Thu
Jun 18 2009

The new Vauxhall Astra in the flesh

Steve Cropley
My first thought, when my eye fell on the new Vauxhall Astra in the flesh for the first time, was that this was far too good a car to be killed in some kind of recession-fuelled reorganisation.

As you can read here (and in the magazine this week), the sixth generation Astra gets a bit bigger, and picks up quite a few of the high-tech features foreshadowed in the full-size Insignia, but compensates for extra bulk with a raft of improvements to powertrain efficiency, including a 1.4 litre petrol turbo engine that sips fuel and only gently exhales CO2, while performing like an old-style normally aspirated 1.8.



However, for me the obvious achievement is on the styling front. Vauxhall design boss Mark Adams has further widened the visual gulf between the ‘family’ five-door — being built now in Ellesmere Port and on the market before Christmas — and the coupe-like Sport Hatch three-door. The former now has Golf-like grace in its lines, while the latter is understood to match or even beat the sporty visage of Renault’s Megane Coupe, which to my eye looks more expensive and exclusive than it actually is.

It’s hard to believe that just a few years ago the three-door version of saloons in this class were referred to as “poverty models” or “Post Office versions”. I always thought GM Europe was a bit behind the game with its styling, ecliped by the engaging but brash sportiness of Ford, and the more considered and developed sculptural shapes of VW.

This new Astra makes me think that, visually at least, this new Astra can match them on their own ground, and that it richly deserves to succeed, whatever the economic weather.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Steve Cropley

Road tester of 35 years and columnist of 15, Steve says he’s as much in love with cars today as he was on day one. “And not just the cars, but also the industry that makes ’em.”

Comments

Audi Tastic May 13, 2009 11:09 AM

"This new Astra makes me think that, visually at least, this new Astra can match them on their own ground, and that it richly deserves to succeed, whatever the economic weather."

Styling wise it deserves to succeed, we will just have to see what happens to the platform and how the new owners affect sales.

Andrew Lee May 13, 2009 12:29 PM

I think Mark Adams (and his team) have done a good job. To me this is far prettier and more resolved than the rather contrived Insignia. But isn't there a lot of Seat Leon - or Mazda 3 - in the rear three-quarter view??

PS I've never associated "grace" with the Golf!

TegTypeR June 18, 2009 12:42 PM

I may change my mind when I see it in the flesh, but the taut lines of the current car, in both three and five door form still look better in my eyes.

Where it was original the current design is just a bit Fiat Bravo, Seat Leon, me too.

obamabeach June 18, 2009 12:58 PM

new Astra nice car - certain hit. Insignia sold out - Opel running Saturday shifts, extended working and shortened summer works holiday at Ruesselsheim plant to catch-up backlog.

Chinese crawling all over German govt. to be allowed back in to bid for Opel; Magna's now got a fight on its hands. At worst, Germans can use BAIC(state Chinese company) to leverage Magna into more concessions on size of subsidies, amount of own capital committed etc..

So from Opel being wound up and all washed up just three months ago looks now like the fastest growing auto nation on the planet is desperate to procure it for a quantum leap in state-owned auto technology and the Russians under Putin personally are likewise desperate to acquire it to 'reset' their hopelessly antiquated auto sector - both vehicle manufacturers and supplier base - into the 21st century by effectively having Opel substitute for GAZ and Lada. Interesting times to say the least.

This also highlights a)how the United States has effectively become a backwater in auto industry terms, with GM a shell of its former self and all the action now focusing westwards, in the CIS and Asia, and b)it makes de Montezemolo(of Fiat)'s talk of 6m units being the viability threshold for vehicle maunfactures look amazingly ironical, with Magna stating just that they wish to build a 6m units/year outfit out of Opel/GAZ with GM's Russian franchise over Chevrolet too and an allinance with Lada. To a betting man this has more likelihood of fruition than Fiat/Chrysler knocking up a 3m+ unit/year business in the United States, a US with a terminally busted economy, surviving barely on the life-support of printed money.

obamabeach June 18, 2009 1:02 PM

'focusing westwards'

- focusing eastwards

apologies.

