Sun
Dec 27 2009

Ford Fiesta Mk6 is my Car of the Decade

John McIlroy

Just as the Focus redefined the standards of ride and handling that buyers in its class could expect in 1998, so the latest Ford Fiesta sneaked a new supermini benchmark into the decade just gone, with barely 12 months to spare.

Yes, I know the Fiesta is closely linked to the Mazda 2. But it doesn’t feel like it. Perhaps the 2 is a tiny bit pointier at the front end, but the Fiesta’s steering is still fabulously direct and feelsome. And its ride is sensational; there are cars two classes up from this that don’t have the same ability to soak up the imperfections of British roads.

Vote for your Car of the Decade here

There may be plusher small cars; a Mini feels better-built, for example. And I’m still not 100 per cent convinced about the mobile phone-inspired central console controls. But in terms of dynamics in mass-market, genuinely affordable vehicles, the Ford set new standards so high that, as with the Focus, we could be halfway into the next decade before anyone even matches them.

Achieving that in a market sector that offers bugger-all margins to play with is one of Ford’s finest hours; how this car was beaten to last year’s Car of the Year crown by the Opel/Vauxhall Insignia will always remain a mystery to me.

Mini is my Car of the Decade - Allan Muir

Rolls-Royce Phantom is my Car of the Decade - Steve Cropley

Audi R8 is my Car of the Decade - Matt Prior

 

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About John McIlroy

Used to report on the WRC for Autosport magazine; jumped to Autocar in '05. Career high? Driving McRae's Ford Focus WRC. Career low? Crashing McRae's Ford Focus WRC. Former Autocar news editor, now Whatcar? editor.

Comments

beachland2 December 27, 2009 10:54 PM

Interiors are still a bit cheap looking.

Mini1 December 28, 2009 12:05 AM

The Fiesta? Affordable? Have you SEEN Ford's prices lately?!! Yes, the Fiesta is a great car and it's set a new benchmark, but to me a Polo is better value even if it looks slightly dull. I'm just getting a bit fed up of the Fiesta's popularity - they're everywhere!!

theonlydt December 28, 2009 12:14 AM

A couple of issues with this car:

1. Price. The pricing is getting insane. Yes, I know you can find £2k off without trying, but the best model to me has to be the 1.6 petrol, but the pricing is just too steep (can get a 1.4tsi octavia for that money!).

2. The diesels. Why can't ford offer a "warm" 110bhp version of the diesel? The extra 20bhp, torque and flexibility of that engine would make a fun warm hatch for ~£500 more than the current 1.6 90bhp.

3. These aren't deal breakers, but compare the interior packaging to that of the Jazz. Seats that fold completely flat would be great. Also some of the trim is a bit poor in comparison to the Polo, which now has very nearly identical prices!

Wanger December 28, 2009 12:35 AM

It certainly is a reasonable supermini, and probably the best driving (with Mazda2) small car.

It is however not especilly good value for money and in terms of space/packaging its certainly not the class leader!

11k starting point is about 2k too much for a base supermini...Mazda`s very similiar, ( and in my opinion) better looking 2 starts off at just over 9K with 15bhp advantage over the base Fiesta...And the rest of the Mazda2 range has a similiar price/bhp advantage too!

Mazda2 for me over the Fiesta, with the new Jazz and Skoda Fabia also in with a good shout at best of the rest...Certainly though, I agree that the Fiesta is one of the best supermini`s of the last decade...(Just not totally convinced it was the best all-round choice for its customers? )

TheOmegaMan December 28, 2009 2:54 AM

The Insignia is better

Richard H December 28, 2009 7:09 AM

Its far too expensive

The interior is poor quality

The engines are rough, and not that good (goes for any Ford)

I'm sick of the motoring press being so gushing about anything that Ford produce.

The Fiesta has not redefined anything.

cimardinius December 28, 2009 7:44 AM

I suppose that we should not be surprised at Autocar's journalists putting as many Ford, Land Rover and I presume a Jaguar product in to their "cars of the decade" list.

However, I agree with a previous poster that the Fiesta certainly did not redefine anything, except perhaps the degree of gimmickry of the interior.

Fiat's multi-air engine, VW's twin-clutch gearbox and BMW's stop-start system are, by comparison, real innovations that change the way we drive for the better.

Ford have really not done anything noteworthy in terms of drivetrain or vehicle efficiency in the past decade.

Indeed, if it was not for their access to PSA diesel engines, they would be truly stumbling from a technological point-of-view.

