Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Wed
Mar 26 2008

Backwards the revolution, comrade

Mike Duff

I suffered a serious moment of disbelief this morning while driving to work, and listening to union boss Tony Woodley doing all he could to pour cold water over Tata’s purchase of Jaguar and Land Rover.

I probably shouldn’t have been surprised. Woodley is general secretary of the Unite union and his view of the world was formed while working at Vauxhall’s Ellesmere plant during the 1970s. Back then Britain’s strike-prone car factories were a byword for terrible industrial relations and it’s clear that even thirty years later he thinks that every question is one of ‘us and them’.

But on a day to show the world a united face, Woodley’s lukewarm support for the deal – including telling the BBC it was a “sad day for British industry” - comes across as a deliberate snub towards Tata, especially as union approval for the deal was a key aim of the negotiators.

Woodley should have more respect for his members and their interests – fundamental to which is surely a strong company. The latest attack is entirely in character, though – Woodley has conspicuously failed to criticise the increasingly punitive taxation being directed at the luxury saloons and 4x4s being produced by his members.

Maybe Woodley would have been happier with independence for Jag and Land Rover – just like MG Rover. But that story didn’t end very happily, did it?

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Mike Duff

The incoming editor of autocar.co.uk started life in radio news, but found doorstepping bereaved mothers too much like hard work and opted to scribble about cars instead. He joined Autocar in 2007 and reckons that big-engined diesels are the future.

Comments

rogerthedodger March 27, 2008 9:57 AM

You would have thought Tony Woodley would know that "Britain" sold Jaguar in 1990 and Land-Rover in 1994.

Perhaps you could preface any quoted comment from Woodley in the future as "Dave Spart" says

Quattro369 March 27, 2008 12:00 PM

Agree totally. The most important thing is that both companies continue function and build cars in britain. Had a private equity firm got hold of them, they would have asset stripped, sacked most the workforce and shipped production out to the far-east before selling them on for a handsome profit. Somone should remind him that his job is now safe for at least the next 5 years. Surely thats what is important?

RobotBoogie March 27, 2008 2:03 PM

I'm a bit mystified myself at the overwhelming welcome being given to Tata and am adopting more of a wait-and-see approach that is perhaps closer to Tony Woodley's position. Tata has, after all, borrowed to buy JLR, saddling it with huge debt from the outset, which is not that different from the position under Ford. Plus, as any long term motor industry watcher will tell you, the guarantees made in terms of British jobs and factories are likely to evaporate the moment the figures don't stack up. It might all go well; equally, it might be Rover all over again.

loather March 27, 2008 4:31 PM

Quattro369 March 27, 2008 12:00 PM wrote:

"Somone should remind him that his[Tony Woodley] job is now safe for at least the next 5 years."

Quattro369, Woodley is the head of Unite what was the T&G(TGWU) and has nothing to do with being employed at Jag/LR.  His 'directest' interest in seeing 15,000 odd jobs kept at JLR is the union subs that eventually pay his tasty £100k+ remuneration. Get a grip.

RobotBoogie's right, the five year guarantee thing before major changes/off-shoring/plant closures is a PR spin. I understand it to be 2011 before major changes can be made, which is as little as 33 months away not 60. Plus Ratan Tata, the boss, has pledged himself only 'to try his best to build on the two marques' heritage'. Note 'try to', a classic get-out if it goes pear-shaped.

I believe that in the very short term Jaguar is threatened, due to its unsustainable low output and consequent high losses. Some deal may be done by Tata with Fiat. Land Rover's not out of the woods either in the medium term as nearly all its powertrain competence now comes from Jaguar/Ford and its desperate need to reduce the weight of its vehicles was residing again in Jag's lightweight alloy body construction expertise. If Jag gets spun off by Tata to Fiat, LR may be exposed in its lack of core engineering competence disguised hitherto by the Jag/Ford hook-up.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Autocar 26 Nov

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>