Coot June 18, 2009 2:25 PM

I think it is interesting to compare Vauxhall's current design regime to that of its arch-rival, Ford. To my eyes, the new Astra and Insignia are much more modern, resolved and simply better-looking than the dowdy Focus and the fussy Mondeo. I'm not bothered that, at the limit, either of Ford's cars might drive 10% better than their Vauxhall counterparts; they are 50% worse to look at and that will grate all of the time.

The Focus has never looked as good as its predecessor. The Mondeo manages to look old-fashioned, bland and fussy all at the same time with its Vanden Plas grill and tacky detailing. Even the new Fiesta, which I liked the look of initially, already looks drab - like it's trying too hard with lines all over the place and that nasty chrome strip up the side (more 70s British Leyland). A 5-year old Grande Punto looks at least as modern and a Mazda 2 looks more sharper and cleaner.

But that's enough about Ford....well done Vauxhall!

Will86 June 18, 2009 2:46 PM

Teg, like you I am a fan of the current Astra, and think it is ageing well and still looks very smart. I very much like the new one too though. There are similarities to other cars in its shape, but I don't think this detracts from the design. Looking forward to seeing one in the flesh.

obamabeach June 18, 2009 3:28 PM

The Astra will be an excellent product. GM have sold off the crown jewels. Read this piece by the US editor of Top Gear magazine published in the Washington Post:

news.therecord.com/.../555264

'Today, Opel is not only the progressive face of GM in Europe and Russia, it has been at the forefront of much of the firm's best engineering in the area of alternative -- hybrid, hydrogen fuel cell and battery electric -- powertrains. And following its sale, Opel's engineering team will for the most part remain in Germany. America's love affair with GM's Corvettes, Cadillacs and SUVs notwithstanding, Opel and that team, forged in the crucible of the hypercompetitive European market, today constitute the best, most exciting part of GM overall.

Excise the Opel-derived Chevrolet Malibu and much of the Saturn range (Opels in all but name), and you've deleted the best mainstream cars GM offers in America. Take Opel out of the mix, and you've suddenly charged its North American engineering team -- the people who gave us the Hummer H2 and the Pontiac Aztek, once voted the world's ugliest vehicle -- with building the cars of the future.

Sadly, none of this is an excuse for not admitting the truth about GM: Its potential salvation is in Germany. And General Motors let it get away.'

Now all Magna needs to do is hook-up a deal with Roger Penske to continue supply of Saturn-badged Opels and Magna/Opel/Gaz/AutoVaz?/Saturn? will in two shakes of a lamb's tail be on its way to being a worldwide automaker with c.6m unit presence usurping the old GM and a nascent but stillborn Fiat/Chrysler. Thank god GM had the good sense to go bankrupt and sell off its best bits to those who love autos and the auto industry.

robk77 June 18, 2009 3:33 PM

Blimey Steve, I think you're rather over-egging the pudding with this post. Yes, it's a pleasant enough design but overall the new Astra appears quite Japanese with a lot in common with the previous generation Mazda 3. Certainly no ground breaker but likely to steal plenty of sales from the current Focus.

sitiba June 18, 2009 3:46 PM

Take the Badge off and it could be from any car maker, the two biggest influences in car design now, are Pedestrian legislation and the ability to mould front and rear Lights, also I wonder if design schools do more harm than good for originality.

Uncle Mellow June 18, 2009 7:04 PM

I think the current 3-door car looks really good . This new one looks mostly better than the old 5-door - except for the "A" pillars. Any car with FOUR "A" pillars is a no-no.

Mr_H July 27, 2009 3:30 PM

"The former now has Golf-like grace in its lines"

Golf? Grace? Should have gone to SpecSavers I think!

"also I wonder if design schools do more harm than good for originality"

The problem is not with the design schools; the RCA, Coventry University etc. still turn out some of the most original car designers in the industry. The issue is more with 'customer focus groups', over-proliferation of models, and short-sighted car company CEOs.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - cover 17-3

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>