Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Thu
Jul 10 2008

The perfect car?

Matt Prior

If you could drive one car – just one, mind – for the rest of your life, what would it be?  

Tricky, isn’t it? First of all, let’s discount anything practical. I know, I know. If I actually had to choose one car forever, it would need to be big enough for a family, have a tow-bar and respectable economy. But that would be boring, so for the purposes of this blog, boring is banned. Let’s imagine you can teleport your kids or, like a B-list celebrity’s wedding, you have a fleet of Audi A8s on-hand to ferry people and things hither and thither. Leaving you to drive what you like.

So, what’s it to be? Type 35 Bugatti? McLaren F1? Caterham 7?

Me? I’ll have a Porsche Cayman please. We’ve group tested one in the 9 July issue, against an Audi TT and a BMW 135i and it wins convincingly. Which is no great surprise.

The surprise is still just how good the Porsche feels when you drive it. It’s not perfect, but it’s about as close as cars get these days.

If one were to be mine forever, it would need a bit more power, a six-speed ‘box (so long as it shifts as sweetly as the five-speeder), a limited-slip differential and perhaps a couple of mods here and there to make it a bit more GT3-like, while not making it too harsh. A suede-rimmed wheel, beefier seats, that sort of thing, though I’d still like a stereo and air-con, thanks.

It is a really brilliant thing. The sort of car that’s at home on a hack up to Scotland as it is a night out in town or a thrash on a track day. Its breadth of ability is rare indeed.

You may, of course, beg to differ. After all, an F40 outside the house every morning would be pretty compelling...

 

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Matt Prior

Has an automotive engineering degree and a Triumph TR2; once raced go karts, now keeps chickens. Adores tiny cars and big motorbikes. Is currently running the road test desk.

Comments

David Harrington-Wright July 10, 2008 4:20 PM

Well for me the new XKR-S would do just fine, and as i don't have kids, or much stuff to ferry around, can you arrange one for this weekend! Thanks!

65 AMG July 10, 2008 4:32 PM

Well i haven't got any kids and i hardly ever carry even a jacket so i guess i'll the Merc CL63 Black pls.

kerrecoe July 10, 2008 4:34 PM

My best-mate just got his first Aston, a James Bond Silver DB9 (jammy sod). It follows a CLK500 Convertible and before that a Maserati 4200GT. I'd be happy to spend the rest of my life with any of them to be honest. The Merc is still totally beautiful. An XKR would go down very well indeed. Can we carpool? :-)

theoriginalshoe July 10, 2008 5:08 PM

Okay, so Nadal beat Federer on the short green stuff (eventually).  But to me, the Fed will always be the best because it's the WAY he wins: with grace, poise and effortlessness.

Why the tangent?  So the Veyron gets the job done, but it's all forced induction, aggression and beastly looks.  The McLaren F1 will always be the greatest, so it is my choice.

Beowolf July 10, 2008 5:28 PM

Good question, and interesting choice!  Having never driven one... and that might be the problem.  How to compare?  

I always loved the look and acclaimed 'go' of the 288 GTO.  Beautiful car.  The original Daytona was also fab looking.

Otherwise... McLaren F1.  Light, powerful, great handling, and weekend racer par excellence.  Ticks my boxes ;-0)   Which car do you think is an 'affordable' F1...?

julianphillips July 10, 2008 5:51 PM

Well, I have a baby boy and although the McLaren F1 isn't my all time favourite, the fact that it has 3 seats would make it my default choice of dream car because everything else only has 2!!  Not sure I could fit a pram in the boot though (if it has one).

Nozwald July 10, 2008 6:17 PM

Depends on your definition of perfect I guess.  McLaren is amazing but for me the perfect car has to be Morgan AeroMax.  It's so dramatic in every way ... even when it's standing still. It's the most elegant piece of automotive sculpture I've ever seen this side of an e-type. And it goes like the clappers! Ultimate allrounder.

James Read July 10, 2008 6:54 PM

RANGE ROVER

trackdemon July 10, 2008 9:25 PM

Its funny Matt, every time I read of 'best sportcar' or somesuch be it in Autocar or any number of other tomes the Cayman is almost always put forward as the prime nominee....

Thing is though, I've driven maybe 1000miles in a Cayman S now and I just dont see it - its almost as though the thing is just too polished, to the point where some of the character has gone with it. In pure road test terms I can see that its hard to fault: its well built, comfortable, quick enough, handles very nicely etc.... but to own one car for the rest of days? Well I want it to put an indelible  smile on my face each and every time and the Cayman just hasn't got that big a personality.

Me? I'll take a 997GT3 please. As its forever I'll take it with the comfort pack, white with black/red interior ;-) Simply the best all round sportscar I've had the priviledge of driving, it delivers on every level. Its properly useable too - the great driving position puts it ahead of most other sportscars straight away - but it has that slightly malevolent edge to its character that is essential in a pure sportscar. Simply wonderful. Oh, and it looks the b0ll0x too.... ;-)

www.trackdemon.co.uk/.../Porsche_997_GT3_2007-01-25_DSC_0034-01.jpgb

Heavensdevil July 10, 2008 10:36 PM

Porsche Boxer RS60 Spyder.

Old guy, single, and living in North America (land of restricted speed limits & high insurance rates). Car has basic looks, nice sound, great handling at a fair price, and this one covers all my basics without worrying about it.

airgith76 July 11, 2008 4:33 PM

One car?.....It would have to be the McLaren F1 just for that engine alone.

mspeedscuderia July 14, 2008 12:18 PM

the ford gt for me pls? one of the sexiest cars out there

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Autocar 19 Nov

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>