Richard H December 28, 2009 8:47 AM

Exactly

VX220EDDIE December 28, 2009 9:06 AM

the insignia beat the fiesta because it is better  the insignia is so far ahead of the vectra it replaced that it more than deserved the car of the year title   the fiesta is ugly and after visiting a ford showroom to see the fiesta the interior is rubbish as is the rest of the ford range.

jonfortwo December 28, 2009 9:17 AM

"the insignia is so far ahead of the vectra it replaced that it more than deserved the car of the year title "

It wouldn`t have taken much to better the Vectra would it now.

Its testominy to the engineering brilliance of the Fiesta that it does not bring anything new to the party in terms of invention but still manages to redefine class standards.

And if you are that hung up on interior plastics but a Polo.

sportwagon December 28, 2009 9:36 AM

The only thing that the Fiesta redefines is rip-off pricing. A Mazda 3 (not 2) with 1.6 engine and climate control only costs £205 more than a similarly specced Fiesta with 1.4 engine and air-con.

jonfortwo December 28, 2009 9:46 AM

"The only thing that the Fiesta redefines is rip-off pricing."

It would appear that the only people whinging about Fiesta pricing are those that write on here.

I believe the fiesta is still a top seller both here and in europe (and probably the US soon)

miecio December 28, 2009 9:49 AM

polo has better quality, better engines, and more sophisticated technology (like DSG gearbox or TSI engines)

Zeddy December 28, 2009 11:13 AM

"It would appear that the only people whinging about Fiesta pricing are those that write on here.

I believe the fiesta is still a top seller both here and in europe (and probably the US soon)"

The key being those are outwithy the UK and thus have far more realistic pricing structure.

Good car, car of the decade?

Overdrive December 28, 2009 11:35 AM

Ford Fiesta, and indeed the Focus and the Mondeo: all good cars, but among the most overrated cars on the market and chief among the most overzealous Ford overraters are the Autocar writers; this blog being a typiclal case in point.

I've been driving a Focus for the past 3 years, a good car to be sure, but it's nothing special. The new Golf (to take one example) is miles better.

VX220EDDIE December 28, 2009 11:42 AM

jonfortwo December 28, 2009 9:17 AM

"the insignia is so far ahead of the vectra it replaced that it more than deserved the car of the year title "

It wouldn`t have taken much to better the Vectra would it now.

If the vectra is that bad how come it won best estate car of 2007 in what car magazine? have you ever owned a vectra or are you one of these people who listen to others without making a decision for yourself! i for one owned a vectra and liked it however my point was the insignia is a much better car!  everyone is ready to down vauxhall and praise ford its so annoying!

Lanehogger December 28, 2009 12:14 PM

If memory serves me right, when Autocar tested the Fiesta in 2008 it was only just class best ahead of its rivals so how on earth can it be car of the decade?

I have no doubt it is the best car in its class, but not by the huge margin it is portrayed to be. Some marques better in some areas such as refinement, perfomance and interior quality.

And while Ford has been taking an absolute panning with it interior quality, i have to agree with many comments. The Fiesta has a great design but some of the worse quality plastics in the class, and the same can be said with all Fords. Brilliantly built, but cheap feeling. Same can be said about the Insignia though which is worse than a Mondeo.

And with mainstream marques falling of the radar at an alarming rate for many punters, is it not time for the likes of Vauxhall and Ford to start going back to cheap and cheerful like they did in the 1980s and early 90s.

superstevie December 28, 2009 12:46 PM

Vectra estate won hatcar best estate for 2 reasons. 1. it is a huge car. 2. whatcar rate cars that are dull very highly.

As for Mazda 2 being better price/bhp, that may be true, and it is a good looking car. However, the interior is shockingly poor.

For me, the fiesta is probably one of the best small cars there is. Ok a Jazz may be more practical, but I don't want practical, I want fun. And I think, as it is explained very well in the article, that its not about practicality or the quailty of the interior, it is about the balance of the ride/handling that betters other cars, even ones that are more expensive.

Would I buy one? depends on money/finance etc as it does for me with any car I look at. Its why I drive a smart and not an iQ. Smart more fun than the more practical, more expensive to finance, and probably better car

kcrally December 28, 2009 12:49 PM

or the peugeot 206

Wanger December 28, 2009 1:18 PM

Superstevie baby...The articles about, "The car of the decade" Yes ride/handling is a factor in the decision on what is the car of the decade but not an over-riding factor (IMO) neither is outright performance,refinement, value for money, packaging,interior ergonomics or quality and fit/finnish...However surely the car of the decade has to be fairly outstanding in its sector,reasonably accessable and provide the future direction too other makes and models...possible radicality and automotive direction leadership?

