s rampaging seems to have ignored the fact that BMW were useless at F1 these past couple of years"

Rubbish in 2009 perhaps, but didn't they come 3rd in the team rankings in 2008, with only 16 points less than Mclaren?

kcrally February 23, 2010 10:43 PM

just ban f1, and everyone goes sportscar racing.

VirginPower February 23, 2010 11:55 PM

Ferrari is absolutely right.

While there are still teams willing to spend limitless amounts of money making F1 what it should be, the FIA shouldn't legislate to strangle it.

A Formula One rendered unworthy of the name, catering to two-bit teams that can easily achieve an artificially lowered ceiling of technology, is, tragically, what we're heading towards.

The degenerated future for which the dim and unwitting are arguing is one of more and more and more and more and more overtaking of cars balked and equalised through stale regulation, to the point where the F1 grid will become indistinguishable from that of GP2.

Then, in pandering to the fatuous viewer who is no longer satisfied with having to spend one moment of a Grand Prix deprived of a passing manoeuvre (who's equally rapt, I imagine, by the reports from the BBC Twitter-Tarts on the brands of jumpers being sported in the paddock), the technology will regress again to the state of the F3 car, then the Formula Ford, then the Vietnamese Tuk-Tuk.

At that point we won't have to read reports about Schumacher anymore, as we'll be able to go and race him ourselves.

chandrew February 24, 2010 9:57 AM

Maybe the Ferrari team know something that we don't but didn't Toyota and Honda pull out because they were facing financial difficulties and realised that it was rather unsavory to have to lay off workers whilst still throwing money at an expensive activity that did little to influence the buying patterns of their core customer groups (not something that could be said for Ferrari).  I can understand BMWs desire to focus on environment as a differentiator to their market and I guess we'll see them focus on racing when there is a class which is seen as both high performance and employing environmental technologies.

What I think Ferrari are so upset about is their whole business model is about F1 technology being marketed to sell expensive road cars.  Nobody else has this model but Ferrari need a set of very competitive F1 competitors using expensive technology to justify the margins for their road cars.  The expense acts as a barrier to entry.

For me F1 shouldn't be about who can spend the most, but instead about intelligent, innovative engineering.  We saw last year when they were out-thought by Brawn - a team without sponsors nor the spend that they had that innovation can come without spending a fortune.  The issue for Ferrari is that just maybe one of these new companies will out-think them in the near future.  Intelligent rather than expensive technology doesn't fit with Ferrari's model of getting higher margins on road cars by selling expensive systems developed on the race track.  It's not in their interest for performance to come from smart changes without expensive systems that will justify high prices.

Surely Mercedes is a major manufacturer coming in with deep pockets?  Or don't they want to mention them given every advertising break on TV here seems to have a rather happy looking M.Schumacher driving a Mercedes SLS?

deppi February 24, 2010 10:16 AM

I am surprised Alan Henry didn't attach Ferrari as he usually does...

I think Ferrai have gone a little too far with their comments but the basis of it is totally right. What other sport in the world has such a baseless budget cap? What other sport has restrictions on how much you can test? Mosley messed things up but it has to be said some manufacturers would have left anyway. Let's remember this is one of the worst wolrd economic crisis of the century.

But we all know how bad and corrupted the system Mosley and the FIA used to accept these 4 new teams. How is it possible that they can't even manage to get a car on track after having pushed so hard to get in? All this reducing budgets to let new teams in and they can't even manage to do proper due diligence on them to choose them!!!

At least it should be a fun season with 4 teams that seem strong.

Last but not least to all of you who keep saying that Brawn had no money last year but still won, just remember that he had 1.5 years of full budget from Honda to prepare this car instead of fighting for a championship!

david RS February 24, 2010 6:49 PM

Yet for these past few years, Ferrari should say a big thank you to the FIA.

david RS February 24, 2010 10:19 PM

Ferrari, come back to Le Mans!

512tr February 24, 2010 10:42 PM

Ferrari are total hypocrites.

They owe the 2007 championship to the FIA and Max Mosley's hatred of Ron Dennis. If it wasn't for the fact Jean Todt kept whining on about how Ferrari had been devasted by "spygate" and how Ron and Alonso handled it, they would never have caught McLaren fair and square that year, let alone destabalise the team enough to get the driver's title as well.

Ferrari almost nicked the 2008 champoinship down to some downright dirty steward descisions including the blatant removal of Lewis from the Belgian GP win despite the fact he was within the rules when he let Raikonnen past yet still got punished. It was also notable that Raikonnen didn't have to keep all 4 wheels on the track in either the 2008 or 2009 Belgian GP's, and wasn't ever considered as having done anything wrong (while driving a Ferrari).

Now Mosley's gone though, it's great to see we can finally have some of the teams talk about him without fear of the punishment McLaren have had to face while the dictator was there, and some of the truth starts to out.

Can't help feeling that the FIA were awfully helpful (even to the point of ignoring the rules) when it was convenient for Ferrari to be an ally, and now it's not convenient, they start firing a broadside.

Why not just start selling FIA T-shirts and basball caps with a prancing horse stuck on it, that's what you're good at now isn't it Luca?

ryaner February 25, 2010 12:48 AM

512 tr

You make it sound like McLaren never did anything wrong in 2007!

"let alone destabalise the team enough to get the driver's title as well"

Are you serious? You sound like a football fan after his team lost a match "because of the ref"!

VirginPower February 25, 2010 9:34 AM

I think there might be something underlying these comments that's been overlooked.

Despite the emotive words, it's likely that this outburst is a lot more politically focused and strategic than it appears.

With an ex-Ferrari principal now in-charge of the FIA, the comments from the Horse's mouth might be aimed at paving the way for a radical shake-up in future.

It may bode well for people like me, who despair of the near-devastation of the core principles of F1 that Mosley oversaw.

This year, I doubt there will be much bleating about the lack of overtaking, since the cars are now substantially and visibly slower, and simply because of these lower speeds, the aero-barrier (so to speak) to close running will be diminished.

A technical Dark Age has reigned for too long in F1, yet there is the hope that Todt is passionate and intelligent enough to scythe through the mire with regulations (or deregulations more accurately) that will allow the sport to return to its rightful status - representing the inspirational cutting edge of mechanical science.

david RS February 25, 2010 11:22 PM

I also hope that we enter in a new era of a non piracy from the FIA.

Finally, the FIA has still managed to counter Renault and McLaren these last years.

softlove010 February 27, 2010 5:47 PM

hello dear friend

How are you today , i know that all is well with you

My name is Gift ,I am a female,I was impressed when i saw your profile  and will like to establishe a long lasting relationship with you. In addition,i will like you to reply me through my private e mail box here is it;(giftbaby09@yahoo.com) Thanks waiting to hear from you soonest.

Gift

Please contact me with my Email address here is it.(giftbaby09@yahoo.com)

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - cover 15.2.12

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>