Are you sure that a Mazda2`s interior is shockingly poor...Why? Do you physically have to take a measure of brandy to calm yourself down after looking into its interior?

Being objective, the 2`s a very well constructed/reliable small car with a more than acceptable interior on par with its Fiesta derivative...It is however 2k on average cheaper than the Ford and more in line with what a supermini should cost new in my humble opinion...Its Japanese qualities offer it something a little different over its Euro competition...Its still not my car of the decade though!

A smarts ride/handling mixture aint too great, its radical as a 4wheeled moped...But its not sufficiently good enough to be car of the decade! The Toyota IQ is too expensive(should have had a Lexus badge?) but has more of a shout in my view at Car of the Decade than the Smart....

jammy_rex December 28, 2009 3:18 PM

I find this faintly ridiculous!  yes a Fiesta may ride and steer nicely, but apart from that has distinctly average engines, debatable quality, cheap interior, not particular space efficient, average/poor residuals... and that interior design, inspired by mobile phones (oh dear) will become outmoded and dated as quickly as the average previous year's mobile phone!  I find the pro Ford reviews in this magazine quite tiresome, my own private money would never go into a Ford!

rtwingo December 28, 2009 6:29 PM

It's impressive how much better a car can get by simply changing the symbol from "Mazda" to "Ford"...

Not that it's the only change, but please - it's hard to argue that the Fiesta is considerably better than the 2.

And Mazda being the source for the platform and basic design - the 2 is, to my opinion, the one worthy of any accolade (if any of the two cars is worthy, anyway).

superstevie December 28, 2009 6:49 PM

"Superstevie baby"

hahahah thats made me giggle!

"Are you sure that a Mazda2`s interior is shockingly poor...Why? Do you physically have to take a measure of brandy to calm yourself down after looking into its interior?"

I don't drink brandy, I prefer a beer, or baileys, or maybe even ameretto. Of course not while driving lol

But seriously, I went and had a look at the mazda 2 recently and it was god awful in there. Its ashame because I like the rest of the car, think it looks really good, especially compared to the dull as ditch water Polo, cheshire cat grinning 207 or the mono box Jazz.

I do agree that the Fiesta is probably not worthy of car of the decade, just that the reason it was picked by John was the ride/handling compromise compared to the competition.

1cfc1 December 28, 2009 7:12 PM

Good choice but surely you mean "Fiesta Mk7"

The Mk6 was the last generation model.

cimardinius December 28, 2009 7:35 PM

"...surely you mean "Fiesta Mk7?"

It doesn't really matter. The autocar word processor has a built-in macro that produces the phrase "class-leading" in any paragraph that the word "Ford" appears in.

So, some release model of Fiesta, Mondeo, Focus or even Transit van over the last decade has to be declared "car of the decade" - whether its the Fiesta Mk 6 or Mk 7 is broadly irrelevant.

However, as others have pointed out, naming a car "car of the decade" solely on a subjective asessement of its ride and/or handling is the most fragile of faint praise.

Jim Holder December 28, 2009 8:05 PM

While you argue it out, can I remind you that it's your vote, not ours that counts. These blogs are one person's opinion - and you can cast your vote via this story:

www.autocar.co.uk/.../245686

TheWizardWeb December 29, 2009 11:10 AM

Having owned a mk6 for a year and used a mk5 as a loan during service, I can honestly say the new car is waaaaaaay beyond the previous model. The interior is not cheap looking and I've had no quality problems inside the car. However, although the interior was based round a "mobile phone", I think it's now a bit out of date as mobiles have gone touch screen, so my iPhone has made a number of features on the car redundant. The issues I have had are regarding the electronics, fuses blowing regularly, both headlamp bulbs have gone, the alarm was a bit crazy in the cold last year, but to their credit, the dealer has been very helpful and efficient at sorting it all out.

i do think it's one of the best cars of the last 2 years but I'm struggling to think of the definitive car of the decade though.

rtwingo December 29, 2009 8:44 PM

"Good choice but surely you mean 'Fiesta MK7'"

No, he's right, the current Fiesta is the MK6.

softlove010 February 27, 2010 6:31 PM

hello dear friend

How are you today , i know that all is well with you

My name is Gift ,I am a female,I was impressed when i saw your profile  and will like to establishe a long lasting relationship with you. In addition,i will like you to reply me through my private e mail box here is it;(giftbaby09@yahoo.com) Thanks waiting to hear from you soonest.

Gift

Please contact me with my Email address here is it.(giftbaby09@yahoo.com)

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - cover 8.2.12

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>